4 ms·
This is a quantitative disagreement. Not emacs vs vim. Straight numbers. Reddit says the API will cost less than a $1/month per user. [1] Apollo says the API
by paulddraper 3y ago
This is a quantitative disagreement. Not emacs vs vim. Straight numbers.
Reddit says the API will cost less than a $1/month per user. [1]
Apollo says the API will cost $2.50/month per user. [2]
Moreover, Apollo claims that Reddit itself makes only $0.12/month per user, therefore the API charges are absurd. [2]
What are the correct numbers? These are numbers, not opinions.
EDIT: One issue...I suspect that Apollo users are significantly more active than the average Reddit MAU. Say, 4x more active. So the $0.12/month revenue estimate is like (for example) $0.50 per Apollo user.
[1] https://www.reddit.com/r/reddit/comments/145bram/addressing_the_community_about_changes_to_our_api/ https://www.reddit.com/r/reddit/comments/145bram/addressing_...
[2] https://www.reddit.com/r/apolloapp/comments/13ws4w3/had_a_call_with_reddit_to_discuss_pricing_bad/ https://www.reddit.com/r/apolloapp/comments/13ws4w3/had_a_ca...
- itake 3y agoJust a shot in the dark, but maybe reddit is only counting logged in users whereas you don't need to be logged in to use apollo?
- austhrow743 3y agoIf they're not logged in then there's no reason to hit the Reddit api on a per user basis.
- riku_iki 3y ago> Moreover, Apollo claims that Reddit itself makes only $0.12/month per user. [2] MAU are very different users compared to users making 200 reqs per day, and bring very different revenue.
- paulddraper 3y agoAgreed. I think this is an issue in Apollo's math. Enough to account for an order of magnitude? IDK
- riku_iki 3y ago> Enough to account for an order of magnitude? IDK reddit daily users (not MAU) are about 50m, which likely also don't generate 200res/d, and this difference is already order of magnitude. Other "issue" from apollo side: he compares reddit API cost to his imgur API cost of $166 per 50m reqs, while forgetting that official imgur API costs $3k/50m.
- Timon3 3y agoGiven the blatant lies by the CEO towards the Apollo developer I don't believe a single word that they can't prove.
- MicropenisMike 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- FormerBandmate 3y agoIt’s truly incompetent management. Spotify gatekeeps all third party apps behind their premium subscription, they could charge $10 a month for Reddit Premium to give access to Apollo and they’d make out like bandits. Spez sounds like he has personal beef with Christian on the AMA, that’s Elon Musk level nonsense except replacing electric cars and space travel with a shitty web forum
- tedivm 3y agoTHIS! Just make it so the third party apps only work for reddit gold users, or have limitations for non-gold users, and now they've converted a bunch of the apollo users into paying members. Instead they're lying and slandering people, getting caught, and doubling down. I'm getting the impression that reddit isn't profitable not because of any fundamental issue, but because the leadership of the site have absolutely no idea what they're doing.
- mindslight 3y agoI have to wonder if this is just the same cross-society trend of employees seemingly checking out and doing the bare minimum, manifesting in the C-suite. One would think top management should be doing the work of coming up with several different monetization strategies, analyzing what different types of backlash they each might cause, how to market them, simulating revenue given various levels of attrition, etc. Instead it's like they (he?) have chosen a single course of action and are just going to force it through at all costs, and they're in charge so why isn't everyone just doing what they say damnit.
- gberger 3y agoReddit says "typical app user" but Apollo claims that its users make more API requests than is typical for other apps, in part due to higher usage, and in part due to inefficiencies in how Apollo structures its queries.
- seanalltogether 3y agoReddit may be making their claims based on an app that doesn't issue push notifications and thus doesn't need to poll their servers 24/7 for every user.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- soraminazuki 3y ago> These are numbers, not opinions. > Say, 4x more active. So the $0.12/month revenue estimate is like (for example) $0.50 per Apollo user. Numbers can very much be an opinion if you pull them out of thin air.
- JeremyNT 3y agoIt all just blows my mind, because realistically none of these details even matter. It's reddit's ball, they can take it and go home any time they want. They don't have anything to prove, they don't owe anything to anybody, not even an explanation. Ultimately they need to make a profit and they think this is the way towards that. I just can't understand why they feel the need to keep publicly stating things that are either outright untrue or at least misleading. Just make an announcement to the effect of "this is the pricing, we have determined this is the best way to meet our financial goals" and shut the hell up. It's not hard! The BS / gaslighting about precise numbers and the misrepresentation of what they've heard from developers is completely pointless.
- Aaargh20318 3y ago> I just can't understand why they feel the need to keep publicly stating things that are either outright untrue or at least misleading I can only think of one reason: they’re panicking. > It's reddit's ball, they can take it and go home any time they want. While this is true, Reddit knows they are dependent on their users for their survival. That’s why they are panicking.
- cute_boi 3y agoisn't everything depended upon their users for their survival?
- harrisi 3y agoNot to the extent that Reddit is, at least not in the same way. Other companies can exist and even thrive regardless of what users want by being necessary or legally mandated. Oil companies' users aren't their customers. Equifax doesn't care about how users feel. ADP, Geico, SAP, utilities, banks, etc. aren't the best companies for users, and many of their users dislike them, but it's generally not a threat to their profitability. This is a somewhat cynical view, admittedly, but overall, many successful companies don't need to please "users" in the same way Reddit does. They obviously make some amount from advertisers, but they need users for advertisers to advertise too.
- derekpankaew 3y agoChristian's math assumes every MAU is worth the same. He took $600 million in revenue and divided it by 430 million MAU, to get to $0.12 per user. In reality, the value of a MAU varies a ton by geography (and other factors). For Meta, in 2023, US and Canada traffic is worth $48/yr, while developing world traffic is $3.35/yr. A ~15x difference. https://www.statista.com/statistics/251328/facebooks-average-revenue-per-user-by-region/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/251328/facebooks-average... The typical Apollo user is probably much higher value than the average Reddit user, so the opportunity cost is higher as well.