5 ms·
Indeed. Remember the Palm Pilot? Those things eventually ended up quite advanced; I remember buying one in Japan in 2002 with a camera, keyboard, swiveling sc
by jrockway 15y ago
Indeed. Remember the Palm Pilot? Those things eventually ended up quite advanced; I remember buying one in Japan in 2002 with a camera, keyboard, swiveling screen, and so on. The only difference was that it didn't have a 3G radio.
Ah, here we are: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Sony-CLIE-PEG-NZ90.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Sony-CLIE-PEG-NZ90.jpg
The iPhone is a fine product. The ground it broke was making people want a PDA, not actually inventing the PDA.
- YooLi 15y agoExcept that looks nothing like the iPhone, while most smartphones now look a heck of a lot like an iPhone.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- arjn 15y agoThe iPhone looks a lot like the LG Prada mentioned in the article and it predates the iPhone.
- Apple-Guy 15y agoNot in reality. http://www.roughlydrafted.com/RD/RDM.Tech.Q1.07/72B08E9A-D467-45EA-B214-28D3A340C3E5.html http://www.roughlydrafted.com/RD/RDM.Tech.Q1.07/72B08E9A-D46...
- aaronblohowiak 15y agoThe Prada phone is as similar to the iPhone as the android phones people claim are rip offs of the iPhone. Given the short difference in time between their announcements, it is. Lear they were developed concurrently. Therefore, the android devices are derivAtive more of the Prada phone than the iPhone or the design decisions in common to the iPhone and Prada phone are "obvious"
- jdq 15y agoYou mean the non-smartphone that was announced a couple weeks before the iPhone? I forget, how was multitouch on it? And the web browser, was it any good?
- ajross 15y agoIt's undeniably true that Apple shipped the first good multitouch implementation on a handset. But there were lots of phones with very capable browsers, and a comparatively successful company (Opera) selling them for years before Apple started work on the iPhone. Which of course is the whole point: ideas are items of trade. Someone thinks of something and someone else improves it. That's the way innovation works. Apple has surely done more of it than any other single company, but they've also, like everyone else, "stolen" far more than they invented themselves. Claiming that they have some special ground with the iPhone is just a laughable, juvenile flame war. I wish these would stop.
- Happer 15y agoIndeed they don't have special ground with the iPhone. Except maybe for one "thing". Back in 2007 I joined a new employer. One evening during my new hire training a colleague demo'ed his iPhone he brought over from America to Europe. All other attendees, including myself, were amazed about the multitouch, pinch and zoom photo's, the easiness of use, the awesome GUI and the beautiful design. At the end of the demo there was a deep respectful silence by all of us. Amazement. Thinking about our own phones at the time compared to what we just saw. Then.. the owner of the iPhone put it gently against his face and caressed it. Yes he actually caressed it. I still remember that image. This is the "thing". You know, this thing called love. Something that cannot be traded like an item and which still holds true for many.
- j45 15y agoHi, just out of curiosity, did you own a smartphone from 96 to the early 2000's? The Treo was the original smartphone. The orignal smart phone that Blackberry copied was the Treo. Apple's spin was ditching the keyboard, but by then even the sony ericcson P800 had a full screen phone with a touch keyboard years before apple. http://www.google.ca/search?&q=sony+ericcson+p800 http://www.google.ca/search?&q=sony+ericcson+p800
- moylan 15y agoi'd have said 1996 with the https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nokia_9000_Communicator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nokia_9000_Communicator but it was a niche product that probably didn't appear in the u.s. much. as a psion user i lusted after these devices. but price of mobile data put them out of my reach. i used a psion 5 as my main computer till 99 when i wanted to start ripping cds for an mp3 player amongst other things.
- wmf 15y agoI owned a P800 and I consider the iPhone to be in a completely different class. Each of the individual differences is small, but when taken together the feel of using them is quite different.
- wvenable 15y agoTo be fair, the P800 had a 150mhz processor and 16 MB of RAM and could display a whopping 4,098 colors. It came out around the same time as Windows XP SP1.
- fpgeek 15y ago> Each of the individual differences is small, but when taken together the feel of using them is quite different. Fair enough, but now you're describing evolution, not revolution.
- gnaffle 15y agoThe Treo was hardly the original smartphone. Nokia had the Communicator before that, and Alcatel had the One Touch Com in 1996: http://data.motor-talk.de/data/galleries/0/3/7206/16273817/p3140094-large-56259.JPG http://data.motor-talk.de/data/galleries/0/3/7206/16273817/p... Apples spin wasn't ditching the keyboard as so many people think, it was designing the user interface around finger-based touch, making the interface easy enough for normal people to use, and finally to ship a decent performing browser at a time when most other phones were a nightmare to use when browsing the web (try a N95, also released in 2007, to see what I mean)
- jrockway 15y agoThe HTC Dream didn't look anything like the iPhone either, but Jobs still says Android is a stolen product. So the question is, what did Android steal from Apple?
- dedward 15y agothats more a personal comment from Jobs...... Apple isnt charging anyone with theft. before thi ihone, no app store no multi touch, litte integration outside of the blackberry, and smartphones and phones in general sucked by comparison. how quickly we forget how crappy what we had before was. sure, previous products had lots f features............ but they didnt blowpeoples minds, or make their companies the most valuable ever.
