8 ms·
Reddit will exempt accessibility-focused apps from unpopular API pricing changes
- giuliomagnifico 3y agoNice. Maybe the general mobilization worked? Looks like a workaround to say "hey the well done apps -like Apollo- can still be used", or I have interpreted this announcement wrong?
- docdeek 3y agoMy impression was that Apollo is NOT included in the free-tier access. IT seems to be addressing apps focused on accessability for blind users and the like, not general users of third-party apps.
- The_Colonel 3y agoIt's going to get quite absurd. The apps for blind users might even make it difficult / impossible to be used by users with a vision. Otherwise, adding e.g. RIF features into a "reddit for blind people" would be an API payment circumvention.
- Daedren 3y agoThe whole point of putting a price on the API -is- to kill Apollo and other standard third-party apps to get people on the official app full of ads.
- quink 3y ago> As long as those apps are noncommercial
- greggsy 3y agoI feel like Apollo has always be ‘freemium’
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Silhouette 3y agoI expect they are going to exempt a lot more than that. I have lost count of how many of the useful subreddits I belong to have already committed to going dark next week but it's a lot of them. This was a terrible judgement on Reddit's part and some kind of mea culpa from a higher-up followed by a rapid climb down looks inevitable if they don't want to be the next Twitter.
- edandersen 3y agoWhy doesn't Reddit just disable the ability to "go dark"?
- TheUndead96 3y agoIt would look even worse on their part, and there will probably still be a lot of people boycotting Reddit by their own volition regardless of how the site operates.
- robinduckett 3y agoWell the moderators could just strike in protest? Which would probably cause more issues
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- treme 3y agobecause they depend on free labors of people that are going dark for their business to function
- prepend 3y agoI think Reddit will actually still run for quite a while without moderators as most egregious spam is caught by auto moderator rules (although set up by moderators). I moderate a few subs and rarely do things manually. So short term strikes won’t have much impact other than degraded quality. Also, there’s already a process for “abandoned” subs where if subs aren’t moderated users can request mod access. So if mods go on strike, new users could request mod access. For some of the larger subs I think this would actually be healthy as there are lots of subs with toxic mods but there is no way to oust them unless they choose to leave.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- AltruisticGapHN 3y agoI love the accessibility of old.reddit.com it's the only way I browse the site, especially on my iPad. /sarcasm , but true.. can't imagine using the modern version.
- Jenk 3y agoGiven just how awful Reddit's own UI is, one could argue _all_ third party clients are accessibility-focused.
- Maxburn 3y agoI had to scroll too far down for this, exactly what my first thought was. The web page and native app are just not that great once you've worked with Apollo and some of the other apps like baconreader come to mind.
- prox 3y agoIf I use new reddit on mobile or iPad, the whole thing just crashes fairly quickly. It’s the only site that does that. Without old.reddit I actually cannot use the site unless I confine it to a desktop perhaps.
- hedora 3y agoThis would be true even if they had a decent UI. They should allow people to innovate on top of their platform if they want to grow their user base. Cutting off their own path to growth that tells me they're in cash-cow mode, so the business strategy is to auger their way into profitability by squeezing money from an ever-shrinking user base. If that's the case, they should also be laying off people to juice margins... checks... yep. Well, that was fun while it lasted. Are there any good reddit alternatives out there yet?
- wlesieutre 3y ago100% agreed. My wife uses Apollo because it handles accessibility (particularly Dynamic Type) better than the official app. If Apollo development stops because of exorbitant API pricing, allowing "accessibility focused" apps does fuck all for any of Apollo's blind users. Accessibility should be part of all apps, but clearly that's not a priority for reddit or she wouldn't be having this problem in the first place. This insinuation by reddit that blind users should be corralled into some special "accessibility focused" app is just PR to cover the fact that they're trying to kill the most accessible reddit clients.
- charcircuit 3y agoIs anyone willing to make a noncommercial accessibility Reddit API that others can use?
- ge96 3y agoFor some reason reddit is terrible on Firefox for me (freezes). I have an i9/fiber. Chrome is fine.
- onetokeoverthe 3y ago[dead]
- prepend 3y agoThis is interesting. I wonder if this is future hope for accessibility and will be legislated by the Americans with Disability Act. There’s already a portion called “section 508” [0] that requires software and web sites to be accessible, but it only applies to federal procurement. An extension could be that apis are required for accessibility and that they apply to all businesses over a certain size. While Section508 is designed for people with disabilities they affect all users since what helps screen readers also helps screen scrapers, etc. etc [0] https://www.section508.gov/manage/laws-and-policies/ https://www.section508.gov/manage/laws-and-policies/
- Loughla 3y agoI doubt it. There is nothing that states API is required for accessibility. There are common, easy to implement design tools to improve accessibility. Look at the WCAG guidelines (https://www.w3.org/TR/WCAG21/ https://www.w3.org/TR/WCAG21/) for exactly what you should be doing (also for a look at what a truly accessible site looks like). These are not difficult things to implement and do not require third party, or even first party apps to do. They can easily be integrated into any website.
