3 ms·
A lesson to be learned. Do not build your entire business on someone else's API. The outcome was unsurprising and it is unfortunate. But this is why third-part
by rvz 3y ago
A lesson to be learned. Do not build your entire business on someone else's API.
The outcome was unsurprising and it is unfortunate. But this is why third-party apps are always at a disadvantage. The same happened with Twitter and they made that clear and now so did Reddit.
Like I said before in [0]
"Either the API gets blocked for third-party clients, or you purchase a high price for it."
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36087219 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36087219
- smoldesu 3y ago> Do not build your entire business on someone else's API For iPhone apps this isn't really an option in the first place.
- mr90210 3y agoToo bad you are being downvoted. You are rather accurate.
- srvmshr 3y agoMaybe for Reddit and Apollo case, this is alright & makes sense. But at the risk of sounding pedantic, don't generalize it. Most of our commodity software is built & deployed by packages, APIs and frameworks we have very little control on. We just hope things don't break/change as drastically and we can modularize our projects as much as we could, to bear some shock or disruption. Unlikely anyone can build & maintain consumer grade softwares ab initio
- heisenbit 3y agoThe closer you are to the final customer the better is your chance to bill for the value you deliver (standing on a fragile cobbled together set of third party components). The short term rewards strongly favor relying on others. The business dynamic compounds this as it places a premium on first movers. Going against this dynamic must be carefully considered and only makes sense in isolated cases (where it is the winning move).
- srvmshr 3y agoDisagree. (In the generalized sense) You cannot extricate yourself entirely and call it a winning move, unless your business is at a scale as large as Dropbox moving out from AWS ecosystem. I still feel no matter how natively one tries to build products - they cannot build everything. You cannot create CI/CD, monitoring, frontend, containerization, and cloud services just for your software or service. Those depend on some platform API which you won't create just for your product. Short or long business value - unless one becomes a major player with several software engineering teams building a product ecosystem - other people's APIs and frameworks will be used. And that is perfectly fine. That is how good products should be -using nice building blocks. No need to reinvent the wheel everytime.
- stronglikedan 3y agoOr do, but have a contract in place that ensures longevity. Of course not applicable in this case, but just addressing the generality of the statement, "Do not build your entire business on someone else's API."
- oldtownroad 3y agoThe tired “don’t build on someone else’s api” lesson doesn’t apply to this case because Apollo is specifically a method for accessing Reddit: Apollo wouldn’t exist without Reddit. The outcome here is sad, yes, but the author built a wildly successful app and made great money for close to a decade: a disappointing end does not discredit the journey. (Ps. your obsession with citing yourself is one of the worst parts of reading HN)
- notsound 3y agoThey also cite themselves within that citation. That second citation contains a citation also written by them. Citationception!
- rvz 3y ago> (Ps. your obsession with citing yourself is one of the worst parts of reading HN) Good. I don't care. It is a priceless prediction that became true. Hence how unsurprising this is.
- thewataccount 3y agoWhich other api's should he be using? Or are you just saying third party clients shouldn't be considered viable to begin with?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TobyTheDog123 3y agoJust imagine what'll happen when sideloading eventually makes its way to the US - the less-illegal sister of piracy, scraping, is going to make a huge resurgence.