4 ms·
What's really so "privacy" about Manjaro that something like Debian doesn't have? Of course Canonical has a really bad reputation on privacy with all the tricks
by wkat4242 3y ago
What's really so "privacy" about Manjaro that something like Debian doesn't have? Of course Canonical has a really bad reputation on privacy with all the tricks they've been pulling but Ubuntu isn't the only game under the sun.
I've never used it but I know Manjaro is basically a more opinionated and easier to use Arch. If you want rolling debian isn't an option but something like OpenSUSE tumbleweed is.
But I really wonder what's supposed to be so much better in terms of privacy on Manjaro.
- JohnFen 3y agoI'm not familiar with Manjaro, but with other security-focused distros, the difference is what the defaults are, plus perhaps some unique convenience applications. There's nothing you can do with any of the security-oriented distros that you can't do with any other distro, but the security-oriented ones can ease initial configuration and perhaps make it less likely that you overlooked something.
- wkat4242 3y agoWell, first of all, security is not the same as privacy though they do of course somewhat align. Second, the defaults on something like Debian are very security focused. Out of the box it installs hardly anything. Also I have never heard of Manjaro trying to be a "security-focused" distro until now. Not in the sense of OpenBSD, Whonix, or Hardened Gentoo. I'm sure it's not bad at privacy and security but really for most Linux distros this is a given.
- JohnFen 3y agoAgain, not talking about Manjaro as I know nothing about it, but while Debian is indeed reasonably secure out of the box, it is a far cry from being actually hardened (because a hardened system is less user-friendly). Security-oriented distros that I am familiar with are more hardened out of the box. But, again, that's a state you can achieve with every distro. It's just with normal distros, it takes more work.
- nazgulsenpai 3y agoManjaro isn't security oriented. Its a general purpose desktop distro that ships with a proprietary office suite by default. They also don't do anything to elaborate on the privacy claims in TFA. Disingenuous in my humble opinion, unless of course the privacy claim is in contrast to Windows. But then again the article doesn't elaborate
- goodpoint 3y agoWhat makes a distro security-oriented? Debian has thousands of contributors and a dedicated security team.
- beardog 3y agoSandboxing is the big one (think Qubes, although it is not exactly a Linux distro), as well as good security practices for the distro maintainers, good defaults for kernel configuration, timely updates, some kinda MAC. Manjaro has little of this as a default out of the box. They are mostly able to claim that they are privacy oriented because any OS that isn't borderline spyware like Windows is privacy oriented in comparison.
- goodpoint 3y ago> Sandboxing is the big one There are various sandboxing tools but they are developed upstream, not by distros. > as well as good security practices for the distro maintainers Some large distributions do this, but it takes a lot of work. How many contributors does Manjaro have?
- leni536 3y ago> If you want rolling debian isn't an option I've been on Debian unstable for years on multiple devices, without major issues.
- bjoli 3y agoDebian unstable is, in my experience, slightly more stable than arch. I gave up on arch after it broke after a pacman -Suy (despite having looked for breaking changes) one time too many. Now I run Ubuntu LTS with gnu Guix for most userland software.
- pabs3 3y agoDebian has lots of privacy issues, help welcome to try and solve them though: https://wiki.debian.org/PrivacyIssues https://wiki.debian.org/PrivacyIssues
- m4lvin 3y agoOkay, but where is the comparison list for Manjaro? ;-)