8 ms·
Everyone's Trying to Track What You Do on the Web: Here's How to Stop Them
- mrspeaker 15y agoMaybe it's just to reinforce the point, but Ghostery prevents 9 scripts from executing on that page!
- jgw 15y agoIndeed. I liked the bit where my browser did a lookup on "track.lifehacker.com".
- nodata 15y ago> We'd say Ghostery, AdBlock Plus, and Priv3 are the essentials here. With Ghostery and ABP installed, why is Priv3 also required?
- greyman 15y agoGood question. I tried Priv3 today, but it seems to be the subset of Ghostery. BTW, it is necessary to use ABP, when I have Ghostery installed? (I don't intent to block ads, unless they actively track me, like Adsense, etc.)
- alexro 15y agoAFAIK, Ghostery doesn't prevent the tracking scripts from running, it just checks for known bugs
- slowpoke 15y ago>I don't intent to block ads May I ask why? I can understand whitelisting domains who you regularly visit and use (and thus want to support with ad income) and whom you trust to serve safe and unobtrusive ads , but I would be going insane without ABP on the web. It's excruciating to use a browser without ABP installed. Imagine trying to hold a conversation with someone while at least half a dozen of people are screaming nonsense at you - that's how it feels to browse the web with ads to me.
- poppysan 15y agoMaybe it' the consumer in me, but I feel responsible to view the ads on websites I frequent. If I see something I may like to purchase, then I'd rather the middleman be a website I frequent, so I can show support. May be trained behavior, but it is why I dont use ABP.
- danssig 15y agoI hear people say this, but personally I've never used any ad block and I nearly never see ads. Unless something weird happens like that one add that seemed to reach up into another one, I really never notice them.
- pavel_lishin 15y agoI could go without Adblock, but I absolutely could not use the web without Flashblock. If you run advertisements that automatically play sounds, you ought to be shot and dumped in a river.
- FellowesQi2014 15y agoYes, it is necessary. Think of Ghostery as filling the role of a black-list and ABP filling the role of a grey-list (and sometimes white-list).
- greyman 15y agoI use Ghostery and Https-Everywhere add-ons, plus startpage.com when I want to use Google search engine.
- barkingtoad 15y agoI'm so tired of this. If you're scared, get a dog. Or just read the "Why Should You Care" section and really think about it. Is it so bad? Do they have your gramma's name and address and are they sending the Depends cops over to check if she's peed herself? No, they have a bunch of anonymous data that they never attach to you personally. Everyone's trying to track YOU? NO, that's just some sort of weird narcissist paranoia on your behalf. Nobody is trying to track YOU. Everyone is trying to track EVERYONE. YOUR information is worthless on its own. NO marketer cares about YOU personally and YOUR data is not worth anything negotiable. If you're scared, get a dog.
- aw3c2 15y agoEveryone tracking everyone IS the problem.
- nodata 15y agoWhat could possibly go wrong with individuals being tracked to this level? Don't be naive.
- barkingtoad 15y agoExplain, and while you do, remember that "slippery slope" is a logical fallacy.
- FellowesQi2014 15y agoWhile I am not nodata, I have a single acronym answer for you: STASI
- barkingtoad 15y agoThat's exactly what I'm talking about; we just magically went from "people are trying to target you with ads that are relevant to you" to "the secret police are going to make you disappear." And that's the connection made when I specifically request an argument that's not slippery slope. And I'm downvoted for specifically requesting a valid argument. Thank you, HN, or should I say, Reddit Lite.
- FellowesQi2014 15y agoFWIW, my Firefox privacy add-on stack is: * Adblock Plus * BetterPrivacy * Ghostery * NoScript * PrivacyChoice TrackerBlock * QuickJava * User Agent Switcher Yes, there is some overlap in functionality. And getting the configurations correct can be a minor pain (none of them are ready to go after install). I have also found the Chromium version of Ghostery cannot be configured to block DoubleClick tracking. :-( So much for using Chrome-based browsers as my main browser.
- slowpoke 15y agoAnother good add-on to consider is RequestPolicy. It controls cross-site requests and thus blocks a lot of stuff before it even loads. It's a nice complement to NoScript. If you don't like all of the social media buttons (which are also trackers and are, in my opinion, an eyesore), consider subscribing to the Antisocial filter list[2] for ABP. It blocks all of these pesky, useless annoyances and removes them from sight. Oh, and btw: Chrome is Chromium based, not the other way round. ;) [1]: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/requestpolicy/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/requestpolicy... [2]: http://adversity.uk.to/ http://adversity.uk.to/
- dharmach 15y agoIs there any add-on similar to TrackMeNot which can regularly send request for random web pages and obfuscate my internet history? TrackMeNot does similar thing for search engines.
- jbooth 15y agoI work in the ad industry. We take pains to make sure that everything is hashed as early in the process as possible, so we're basically just correlating hashes with each other. There's nothing personally identifiable. I understand that it sounds creepy, but it's worth noting that advertising is what pays for all the free content you enjoy on the internet. EDIT: Downvoted for comments from the industry. Thanks! Let me know if there's any questions I can answer for you guys.
- dawgr 15y agoYou don't need to track people to show them ads and in no case should you track people without their consent.
- jbooth 15y agoThat's awfully sanctimonious. Do you cut personal checks to websites who's content you enjoy? If not, they need advertising dollars, and advertising can bring in way more money when anonymized tracking is used.
- WayneDB 15y agoWell, paying for content sounds great but most websites that I visit don't even offer that choice. Sorry, but you're wrong that tracking is required. TV, Radio and Newspaper have been making money hand over fist for decades without tracking.
- jbooth 15y agoNewspapers are making money hand over fist? Funny, I thought they were being massacred and increasing CPMs on their remnant inventory is one of the few bright spots in their finances. If you visit someone's website, they're not violating your rights by noting that you visited. You're free to not visit, in fact. Or to register yourself on a do-not-track registry, enable ad block, and visit without contributing towards their bottom line. Whatever you want.
- brudgers 15y agoAs if to demonstrate the point, the page does not load any content unless javascript is turned on [Firefox], even though the server does not require it in order to provide the article text. One of the questions in my mind is in regards to Chrome, which I have not used for some time. Does it still send keystrokes from the address/search bar to Google servers in order to provide suggestions?
- pavel_lishin 15y agoI think Blogger does the same thing; it kills Instapaper functionality. (Net result: I don't read things published on Blogger.)