3 ms·
The existence of that self-identification by a small minority of people is an objective fact. But what does that have to do with how the rest of society—medical
by rayiner 3y ago
The existence of that self-identification by a small minority of people is an objective fact. But what does that have to do with how the rest of society—medical professionals, schools, etc.—uses the terminology?
Are you saying terminology isn’t important? It sounds like you think it’s very important.
- tptacek 3y agoAccording to a UCLA survey, over 1.6MM trans people live in the US. According to Iceland, 6,492 Icelanders live in the US. If you tried to tell someone "only a small minority of people identify as Icelanders", they'd look at you like a space alien.
- defrost 3y agoLeaving aside the thorny gender issues, ~6,000 in a population of > 300 million is literally a small minority.
- elcritch 3y agoThey'd probably look at you like you were an alien because most people would say either you're Icelandic or you're not. Even if you were a naturalized Icelander they'd probably also say "oh but you're really American" etc if they learned you were naturalized.
- rayiner 3y agoBoth are small minorities if you’re talking about definitions of labels that apply to all 8 billion people on the planet. If Icelanders’ self-identified as Asian and people were coming up with new terms when they needed to refer specifically to “asians from the continent of Asia” that would be a parallel example.
- jfengel 3y agoThe comment that I replied to praised them for not playing semantics and word games. I agree that terminology is important. So it sounds like you're disagreeing with the OP and should mention it to them.