5 ms·
In the movie "A Beautiful Mind" one scene, quite brief and irrelevant, was quite interesting. Our protagonist, genius beyond measure, was in a courtyard amongst
by somenameforme 3y ago
In the movie "A Beautiful Mind" one scene, quite brief and irrelevant, was quite interesting. Our protagonist, genius beyond measure, was in a courtyard amongst a flock of pigeons. He was intently studying his subjects, implicitly determined to solve the riddle, crack the pattern, of their behaviors and movements.
It leads to an interesting thought. Could you actually crack the riddle of pigeon movement given access to the entirety of humanity's resources? Be those resources manpower, computation, or funding? I really doubt it. It's going to be a chaotic interdependent system, rife with individual variation, and a good deal of randomness and chaos thrown in for good measure. All with no reason to expect any sort of remotely normal or measurable distribution.
I really don't think my opinion there is especially controversial. Yet, if not - then how is it we might instead imagine we can delve into the patterns of the human mind and psyche? Where complexity, chaos, and interdependence is many orders of magnitude greater? It just doesn't really make any sense to me. We only take it as a given because we're born into a society where this is a given. From astrology to phrenology history is littered with examples of "science" that weren't really science at all, just fields perpetuated by bias confirmation, lack of falsifiability, and so on. I often think we're stuck with some 'arrogance of the present' where, due to our advanced knowledge, we imagine we could surely never repeat the same mistakes of the past. Of course people of the past thought the exact same as well.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoI think this is excellent example of the problem. Very complex, with some chaos thrown in. I disagree that is is impossible. We continue to chip away at the problem, at least to an extent that it seems worth continuing, not stopping. This thread is filled with people that think Psychology is akin to astrology. But will then happily click on their phones that psychology has helped dial in to produce a response in them.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThe conclusion that I draw is slightly different. We might not ever be able to deterministically predict human behavior, but that doesn't mean it's useless too identify Trends and develop heuristics. The problem is entirely with people confusing and treating Trends or heuristics as deterministic facts when they are far from it
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoI agree but also the opposite is happening. The ability to identify Trends and Heuristics is seen as 'not scientific, or exact enough', and thus tossed out as worthless. So trends/heuristics can be both, over-played, and under-appreciated. So guess there are two camps in the thread: Psychology is either over-stating its findings, 'trying to be too exact when exact is not possible', so it's bad science. Or when it does find something, it's deemed not exact enough, 'how dare you report a simple heuristic', so it's bad science. Damned either way.
- mlsu 3y agoEven though the exact movement of the pigeons can't be calculated, you can extract patterns. They go towards food, they nest in cliffs and buildings, they sleep at night. You can make very strong predictions about that stuff. Like fluid mechanics. It may actually be impossible to analytically predict the motion of individual particles in a fluid. Numerically it is certainly difficult. Yet we've extracted patterns to the point that we can design jet engines, wings, we can quantify the change in fuel economy from changing the shape of a car headlight... In an ideal world, psychology limits itself to attempting to look at these broad patterns and does so in a rigorous, reproducible way.