4 ms·

I don't use reddit much anymore, the problem is that most interesting communities i know have moved to discord that is a garbage alternative in my eyes. You ca

I don't use reddit much anymore, the problem is that most interesting communities i know have moved to discord that is a garbage alternative in my eyes. You can't find the best posts for any given time range, you can't discuss one thing at a time, everything just disappears after everyone has paid very little effort to write something because its gone quickly. It's fragmented, low-effort, digital dementia and i hate it. I don't understand the appeal of discord and really hope someone creates an actual alternative to Reddit.

ssimpson 3y ago
the appeal of reddit is that you get a bunch of discussion on one topic, vs discord, my discussion on a topic is spread out over one or many discords. i really just use discord for communicating with groups of people that might all know each other under some interest. i wouldn't say that discord is an alternative to reddit, more of an alternative to slack.
gnoop 3y ago
We're in the chat cycle of the internet. We went through this with AOL chatrooms and IRC in the 90s as well. I'm not the most massive fan of chat in place of forums either but that seems the trend lately. Even on Reddit, a bunch of communities have Discords you can join. Maybe some new web forums will spin up, though it looks like much the software remains the same as it has been for a while.
- kossTKR 3y ago
  True, it's probably also closer to a feed, and creates more engagement with less thoughts involved. The problem i think is it massively lowers quality, searchability and generally just creates this fogged-out state of mind when looking for or researching something besides plain "relaxing in a groupchat".
- BlueTemplar 3y ago
  But then in the 90s forums didn't exist yet ? Also forum software has been evolving too, for instance even phpBB has drag and drop image insertion these days.
  - gnoop 3y ago
    I was on Slashdot in the 90s - they started in 1997. There were some early web boards that came out then as well. And yeah, phpBB has improved. One site I've been on for a good 15+ years is running on it and it's got some decent features.

ssimpson 3y ago

the appeal of reddit is that you get a bunch of discussion on one topic, vs discord, my discussion on a topic is spread out over one or many discords. i really just use discord for communicating with groups of people that might all know each other under some interest. i wouldn't say that discord is an alternative to reddit, more of an alternative to slack.

gnoop 3y ago

We're in the chat cycle of the internet. We went through this with AOL chatrooms and IRC in the 90s as well. I'm not the most massive fan of chat in place of forums either but that seems the trend lately. Even on Reddit, a bunch of communities have Discords you can join. Maybe some new web forums will spin up, though it looks like much the software remains the same as it has been for a while.

kossTKR 3y ago
True, it's probably also closer to a feed, and creates more engagement with less thoughts involved. The problem i think is it massively lowers quality, searchability and generally just creates this fogged-out state of mind when looking for or researching something besides plain "relaxing in a groupchat".
BlueTemplar 3y ago
But then in the 90s forums didn't exist yet ? Also forum software has been evolving too, for instance even phpBB has drag and drop image insertion these days.
- gnoop 3y ago
  I was on Slashdot in the 90s - they started in 1997. There were some early web boards that came out then as well. And yeah, phpBB has improved. One site I've been on for a good 15+ years is running on it and it's got some decent features.