- prepend 3y agoIt’s not a requirement now. I meant that there would be new legislation to expand ADA to cover API requirements. APIs aren’t expensive to implement, but they reduce revenue since people bypass ads and weaken moats as data is more portable. Companies are choosing to drop and not build because of revenue, not cost.
- Loughla 3y agoSo the problem with that is that (a) it requires a full update or amendments to the ADA, and (b) it requires legislators to understand what an API i and what it does. For point (a): We went from 1990 to 2008 before the ADA was last amended. So, according to that precedent, we will be waiting until 2026 or so. I guess that's not too bad. But my money says it's 2040+ before we see that amended again. For point (b): It feels like this one may be like asking if you can lick a rainbow.
- SilverBirch 3y agoReddit really is desperate for this IPO isn't it. This pricing decision is a total debacle. They're clearly going to try and tell a story about how their data set is massively valuable for AI (it isn't) and that they've got it under lock and key (it's already been crawled by every major player in AI) so that they can get a totally unrealistic valuation at IPO. It makes sense, imagine how incredible it would be if you could get an Nvidia level multiple at IPO. Unfortunately in the process they're killing the actual product. They're trying to backtrack to try and paper over this but you really can't get past the fact that what they're doing is deliberately attacking their own users and community. So they're trying to go "err uhh well, if you're exclusively using the API for accessbility and not making any money"... alright, we'll let you fix our broken shitty site but only if you take a vow of poverty. The correct answer from any developer to this should be clear "Fuck you pay me.". The relationship between Reddit and it's community is very delicate, so it seems pretty silly for Reddit to decide to crash it into a wall shortly before their IPO. They might get the IPO pop they want - I doubt it, they're smashing the long term viability of the company.
- sebzim4500 3y agoI think their data set is valuable, it's just freely available for anyone to scrape (or as you say, has already been scraped).
- MagicMoonlight 3y agoYou can’t scrape it anymore. It’s really annoying because I was just scraping individual posts to save them and now I can’t.
- ipaddr 3y agoPretend you are a bing bot
- sebzim4500 3y agoWhat happens when you try?
- 3y ago
- blacklight 3y agoWell I honestly don't care. The moment a service puts a paywalls around the API used to pull their public data they're already dead to me. No matter how many acts they decide to embark on to wash their dirty conscience. If your service doesn't expose your data using an API or an open feed, then your service has already become irrelevant, period.
- blender13 3y agoIt appears that this is just the Verge helping Reddit push PR because they (the Verge) did not bother contacting r/blind for information or the developers of the apps that they listed. It also appears that Reddit hasn’t done the same either. === Regarding the [June 7 article on The Verge](https://www.theverge.com/2023/6/7/23752804/reddit-exempt-accessibility-apps-api-pricing-changes https://www.theverge.com/2023/6/7/23752804/reddit-exempt-acc...), r/blind was not contacted for comment on the new development. We have not had clarification on Reddit's definitions of "accessibility focused apps" or any process to determine apps that qualify. There is no clarification on "non-comercial apps," given the current model of the apps listed by The Verge. We have strong concerns that Reddit lacks expertise to consider the varying access needs of the blind and visually impaired community. We have reached out Reddit for further comment. We would also like to note that r/blind, u/rumster in particular, have continuously contacted Reddit over accessibility concerns, over the past 3 years, having received no substantive response. r/blind === https://old.reddit.com/r/Blind/comments/13zr8h2/_/jnbkjed https://old.reddit.com/r/Blind/comments/13zr8h2/_/jnbkjed === As added support, while the article mentions Luna, I would like to contribute that I have not been ccontacted in any way by Reddit whether that is in regards to this article, or the changes as a whole. === https://old.reddit.com/r/Blind/comments/13zr8h2/_/jncxom1 https://old.reddit.com/r/Blind/comments/13zr8h2/_/jncxom1
- decremental 3y ago[dead]
- yardstick 3y agoStupid question but I’m out of the loop here. What’s the main beef with the Reddit site and app? Is it just accessibility and moderation tools or something else? I do use RES in desktop, but I mostly use it via the official mobile app these days. I used to miss old.Reddit.com but now I’m rather indifferent.
- ryanmercer 3y agoAs a long time user, and moderator, I do everything via old.reddit (and the only additional thing is mod toolbox, which I could live without) on a proper computer. I just can't fathom any meaningful use of Reddit via a phone app. To me that's as insane as trying to read a novel on your phone or watch a movie. Simply does not compute to me.
