28 ms·
One example of where this would apply is for instance against criminals whose medium of information exchange has been compromised. Yes, they are 'victims', but
by jacquesm 3y ago
One example of where this would apply is for instance against criminals whose medium of information exchange has been compromised. Yes, they are 'victims', but they are also perps and probably in much worse crimes than the original hack of their comms.
An example of such a situation is the EncroChat hack.
- daenney 3y agoIt also applies to all victims of hackers, irrespective of whether the victims themselves are supposedly criminals or not. So if you get hacked, then suddenly the government can hack you too. No amount of hypothetical "it could also be used against criminals" balances out the bonkers overreach this represents.
- jacquesm 3y agoIn theory yes, but in practice this hasn't happened and I really don't expect it to happen. I've seen enough of LE in NL up close to have an idea of how it all hangs together and this article definitely has a point: the law should be worded more carefully but at the same time it isn't going to get out of hand the way the article would have you believe. Plenty of oversight here and judges that take conflicting laws fairly seriously (such as the GDPR, but also laws regarding the gathering of evidence and such). NL has lots of problems, but lack of judicial oversight over both the police and the intelligence services isn't one of them, in fact you could make a pretty good argument that the degree of oversight actually hinders going after tech savvy criminals. But better too much than too little. This law won't change that by much as far as I can see.
- ar-jan 3y agoYou say "this hasn't happened" and "plenty of oversight", but the president of the review committee just resigned because of this. And she isn't allowed to inform the public nor parliament of what has already been happening, even before this change. As in, examples of the type of surveillance already happening have been redacted from the annual report of the review committee [0]. The annual report was specifically made to omit operational details and only inform of the general picture, but parts have been declared state secret. The now ex-president of the review committee stated she could not inform parliament because she did not want to go to prison for 15 years [1]. 0: https://www.tweedekamer.nl/kamerstukken/detail?id=2023Z05165&did=2023D12102 https://www.tweedekamer.nl/kamerstukken/detail?id=2023Z05165... 1: https://debatdirect.tweedekamer.nl/2023-03-30/binnenlandse-zaken/groen-van-prinstererzaal/technische-briefing-door-ctivd-en-tib-over-de-tijdelijke-wet-cyberoperaties-17-30/video https://debatdirect.tweedekamer.nl/2023-03-30/binnenlandse-z...
- costco 3y ago"Going dark" is a scam - https://crimesciencejournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s40163-023-00185-4 https://crimesciencejournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.11... for instance found that there was no difference in conviction rate for cases involving E2EE encryption vs those that didn't in the Netherlands. The government just wants the halcyon period of surveillance from late 1900s to the early 2000s back but these supposed tech savvy criminals almost never turn out to exist.
- jacquesm 3y agoThat's a different context entirely. Obviously the intelligence services would love to be able to tap phones the way they were able to in the past as well as to read all of your mail. But in practice the network analysis is as much or even more efficient than reading the mail itself in the investigation phase of a case.
- hulitu 3y agoAnother example are opposition's politicians.
- radicalbyte 3y agoThe thing is, is that we've had an oversight commission who reacted quickly to decide in those cases. That worked, it provided oversight. Now they want free reign to spy on everyone.
- jacquesm 3y agoWanting something and getting it aren't the same thing and it wouldn't be the first time that something like this gets enacted and then gets shut down again. My main worry would be journalists, those are at some danger from stuff like this especially when they are protecting their sources. If this ever gets abused that's where I would expect it to happen.
- coldtea 3y agoThat's one of the prime real uses cases they'd care about...
- jacquesm 3y agoYes, and clearly there should be a very pointed note about journalists in this law if it is to be put into practice. But for the likes that use(d) EncroChat I'm all for it. Btw, both lawyers and journalists have quite a few special protections under Dutch law and it isn't clear to me that this proposal would trump those protections, in fact if challenged I would expect the judiciary to affirm that those protections carry the most weight.
- ahubert 3y agoAuthor here - the protections remain in theory, but will not longer be active beforehand. It is possible that the oversight committee finds the time to check afterwards, but they aren't obliged to do so. Also, by then the damage is done.
- jacquesm 3y agoYes, that's the risk, but: similar issues have been flagged in the past and in the end oversight won out so I'm not quite as worried as you are. A typical scenario is that a hacker is using a series of nested accesses to compromised systems, if the original warrant allows for tracking the hacker on the first system then there is no time to obtain warrants for the systems that are uncloaked as the result of the investigation, this happens pretty much in real time. So this provision allows the investigation to proceed and will have a reasonable time allowed to 'catch up'. It definitely is possible that it will be abused, but that will lead to this provision being disbanded, as has happened in the past when dutch LE overstepped their authority. I'm fairly sure that those lessons - and the cases thrown out as a result - have been learned, but of course it is very well possible that we'll see a re-run. I'm on the fence on this one, I'd say let's see where it leads because it is clear to me that the digital world is moving much faster than law enforcement can normally speaking keep up with and a lot of crime is perpetrated because of that. The risk of abuse of such methods is always present, and 'protections in theory' that are abused tend to find very unsympathetic judges in this country. It's fairly clear that something will have to change if LE is to keep up with the increase in online crime, whether this overshoots the mark or not remains - in my view - to be seen. It definitely has that risk, but then again, so would every other proposal short of the status quo and that clearly isn't effective enough.