5 ms·
We trade with lots of creatures and living things. Like bees. We give them a hive and protection, and they give us honey. The same with all sorts of vegetation
by WalterBright 3y ago
We trade with lots of creatures and living things. Like bees. We give them a hive and protection, and they give us honey.
The same with all sorts of vegetation.
Flora and fauna often have co-dependent relationships, too.
- TZubiri 3y agoThis. Bees are very closely related to ants. We also trade with Wasps, which hunt other pests. And wasps are basically winged ants
- actuallyalys 3y agoI suppose the "cats domesticated themselves" theory could be thought of as a trade that cats initiated. For people not familiar, the idea is that cats hung around human grain stores because they were good places to catch mice and similar prey attracted to the grain and humans tolerated them because they drove away the pests.
- valval 3y agoThis still assumes some form of consciousness of the merit of the exchange for the humans viewed from the cats’ point of view. The cats found a place with a lot of mice, and hung around. Humans tolerated them, but not for any reasons the cats would have the capability to comprehend.
- WalterBright 3y agoCats will give caught mice as gifts to their owners.
- lancebeet 3y agoI would argue that's not really a trade, at least not in the sense described in the article, since it lacks awareness and consent from one party. The bees never agree to the trade of providing us honey in exchange for the hive and protection, and most likely see no connection between the two events. They simply stay in a hive they have found while it's convenient for them, and when their honey is unexpectedly taken from them they will survive on sugar water that they conveniently find outside the hive.
- klipt 3y agoHoneyguides, the birds, definitely trade with us (well, with the local populations who co-evolved with and understand them)
- WalterBright 3y agoCrows will often give "gifts" to humans in exchange for treats.
- svnt 3y ago> They simple stay in a hive they have found > they will survive on sugar water This is not how beekeeping usually works. 1) Honeybees are typically divided into hives and do not choose. 2) You cannot sustain an overexploited hive on sugar water — they will starve. It may help in a situation where nectar flow is lacking though.
- jenadine 3y agoThis is not trade, it's more like slavery. That would be like in the "The Matrix" movie.
- hollerith 3y agoWe trade with bees mainly because at the current level of human technology, it is the most efficient reliable way to pollenate some of our crops. The fear with AI is that it will become able to wield tech that is much more advanced than the tech we can wield. If our tech were much more advanced, using our tech to pollenate our crops would more efficient and reliable than using bees (or we would ditch the crops in favor of more efficient ways of producing food) and the future existence of the bees would be in doubt if humans did not have a fondness for the natural environment and no one knows how to put a fondness for humans (or for nature) in an AI despite the fact that this has been an ongoing research area since 2004 when Eliezer published his CEV proposal. We used to rely on horses for transportation and for plowing fields, but we replaced them with tech almost entirely. Horse are still useful to some (wealthy) people, but it would be foolish to put our hope in the possibility that AI will benefit from humans the way that humans continue to benefit from horses. More precisely, if someone does know how to put a fondness for humans in an AI they are not sharing their knowledge with us (and they have an incentive to and no incentive that I can see not to share). Dozens have proposed schemes that do not continue to work once the AI becomes smart enough to deceive humans reliably and to plan much better than humans can. Confidence in these schemes that do not work and overconfidence in the AI community's ability to come up with a working scheme is the main source of the danger we are in. It is not that our scientists are incapable of coming up with a scheme that works, but that will probably takes decades (because of the sequential nature of science wherein no one can find insight Z till someone finds and shares with the community insight Y, which in turn must wait on the publication of insight X) so we are faced with the difficult task of preventing the overconfident AI researchers from killing us all till we figure out how to put a fondness for humans in an AI.
- erikerikson 3y agoMechanical pollination is more reliable, just not more efficient: https://firmanpollen.com/ https://firmanpollen.com/