2 ms·
Sorry, but this is flat out wrong. The Tsar Bomba was a 100 MT bomb, period. It was capable of being used in 50 MT configurations but there was absolutely, pos
by InclinedPlane 15y ago
Sorry, but this is flat out wrong.
The Tsar Bomba was a 100 MT bomb, period. It was capable of being used in 50 MT configurations but there was absolutely, positively zero chance that the 100 MT configuration would not work. Additionally, the 100 MT version would not have been a significantly different weight or size.
The reason for the 50 MT / 100 MT difference is that such weapons use a mix of fission and fusion reactions. In a thermonuclear weapon you can use natural Uranium (U-238) as a jacket around the fusion fuel capsule. While U-238 doesn't normally participate in a fission chain reaction it will fission when under high neutron flux and as it turns out fusion bombs generate enormous amounts of neutrons. Thus typical thermonuclear weapons leverage the fusion reactions to drive fission reactions and boost yield enormously, resulting in most of the energy from a "thermonuclear" weapon ultimately coming from fission reactions.
The downside of this is that fission reactions are very dirty. And in the case of the Tsar Bomba design that meant that testing the design at a full 100 MT yield would result in 50 MT worth of nuclear fission fallout being spread across the Soviet Union (and ultimately the world of course). Which is rather quite a lot of fallout. By replacing the jackets around the 3rd stage fusion fuel capsules with different materials that do not undergo fission the result is that the fusion reactions still proceed, and the bomb still releases 50 MT of energy, but very little energy comes from fission (the primary, parts of the secondary and the spark plugs in the tertiary stages), massively reducing fallout.
The part about the pilots not having enough time to get to a safe distance from a 100 MT explosion is true, but aside from that had the Soviets wanted to they could have done a 100 MT test of Tsar Bomba quite readily.
- ThaddeusQuay2 15y agoThanks for the correction, and the explanation. I recalled reading the following in the Wikipedia article, but forgot about it as I was writing the comment, while trying to juggle several other things. "The initial three-stage design was capable of yielding the power of approximately 100 Mt, but would have caused too much radioactive fallout. To limit fallout, the third stage and possibly the second stage had a lead tamper instead of a uranium-238 fusion tamper (which greatly amplifies the reaction by fissioning uranium atoms with fast neutrons from the fusion reaction). This eliminated fast fission by the fusion-stage neutrons, so that approximately 97% of the total energy resulted from fusion alone (as such, it was one of the "cleanest" nuclear bombs ever created, generating a very low amount of fallout relative to its yield). There was a strong incentive for this modification since most of the fallout from a test of the bomb would have ended up on populated Soviet territory." Also, if you have the time, I'd like your opinion on what I said about atmospheric focusing. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3626601 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3626601
- InclinedPlane 15y agoAtmospheric focusing is a pretty inefficient process, on top of the existing inefficiencies of massive nuclear weapons it's probably not worthwhile to use as a weapon. It's a lot easier to send conventional bombs or bullets to Finland if you want to break windows there than to use multi-megaton bombs thousands of miles away. The main reason you build big bombs is (aside from the arms race / show boating aspect) to destroy important targets with inaccurate delivery systems. The other reason to build big bombs is to intentionally create fallout, which could be used in a "doomsday" weapon, possibly as a MAD deterrent. If you exploded a 1,000 MT nuke on a containership in international waters off the coast of Europe or North America and you took advantage of the prevailing winds you could do devastating damage to the population, agriculture, etc.