3 ms·
I don’t know. The positive argument for districts is that your representative represents local political needs which isn’t nothing and local needs definitely ex
by vlovich123 3y ago
I don’t know. The positive argument for districts is that your representative represents local political needs which isn’t nothing and local needs definitely exist and this is a way of expressing “hey, your federal policies are hurting me locally here”. This does happen I think although it’s unclear how effectively that gets communicated.
A big part of the problem is that gerrymandering is only really effective when the House of Representatives stays fixed in size. That’s actually fixable and would significantly reduce the effect size of gerrymandering (and also reduces lobbying power because you need to corrupt a lot more people which gets extremely more expensive).
One way to do proportional representation which I think works well is to blend it with districts. All districts get a representative but you add floating seats that are filled in proportionally based on overall vote count. That way you both get local representation in a larger system while largely removing the benefits of gerrymandering because the power balance isn’t determined by the map.