- gremlinsinc 3y agoI've done all these things on my phone, movie, novel, used Reddit, but not the site or the mobile app. I've tried many times thinking maybe it got better, it never did. I use relay and love it. it doesn't have chat but I don't ever use Reddit chat. I'm also not a mod.
- raldi 3y agoHa, I also access the site exclusively through the old web interface, but I do tons of moderation there via my phone, and might phrase it as, it’s as natural as reading a novel on my phone, or watching a movie.
- tester457 3y agoI watch movies, read novels, and even code on my phone but I refuse to use the reddit app. It's that bad.
- doix 3y ago> Is it just accessibility and moderation tools or something else? The information density and UX are terrible in new Reddit and the official app (in my opinion of course). I find them completely and utterly unusable. I just tried opening new Reddit and going to /r/all. I can see exactly 2 posts on my screen, compared to 14 on old Reddit. I tried clicking on something, it opens up in a narrow popover. Middle clicking to open it in a proper tab takes a lot longer than in old Reddit. When it comes to the app, there are similar issues, it's just _so_ much slower than using RiF, the information density is abysmal, comment chains are painful for me to read and it uses _significantly_ more data than RiF. I'm guessing it preloads lots of assets in the background or something. When they kill off 3rd party access, I will stop using it on my mobile. I already feel like I waste too much time on Reddit, ruining the experience will make it much easier to quit. If they ever kill old Reddit, then I guess I'll finally quit Reddit for good or make an extension that makes it look and work like the old version.
- drumhead 3y agoThere is no other site more dependant on its users for its success than Reddit. There is no other site with more militant users that Reddit. If they want to they can and will cause havoc. Do you want to invest in something with such a volatile and uncontrollable workforce? The Reddit management know how this will end, not well.
- plagiarist 3y agoBased on how they've spent years ignoring what moderators ask for to help manage communities; I'm sure they don't give a shit as long as they can cash out.
- janmo 3y agoI operate https://apewisdom.io/ https://apewisdom.io/ I think that I can deal with the new pricing, but only at the condition that Reddit improves its current API, ideally adding websocket support, so that I don't have to pull a complete subreddit every x minutes. Also currently you cannot get all the comments on a thread in one API call, it can take you hundreds to do it, because you can only do so by querying individually nested response when there are many. So it might cost you $1 already just to pull a daily thread under the current API system. Also, you can only query the 500 last submissions (in new / best). The Reddit API as it stands currently really sucks.
- broodbucket 3y agoReddit could have done zero development in the past decade and the website would be more usable today, not less
- some_random 3y agoI don't agree, anecdotally there were a lot of people who bounced off the site because they didn't "get" the UX and even back then we had to fix the site using RIF. Now, was that difficulty a useful filter? Perhaps.
- flutas 3y agoI actually agree with the GP comment. The new UI brought in a bunch of people who turned the site into their personal little estate to lord over the serfs. Example: I just got banned for 3 days because I reported someone for saying "politicians should all be burned alive." ... followed up by a week later reddit telling me they took action on that account because of the comment... Example 2: I just got banned for 7 days because apparently "he's singing like he has a hand up his fa*ot ass" isn't homophobia and instead according to their message I'm > Using Reddit’s reporting tools to spam, harass, bully, intimidate, abuse, or create a hostile environment For context, the only way for these bans to be served is if the mod of the subreddit in which you reported that content reports you for "report abuse."
- broodbucket 3y agoI think having the core website be a blank canvas and letting users choose their preferred interface is completely fine, Reddit was thriving long before the official app and "new reddit" came along. Third party mobile apps did very well and power users (that are responsible for a lot of content and moderation) were happy with RES
- memefrog 3y agoReddit used to constantly break under load. It would throw up 503s at busy times every single day. The user interface was much better but the underlying technology was awful.
- brownfox 3y agoReddit's ideal scenario would involve its users migrating to other platforms while preserving its archived content. Its community was once thriving, but the mismanagement ruined it. Despite reportedly having thousands of employees, Reddit's excessive hiring and ambitious expansion led to wasteful spending. A platform with basic features like Reddit could easily be maintained by a team of fewer than 100 staff members and generate revenue through Google Ads.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- willis936 3y agoI am certain that is not the narrative reddit is selling to potential investors because that is a narrative that does not maximize profit.
- zagrebian 3y agoAre you telling me that Reddit’s accessibility is so bad that there exist popular third-party apps whose only purpose is to make Reddit more accessible?
- Maxburn 3y agoAnd how do you differentiate it from the primary mission of every single other reddit app? It's the entire point of having apps...
- devinprater 3y agoYes. RedditForBlind, Dystopia, and RedReader isn't really for accessibility but is the most accessible on Android, oh and Luna for Reddit.