- fpgeek 15y ago> no app store I wonder what Andy Rubin would say about that...
- greggman 15y agoThere were app stores in Japanese phones from 1999. We're not forgetting that they sucked. We're pointing out Apple didn't invent this stuff. Touchscreens, had those for years. Multi-touch? Lots shown in the ARS article. Here's some http://tactiva.com/demo.html http://tactiva.com/demo.html. Includes pinch to zoom, 2 finger rotate objects. Also includes tactile feedback, something no tablet has introed yet AFAIK. Apps, had those too for years. Oh look, it's instructions from 2001 on how to write apps for phones http://www.geocities.co.jp/SiliconValley-Cupertino/1621/ http://www.geocities.co.jp/SiliconValley-Cupertino/1621/ App stores? Did you ever bother to look? There's been app stores since at least 2001. None of them were that popular but they did exist. Oh look, my WinCE box boots into a grid of icons in 2001 http://blog.greggman.com/japan/ce/dsc03224.jpg http://blog.greggman.com/japan/ce/dsc03224.jpg Maps, I had 3d first person maps on my 2004 feature phone, something still missing from any iPhones I know of. They had 2d maps in 2000 Games, Yep, last 5 phones I owned before my iPhone all had downloadable games. Here's me playing mappy I just purchased from an online app store in 2001 http://blog.greggman.com/blog/what_s_this_/ http://blog.greggman.com/blog/what_s_this_/ Cameras? Here's pictures from my 2001 cellphone camera http://blog.greggman.com/blog/pictures_from_cell_/ http://blog.greggman.com/blog/pictures_from_cell_/ Facetime? Here's Facetime on a P2101V from 2001 http://blog.greggman.com/blog/more_cellphone_madness/ http://blog.greggman.com/blog/more_cellphone_madness/ Front and back cameras? 2002 http://joi.ito.com/weblog/2002/11/15/my-new-p504is.html http://joi.ito.com/weblog/2002/11/15/my-new-p504is.html Airtime, i.e. TV playback? 2003 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2XWLG-6qPwo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2XWLG-6qPwo Webpage browsing? Yep. Wrote my first blog post from a phone in 2001. Maybe Apple can claim full browsing first on iPhone though I suspect people have earlier examples. I could certainly view full pages through Opera Mini before iPhone. Music? Several of the phones I owned has music stores built in and some phones advertised how awesome a movie player they were. Synced to PC and everything. Want an iPad? How about the Sony Airboard, 2001. Wireless internet browsing touchscreen tablet http://www.sony.jp/airboard/indexpc.html http://www.sony.jp/airboard/indexpc.html Did Apple take all those features and make them super awesome? YES. The point is THEY TOOK EXISTING FEATURES. They didn't invent them. They just made them way better. Awesome. It's the little details they did well. It's the sum of the parts. It's pretty hard to pick any one thing for which there is no precedence. Cut and Paste? old. Zoom under pointer? Old. Slide to Unlock? Old. Email? Old. Pages of icons? old. They brought awesome style and design but even my old B/W WinCE machine linked above I didn't need or use any of the buttons except POWER and I could use my finger to control everything else.
- JoelSutherland 15y agoHere is a 2002 Palm Treo Phone: http://www.gsmarena.com/palm_treo_180-623.php http://www.gsmarena.com/palm_treo_180-623.php Palm OS looks a lot like iOS when you factor in the era's technology.
- ghshephard 15y agoI owned three Palm Treos from 2002 - 2006, including the 600 and the 700p. I _lived_ on those phones for the better part of four years - and I recall waiting for each new release. So, as a Palm "Fanboy" I can say with certainty that those devices were not even in the same product category as the iPhone. Suggesting that they looked like iOS is farcical at best. I recall struggling for the better part of a week to purchase and install a "Yahtzee game" for the phone. Even after nine months on the 600, I _still_ was unable to reliably hit the proper key sequence to dial a number out of my phone book (the Cancel had the focus by default, so you would "select number, hit enter - and cancel out. Instead you had to "Select number, change focus, _then_ hit number to dial. They finally reversed it on the 700, screwing up 18 months+ of muscle memory that finally developed. net-net - anybody who ever owned a Palm, and particularly those who used the browser, will state beyond a shadow of a doubt the iPhone and Palm had no relationship, evolutionary or otherwise, to each other.
- omerta 15y agoI agree. Comparing those devices to the iPhone is just laughable. The iPhone took everything Palm could do and made it much more elegant and intuitive to use. It did it in such a way that made the older palm devices look so incredibly archaic.
- fpgeek 15y agoI lived on the Treo 650 from the day the GSM version came out to when I got my G1 (about a month after it came out). Having used that Treo 650 and many other smartphones of that era (O2 XDA, Sony-Ericsson P900, Nokia Communicator, ...) I will absolutely, unequivocally, beyond the shadow of a doubt say that the iPhone was part of the same evolutionary tree. Did the iPhone do the things my Treo could do much, much better? Was it a great step forward? Absolutely. The iPhone was and is amazing [1]. Nevertheless, saying that the iPhone stands apart from the broader evolution of mobile devices is either ignorance or a willful misreading of the relevant history. [1] Though I will admit to finding the idea of paying money for ringtones of music you already owned a repugnant step back.