3 ms·
I strongly disagree. "Professional embarrassment" isn't really much of a punishment. > sufficient deterrent to future offenders because the “oops I didn’t know
by JohnFen 3y ago
I strongly disagree. "Professional embarrassment" isn't really much of a punishment.
> sufficient deterrent to future offenders because the “oops I didn’t know” defense won’t apply a second time.
I disagree with this as well, because the error this attorney made wasn't really about using AI. It was about not doing due diligence. Surely even freshly minted lawyers are well aware that doing due diligence is most of what people pay lawyers for in the first place.
- gnfargbl 3y ago> "Professional embarrassment" isn't really much of a punishment. That really depends on the profession. If you're a line cook at Waffle House and you get fired for coughing on the eggs, then that's probably not career-ending. If you're a software developer who deletes the production database and causes a week of downtime then that's worse, but likely still not terminal. On the other hand, this guy's income depends to a large extent on convincing his clients that they will be represented competently. Being known primarily for breathtaking incompetence will probably have a pretty significant effect on his future income.
- JohnFen 3y ago> Being known primarily for breathtaking incompetence will probably have a pretty significant effect on his future income. Perhaps so, but most people won't ever know the he's breathtakingly incompetent. It's certainly not a career-ending thing. For an error of this scale, I think that a strong argument can be made that he should choose a different career.