3 ms·
IANAL but as far as I know, if you think you've found some kind of technicality or gotcha in a legal letter or email that means you can ignore it, you're probab
by jeroenhd 3y ago
IANAL but as far as I know, if you think you've found some kind of technicality or gotcha in a legal letter or email that means you can ignore it, you're probably wrong.
Ignoring the legal process can result in seized domains and servers, services being taken down, lawyers obtaining all kinds of personal information through the courts, and other stuff that gets very expensive very quickly. I doubt that this person will be extradited for making a Youtube frontend, but fighting Google can be certified Not Fun.
If you're going to ignore a cease and desist, consider getting legal advice from an expert with relevant knowledge first. They will tell you what can and cannot happen if you ignore letters like these. Perhaps they can word your protest in a more legalese form that Google will need to respond to if it wants to actually pursue the matter; it's certainly possible that getting actual lawyers involved to overthrow a realistic defence will be too much for Google to actually care. Youtubers certainly seem to get the velvet glove treatment after their message exchange with Youtube representatives mention lawyers.
There are probably ways in which the project can be defended (for example, if it really doesn't use the API in any way I don't believe it can be subject to their terms and conditions) but "you used the wrong opening for your email" and "Invidious *is*." isn't it.
- AnonCoward42 3y ago(IANAL) You are likely right, however this is not some minor technicality, but the basis of their cease and desist. 1. Not using their API therefore not bound by their TOS 2. Wrong recipient 3. invidious.io isn't offering the service It's possible that ignoring this is the best answer, but in any case consulting a lawyer is recommended.
- pjerem 3y agoWell, to be honest, for now, he would be in a better position by having just ignored the mail. In France, an e-mail have no legal value. You can just argue that you never received it. That’s why any legal document must be send via tracked physical mail. However, it starts to have a value if you somehow admit to have received it. Most of the times it’s by answering, and here it’s because the receiver wrote a public blog post about it. Also, France doesn’t extradite its citizens. It doesn’t mean that no action is possible but Google will have to sue him in a French court for violating the French laws. Idk if he can be sued for violating the French law but I myself would totally ignore that e-mail. Maybe you can talk about it to your lawyer I you feel that can escalate but nothing else.
- moffkalast 3y agoDMCA requests are also as valid as some words written with crayon on toilet paper in the EU, unless they're explicitly sent as an ECD request.
- lrvick 3y agoI have ignored plenty of CADs and threats from lawyers over decades. Sometimes I work on open source stuff that pisses people off. Lawyers know all they can do is bark in cases like these.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoIf you're american they can bankrupt you by forcing you to pay a lawyer to defend you in court. Not sure if France is in that category but there are countries out there where corporations can't abuse the legal process to bully people into submission. Where I live they can't get away with that since citizens have a right to legal representation, there's no "speedy trials" to minimize their own costs and they could be ordered to pay for all costs if they lose.
- thumbuddy 3y agoHappens all the time.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoImagine being extradited because you wrote a free software replacement for YouTube's shitty frontend. Surely the justice system cannot be this out of touch.
- jfengel 3y agoThe "justice" system is indeed that out of touch. Every lawyer everywhere will concur that the only "justice" they can deal with is implementing the law. Actual justice plays zero part in it. Lawyers want to be programmers. They are as bad at it is programmers are at the law. The best you can hope for is that your own lawyer can make the law work for you. That is manifestly unjust but all of the other options are even worse. Start by putting any notion of fairness, compassion, or awareness on their part out of your mind, just as you would when debugging a program.
- rosmax_1337 3y agoWhy do you use the abbreviation IANAL to open your post? I know what it means, I'm curious as to why you use it.