3 ms·
> The reason the US doesn’t use math to solve gerrymandering The US uses math to maximise partisan outcomes, when US Republicans have the chance to set boundar
by defrost 3y ago
> The reason the US doesn’t use math to solve gerrymandering
The US uses math to maximise partisan outcomes, when US Republicans have the chance to set boundaries they use software and consultants to crack Democrat districts and maximise chances for Republican county wins (and, of course, vice versa).
Countries such as Australia also use math to lay out districts, however they don't put the fozes in charge of the henhouse and instead have independant groups proposing new maps on the basis of party neutral constraints, take submissions and challenges onboard and operate in a transparent manner.
No system is perfect and naturally Australia at various times and in various locales has had "gerymandering" complaints and scandals - but nothing on the order of the US skews .. even after normalising for population scales.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 3y ago> (and, of course, vice versa). True, but only one of these parties ever talks about fixing the system. To be fair, of course, that's partially because the data says they'd win almost every election if it came down to a straight popular vote, so any system not specifically gamed against them is in their favor.
- tl 3y ago> True, but only one of these parties ever talks about fixing the system. To be fair, of course, that's partially because the data says they'd win almost every election if it came down to a straight popular vote, so any system not specifically gamed against them is in their favor. Democrats in New York produced a map so gerrymandered, it would have counterbalanced Republican gerrymandering elsewhere, but it was struck down by the courts: https://fivethirtyeight.com/videos/new-yorks-gerrymander-might-change-which-party-picks-up-seats-in-the-midterms/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/videos/new-yorks-gerrymander-mig...
- zmgsabst 3y agoRight — and the reason that the US doesn’t have a formulaic solution to prevent that is due to intentional racial gerrymandering. They’ve chosen a different strategy, with different outcomes. That’s the sense in which mathematics can’t solve a political problem. US voting maps hinge on the “one drop” rule — where the government says anyone who is multi-racial counts as black but not their other races. > Based on that guidance, census responses from people who marked both the "Black" and "White" boxes should be counted with the Black population. And when focused on discrimination specifically against Black people, responses marking boxes for two or more minority races including "Black" should also be counted as Black. https://www.npr.org/2022/10/18/1126287827/redistricting-supreme-court-louisiana-black-african-american https://www.npr.org/2022/10/18/1126287827/redistricting-supr...