3 ms·
A thread on the deterioration of accessibility in GTK4 and Wayland
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- LeoPanthera 3y agoYou can click the "eyeball" icon in the top-right to expand every post at once.
- _dain_ 3y agofuck i got all the way to the bottom expanding them one by one and then tabbed over and read this. is it some practical joke? why not just label it
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- doubled112 3y agoLabels are bad. Just a barely visible icon off to the side with no description is the way.
- pjmlp 3y agoA certain irony on a accessibility discussion thread.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- develatio 3y agoAny reason why everything is "hidden" by default? It's imho a very unfriendly UX (which is quite ironic coming from a thread criticising "GUI")
- LeoPanthera 3y agoThis decision is made by the author of the post in question.
- jchw 3y agoI'm surprised GTK/GNOME has had issues with accessibility deteriorating; it always seemed like they had the best story for it, and I expect Fedora and Ubuntu to care about it. Unfortunately, it's hard to be surprised that if anything would deteriorate, it's accessibility, either. But while I understand it's not the point of this thread, which is probably mostly venting, maybe it'd be a good idea to focus here on trying to find what can be improved. I'd definitely be willing to sponsor work on improving accessibility in Wayland and Linux in general, patron-style. It'd be nice to have serious effort put into the protocols the way that we are seeing attention put into color profiles and HDR right now.
- lmz 3y agoI thought it was Sun who mostly paid for the accessibility improvements for GNOME 2: https://mail.gnome.org/archives/foundation-list/2010-February/msg00019.html https://mail.gnome.org/archives/foundation-list/2010-Februar... With them gone I guess the rest don't care as much.
- suby 3y agoI believe we need to bypass all of these bespoke accessibility solutions and use machine learning to visually parse a live feed of your computer screen. We should be able to take a given screenshot and determine where the buttons are, what the text is, and make something that is decently workable. Then we won't need to care about each app, each website, each operating system supporting accessibility standards because our accessibility tools will be using the computer in the same manner that humans do, visually decoding a live feed of images. Easier said than done, but given what is happening in AI right now, it doesn't seem far fetched to think that we'll be able to accomplish this.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoI was hoping to do something like this for adventure game hotspots after a hand injury. Even experimented with AutoIt and its OCR, before giving up. Now there is another niche project with the goal of translation: translate.net With more capable models it's going to be fun to see what folks come up with! Still, I hope internal efforts get some attention as they don't need to rely on hacks and awkward workarounds.
- kaba0 3y agoIt doesn’t sound unachievably hard, but I cry for all the “wasted” energy it would require.
- hello_computer 3y agoFrom a user perspective (i.e., not a developer one), what have either of these projects improved since the old days of GTK2 and X11? Maybe I'm not enough of a power user, but I see no tricks in my Linux GUI today that weren't already there 15 years ago. Preemptively, I reject the "security" answer, since Intel/ AMD/NSA/Mossad can already peek my RAM at will. The whole mess feels like corporate sabotage.
- yakubin 3y agoIn the beginning of Gnome 3 I loved this feature where you could reply to someone’s chat messages straight from the notification without switching apps/windows: <https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-hIyeIWfFyvc/ToRSxqZnFQI/AAAAAAAAGEM/yXi5buduS4w/s2000/chat-reply.png https://lh6.googleusercontent.com/-hIyeIWfFyvc/ToRSxqZnFQI/A...>. It eliminated a costly mental context switch. But XMPP is dead, so I don’t use such apps anymore. I also haven’t been using Gnome for a very long time now. I’ve read somewhere that they removed this feature though.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- MattJ100 3y agoXMPP isn't dead, but quite active: https://xmpp.org/blog/ https://xmpp.org/blog/ It's very possible your social circle is not on XMPP though. There's some light at the end of the tunnel with the EU's Digital Markets Act forcing the large messaging providers to provide interoperability - at a minimum this should enable better bridges between XMPP-based and proprietary systems. The active GTK clients these days are Dino and Gajim. Pidgin is still around, but has fallen very far behind with regards to features (they're in the middle of a rewrite that will hopefully address this).
- kaba0 3y agoPeeking at RAM and literally being able to record your whole screen from an npm package are two quite different levels of threats. Also, multi-monitor setups with different DPIs are not possible on X.
- W4RH4WK55 3y agoGnome/GTK accessibility has been deteriorating for years. Unrelated to Wayland. Hamburger menus that cannot be navigated with Alt+_ shortcuts (and sometimes not even with cursor keys) are the prime example.