5 ms·
As long as fewer humans and dogs die from autonomous vehicles than by human-driven vehicles, they are a net good. Don't expect perfection when we don't even exp
by satvikpendem 3y ago
As long as fewer humans and dogs die from autonomous vehicles than by human-driven vehicles, they are a net good. Don't expect perfection when we don't even expect that from humans.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoAt this point we don't know if this is subtractive, additive, or a wash.
- MattGaiser 3y agoHow many people would normally be killed in the same distance driven by human drivers?
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoIt can't just be the same distance, but the same parameters in general.
- williamcotton 3y agoLess than 1 fatality per at least 100 million miles driven would cover enough scenarios to be an acceptable metric as well as an improvement over human drivers.
- vba616 3y agoI think I remember that a ballpark figure (meaning zero significant figures) for how many miles a human typically drives between fatalities is 100 million, or roughly 100 lifetimes' worth. I also knew a bus driver who had a plaque for going 1 million miles without an accident.
- radq 3y agoAs someone that rides a bicycle around human-driven vehicles, I will take my chances with autonomous cars. The autonomous car isn't going to drive drunk, use a phone, or drive erratically because the driver is feeling frustrated.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoAre they training autonomous cars on how to handle equipment malfunction?
- sour-taste 3y agoFirst of all, probably. These cars have far more sensors and far more monitoring than standard cars so they know when things go wrong quickly and can react quickly (by like pulling over). At the current scale of self driving cars actually being tested right now it's basically guaranteed that a tire has blown by now. Given we haven't heard about it killing someone it probably means that the software knows how to handle it. Second, human error accounted for >90% of accidents [1]. Focusing on that fraction first makes sense. 1] https://www.cbmclaw.com/what-percentage-of-car-accidents-are-caused-by-human-error/ https://www.cbmclaw.com/what-percentage-of-car-accidents-are...
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoI'm just wondering what happens as these cars get older. Right now they are all young, and presumably regularly and well maintained. I presume they'll be engineered to the same standards as conventional vehicles, which means chronic issues popping up.
- pavlov 3y agoDoes the same logic apply to wars? Should we give over warfare to AIs to conduct between themselves, as long as fewer humans and dogs die on average compared to current human-led imperfect wars. (This by the way is the plot of a 1960s Star Trek episode. A lot of the old sci-fi suddenly seems prescient again. HAL-9000 behaves like an LLM.)
- satvikpendem 3y agoYes? Why wouldn't it apply to wars as well if it's a net positive for human suffering?
- pavlov 3y agoWould you really have an AI make independent decisions about missile strikes and warship deployments? If one AI decides to invade Taiwan and another decides to send all American forces to the Taiwan Strait in opposition, are we supposed to accept the outcome without debate because it’s somehow statistically correct based on the information captured by the models that made the decisions?
- satvikpendem 3y agoYou said the AIs conducts warfare amongst themselves, you never mentioned it was human troops it was moving around. I interpreted it as AI robotic troops or AI cyberwarfare. And yes, even with human troops, if fewer people are killed, then what's the issue? Don't mistake the sense of control for the amount of suffering caused. If you're a utilitarian, only one matters, regardless of how much control we want to exert on the outcome. This all assumes the AI is actually correct, if it's not then the scenario would break down.
- anonymouskimmer 3y agoLocus of control (real or perceived) has important psychological effects both in the moment and over the course of time. Given the amount of control wielded in war I don't know that it matters for the bulk of humans involved whether its another human or an AI giving the orders. But this sort of thing is what led to the Eloi/Morlock idea in The Time Machine. Edit to add: I'm not drawing a parallel between the Eloi and autonomous vehicles. Autonomous vehicles are a tool that the human passenger is ultimately in control of. This is about AI giving the orders to humans.
- vba616 3y ago>As long as fewer humans and dogs die from autonomous vehicles than by human-driven vehicles, they are a net good There is a logical chasm between pointing to an accident prevented by superhuman reflexes/abilities, and the claim that there is a net improvement in driving ability. It seems beyond a reasonable doubt that autonomous vehicles can avoid some accidents that a human could not. But you can understand why that isn't proof of a net benefit, can't you? Think about how men complain about women supposedly being terrible drivers, and how studies show that women are more at risk in a crash, yet insurance rates for women are lower.
- satvikpendem 3y agoI'm not sure what you're saying exactly, why is that not proof of a net benefit? If fewer humans die, that's a net benefit, by the definition of the word net. In your man/woman analogy, I'm not sure what studies you're referring to, but how men feel about women driving is not really a motivator for actuaries at insurance companies who have statistics on male versus female accidents.
- anonymouskimmer 3y ago> why is that not proof of a net benefit? Autonomous vehicles may be more prone to certain types of lethal accidents that humans aren't prone to. Autonomous vehicles may lead to more hours/miles driven, so even if deaths per mile driven are lower, the deaths per person may increase. Unknown physical or cognitive health effects of being a passenger versus being an active driver. Just off the top of my head. Fingers are crossed that autonomous vehicles won't lead to an increase in animal deaths. The roads are bad enough for them as is. I'm hopeful that convoying autonomous vehicles for long trips may be a benefit here.
- satvikpendem 3y agoSure, I suppose we should take all of those factors into consideration when crafting our utility function.
- vba616 3y ago
- MarcoZavala 3y ago[dead]