3 ms·
That's a great feel-good story for gun lovers - but you might want to check the actual history of civvies with guns trying to fight against armies which were de
by bell-cot 3y ago
That's a great feel-good story for gun lovers - but you might want to check the actual history of civvies with guns trying to fight against armies which were determined to win.
Warsaw Ghetto Uprising in 1943?
Semaine sanglante (Paris) in 1871?
Edit:
> Anyway don't support this view, I don't own guns. I'm just saying that blatant disregard for peoples safety is why...
+1, but yes and no. These sort of "+5 sigma" clicky stories really push some people's buttons...but I think the real drivers of "don't trust the Government" are elsewhere. I'd point to the routine crap of American municipal government - which often resembles the daily drama of a bunch of low-functioning Junior High students. The whole "rich get richer, everyone else gets screwed" shift in the U.S. economy (and Democratic Party) over the past ~60 years. And the endless, strident screams of right-wing political edgelords.
- VoodooJuJu 3y agoMujahideen equipped with small arms have been successfully fending off professional armies for decades, most recently the U.S. military in Afghanistan.
- troad 3y ago> you might want to check the actual history I think the primary example that's going to come to mind for all Americans is the American Revolution, which was successful, if I recall correctly. I don't really like this tone of 'lecturing' people, as though they don't understand and you do. Well-informed people have legitimate differences of opinion on these questions.
- ethanbond 3y agoI sure hope they don’t. That’s a terrible example. The British homeland was 1) an ocean away in the 1700s and 2) extremely distracted by numerous other conflicts and 3) had pretty much the same firepower that a civilian and privateers would have. None of those things apply now. IMO the Taliban is a much better analog. And you of course have to mix in the horror of a true civil war which in America’s case pretty much everyone came out of thinking no one won.
- troad 3y agoI honestly don't understand in which part of my comment you think I'm in favour of civil war. I'm merely pointing out that attempting to argue against guns from the perspective of 'popular resistance against tyranny never going to be successful' is far from the best way to argue against guns. It has been successful before, and the country's entire foundation myth rests on one of those instances. There's many ways to argue against gun proliferation. This is a bad one. It's particularly bad one to use on right-of-centre Americans. But people on the Internet disagree, love using it, and they've been incredibly successful in using it to win over suppo- oh, wait.
- ethanbond 3y agoI didn't suggest that you're in favor of it? Was not my intention so sorry if it came off that way! I agree with the overall thrust though: this is not a winning line of argument. But I'm not sure what is, to be honest, given that this issue has become quasi-religious. Eventually we'll have enough dead kids (and enough dead old people) to start questioning this religious conviction, but yeah, logic or history won't get us there.
- troad 3y agoI appreciate your reply and I hear what you're saying. So much of life has become political, and so much of the political has become pseudo-religious. People no longer have positions on policies, they have articles of faith on politics. It's not a great basis for a dialogue, unfortunately.
- bell-cot 3y ago"going to come to mind", yes. But much of what Americans "know" about the American Revolution is popular myth. In actual history, it was one of the western theaters in the Anglo-French War - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglo-French_War_(1778%E2%80%931783) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anglo-French_War_(1778%E2%80%9.... Spain was also fighting against Britain, and there was a serious threat of a combined French/Spanish invasion of England. Britain had to make some hard choices about priorities, and decided to focus its efforts in places that weren't the 13 Colonies.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- willcipriano 3y agoWar in Afghanistan (2001–2021) - Goat hearders defeat the most powerful military on earth Vietnam War (1955 - 1975) - Textile workers defeat the most powerful military on earth American Revolutionary War (1775-1783) - Pilgrims defeat the most powerful military on earth Also note Germany had strong gun laws after WW1 while France was limited to shotguns and hunting rifles.
- bell-cot 3y agoThat sounds cool...but Afghanistan and Vietnam were proxy wars, where the U.S. decided that holding onto a basket-case country was not worth the cost. And the actual military defeats occurred after the U.S. forces were gone. American Revolution was not actually "Pilgrims against Britain", it was one of the western theaters in the Anglo-French(-Spanish) War.
- willcipriano 3y ago> where the U.S. decided that holding onto a basket-case country was not worth the cost Yes. That's what they were going for. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attrition_warfare https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attrition_warfare The British didn't think it was worth the cost either.
- bell-cot 3y ago> That's what they were going for. Perhaps the U.S. pro-gun folks need to advertise more widely that their imagined "victory scenario" is "turn the U.S. into a smoking crater/basket case, which the U.S. Army won't think is worth holding onto"?
- willcipriano 3y agoYou'd give up your right to self defence to a government that would "turn the U.S. into a smoking crater" before they would return the power to the people?
- saiya-jin 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]