20 ms·
It's a bit more complicated because these things are coupled. I think people are trying to draw deep distinctions to have a clear and simple answer to why the c
by godelski 3y ago
It's a bit more complicated because these things are coupled. I think people are trying to draw deep distinctions to have a clear and simple answer to why the cost of nuclear rose but it is quite a lot of things that contribute and feed one another over time. As an incomplete example: anti-nuclear sentiments can make a government reduce the number of reactors they order or even cancel projects, this can then increase the cost of other reactors as low order counts don't scale well, causing others to cancel or delay orders as prices were higher than expected, and so on. Do this over 40 years.
There isn't any one thing that killed nuclear in the US, but rather a lot of little things. There's the anti-nuclear sentiment, there is big oil/gas disinformation campaigns (their climate campaigns were about making doubt of everything but them), it was a drop in price of crude oil during the Regan/Bush era, it was a change in regulation after Chernobyl after 3-Mile and after Fukushima, a rise in fossil fuel subsidies when nuclear had none (Regan/Bush/Carter), a decrease in DOE research funding of reactors, and it was many more things. The story and history matters. The complexity matters because it didn't die overnight.
This is important to understand because it also means fixing a single thing won't change things. Political will and support does matter but only gets the ball rolling as it prioritizes it to let the experts fix things. But the complexity means it won't be resolved overnight were we to magically get 100% of people onboard and passionate.
I wish nuclear proponents as well as opponents would recognize the inherent complexities of these problems. The truth is that stories like this aren't unique to nuclear and our oversimplification prevents us from solving many of our critical issues these days. The world is complex and messy. But I guess it is easier to garner support (an important factor) if we over simplify things. I just wish that would be the hook rather than the full story that we passionately defend.