3 ms·
> He says the difference comes from a different cultural perspective. It's been a long time since I read it, but I'll try to summarize it with the Chinese persp
by TeMPOraL 3y ago
> He says the difference comes from a different cultural perspective. It's been a long time since I read it, but I'll try to summarize it with the Chinese perspective was that phenomena could not be modeled. Everything was a unique creation. I.e. the behavior of a model could not be extrapolated to explain other behaviors, while the European perspective was always trying to explain things with models.
This makes me believe Diamond over Roberts even more. I don't think cultural philosophical beliefs matter that much. They can be arbitrary and stick around for long if they don't make much of a difference in daily lives - but anything that does make a difference will get more accurate with time rather quickly. This is to say, humans aren't dumb - and because of that, economics is stronger than faith or custom.
> My own observation of history is that the key factor is recognition of and protection of the rights of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness produce massive technological progress and the uplifting of society.
I'm a much less experienced observer, but my current view is that... it's mostly the other way around. Life, liberty and pursuit of happiness is the kind of stuff that mostly flows from people's emotions and social intuitions. People try to pursue those naturally. How far they go is determined by their economic situation - Ancient Rome afforded for different levels of "life, liberty and pursuit of happiness" than early agrarian settlements did; different still than what was possible in Feudal Europe, and different from what was possible after the Industrial Revolution.
Technological progress reshapes the economical landscape, allowing people to achieve more "life, liberty and pursuit of happiness". Specialization of labor, agriculture optimization, the printing press, industrialization, engines, washing machines, electricity - all created conditions that allowed people having more rights, liberty and happiness than they could've before.
- WalterBright 3y ago> Specialization of labor, agriculture optimization, the printing press, industrialization, engines, washing machines, electricity - all created conditions that allowed people having more rights, liberty and happiness than they could've before. Sorry, but this is exactly backwards :-) In the US, the rights came first. Note that the states that still practiced slavery failed at industrialization, specialization, etc.
- gregjor 3y agoThe Founders of the United States did not invent the rights you refer to. They had thousands of years of western history to cherry-pick ideas from. The states in the north had slavery too, just not an economy heavily based on slavery. By the time of the American Revolution slavery was already on the way out in Europe, practiced in plantations in the New World but not at home. The ancient Athenians and Romans believed in inherent rights of life, liberty, happiness, freedom too, just not for everyone.
- WalterBright 3y ago> The Founders of the United States did not invent the rights you refer to. You're right, those rights are inalienable characteristics of humans. However, the US was the first to codify them into the founding document of a nation. The states in the North had all ended slavery by 1804. Prosperity followed.
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> The states in the North had all ended slavery by 1804. Prosperity followed. And so did the Industrial Revolution. What's the causal mechanism that puts codifying the rights you mention, and quest for happiness, before prosperity? With industrialization, the possible mechanism is much more clear for it being the source of both prosperity and the ability for US to keep those rights codified over longer periods of time.
- WalterBright 3y agoIndustrialization only happened in free societies that recognized those rights. Yes, I know about the forced industrialization in the USSR, but that failed to really deliver much to the civilians. It was mostly focused on military production. The US industrialization was so far ahead it provided not only the highest standard of living in the world, but enabled the US to fight simultaneous wars in both hemispheres, while supplying its allies (including the Soviet Union) with vast quantities of industrial products. > is much more clear Again, the industrialization of America happened after the rights were guaranteed, and only in the parts of America that were free.