- Quequau 3y agoReading through the list of concessions and explanations attributed to Steve Huffman that Reddit is currently sending to subreddit moderators, I saw a couple of things that struck as almost certainly untrue or at least exaggerated. I don't think Reddit is approaching this in good faith.
- theknocker 3y ago[dead]
- bloopernova 3y agoThe way reddit seems to be unable to implement useful and complex new features leads me to wonder what their development practices are like. It's like they can only create simple new things, but more complicated stuff is beyond them. Complex features like moderator tools, rate limiting, accessibility, a working video player, and a rich text editor. Are they only hiring the cheapest least experienced developers? Too few devs, or too many managers?
- kelipso 3y agoHas reddit ever had a good reputation in the tech world? I'd rather work a pornhub than reddit and would take a pay cut to work at all of the other big social media companies than reddit. The engineering team seems terrible looking at the website and all its iterations, you'd have to work for people who had hosted all of those repulsive subreddits, the company itself seems very unstable. Probably moot would be more successful IPOing 4chan.
- kurisufag 3y ago4chan was very close to making a loss for every single year m00t was running it. It actually still might be; the only revenue stream is a "4chan pass" that users are actively derided for purchasing and a few individually-funded ads.
- dotnet00 3y agoKind of gives me pre-aquisition Twitter vibes. Although I think Reddit is less bloated than Twitter was as an organization.
- vxNsr 3y agoHmmm… really makes you think, if you spend all day focused on the wrong things and hire based on your own biases you may not end up with a company full of A’s.
- jonplackett 3y agoBut this wouldn’t make any difference for Apollo right? Pretty much every sub I’m on has decided to strike for at least 2 days and there’s quite a weight behind indefinite
- dotnet00 3y agoYeah, I think they're just not saying indefinite because apparently that'd give reddit an excuse to just replace the mods using the excuse of inactivity.
- nhubbard 3y agoA clever way of getting around this would be the mods posting every 30 days (I believe that was the cut-off for inactivity) so that Reddit has no valid excuse to replace them.
- mrguyorama 3y agoA private company is free to interpret their internal rules however they see fit. "Malicious compliance" isn't magic, reddit can replace whoever they want whenever they want and not be guilty of any crime. Mostly they just don't care, because they probably expect most popular subreddits to just come back at some point. People will get bored. Millions of people use reddit through the official app and DGAF that the UX is "bad" because we have spent the past 20 years gaslighting people into feeling like this is just how computers and things ARE
- josefresco 3y agoIs Elon running this company? It's straight out of the Elon/Twitter playbook. Announce a new policy so horrid almost everyone is appalled. Wait a short period of time and then make a small/token exception for a sympathetic community and reap the media rewards. Wait a short time and then roll out former said horrid policy with less outrage because of fatigue and the newly muddied waters. Brilliantly evil.
- asveikau 3y agoI was thinking it was more of a Zuckerberg strategy. At various points in Facebook's early history, users would voice protest about new features, such as news feed. They pretty much ignored the feedback and let it keep growing beyond the size of the critics. Reddit probably doesn't have as much growth as fb did of course.
- arbitrarian 3y agoWell, this is weird. I'm totally blind, and I use Apollo precisely because it is accessible. So now what Reddit?
- webdoodle 3y agoThis whole drama is so absent logic, I can only conclude that Reddit is intentionally committing seppuku. After breaking every moral promise they've made with their users, they still can't control the narrative that their Billionaire overlords require of them. So they are breaking Reddit so bad, hoping nobody stays.
- jmull 3y agoNew Rule: We'll being kicking everyone hard in the jewels, every month! <outrage ensues> Correction: ... *Except the blind <everyone's OK now?> This is great. Nobody likes the idea of excluding disabled people. But does it really get to the heart of the issue? It's actually a pretty high bar for someone to decide to use anything besides the default client. More or less everyone using apps depending on these APIs has what, to them, was an important reason. It's great this exemption addresses one of those important reasons, but it's just one of so many.
- redavni 3y agoAre there any disabilities involving bacon preference? What kind of features would enable the bacon-preferential spectrum community to participate more fully in the Reddit?
- dogleash 3y agoIsn't this tacit admission that their pricing is meant to squeeze out third party apps?
- mock-possum 3y agoNot good enough.
- hourago 3y agoSince Twitter fired so much developers, started to price its APIs and monetize its blue marks there are two different reactions: - The Venture Capitalists see these moves as the best thing that ever happened. A way top put employees (mostly the software developers) and users (that get things for free) in their place. - The consumers and employees see that the value that Twitter provided is disappearing fast as much as employer as a platform. Many VC backed companies, and other that do not, seem to be following Twitter trends. Let's see if they are right and they can lower salaries to employees and increase prices for consumers, or if they overestimated their capability to do so. Reddit is just another example of this trend.
- deafpolygon 3y agoJust damage control at this point.