3 ms·
We've currently got the West panicking about a war in eastern Europe and ratcheting up the escalations (speaking of, I see we now have a couple of incursions in
by roenxi 3y ago
We've currently got the West panicking about a war in eastern Europe and ratcheting up the escalations (speaking of, I see we now have a couple of incursions into bone fide Russian territory - hope they weren't armed with NATO weapons). The odds of a global nuclear conflict are hopefully not in the double digit percentages, but I can't see why they aren't at a historic high in history.
Before that, we had mass lockdowns, economies shut down and people under something that wasn't house arrest because it was too industrialised. based mainly on evidence that turned out to be wrong and with solutions that didn't work as advertised.
Prior to that, we were seeing the start of the general economic catastrophe likely because the major economies refuse to let people secure long term access to cheap energy. There has been a big push to lock economies into inflationary currencies that are being used to prop up what appear to be failed, wealth destroying businesses. There is a pretence that companies making regular sustained losses are normal and investable.
I don't want to talk about seatbelts. I don't think they are that important. I don't care. I want people to stop this hyper-collective power accumulation that is doing a remarkable amount of damage. All of the major problems are being caused by huge, centralised moves of organised and (in 2 of 3) frightened people not thinking clearly about where priorities ought to sit. We knew all the way through that people aren't good at predicting outcomes of policy.
- nathan_compton 3y agoI'd argue that none of these things are hyper-collective, though. These things are authoritarian. I'm not going to argue with you about the Covid response. But in the case of economic management, the policies you describe aren't meant to benefit the collective. They are meant to benefit a small elite.
- baremetal 3y ago[flagged]
- nathan_compton 3y agoCool story bro.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- digging 3y ago> All of the major problems are being caused by huge, centralised moves of organised and (in 2 of 3) frightened people not thinking clearly about where priorities ought to sit. This is not true of all major problems, most are caused by greed (corporate and individual). Of the ones caused by fear-based centralized power, that's authoritarianism, not collectivism. I can tell because the line I quoted perfectly describes what's happening in my decidedly non-collectivist state government (and many others) to threaten my well-being and potentially my life.
- Aerbil313 3y agoThat power accumulation is inevitable when modern technology is used by humans, or aliens, or AI, or anything with the instinct of survival and self-replication, argues anti-technologist Ted Kaczynski. See the book Technological Slavery, free on internet archive.
- n4r9 3y agoJust a note that mandated mask-wearing, stay-at-home orders and business closures happened in the 1918 Spanish flu in much the same way. The world didn't suddenly became more authoritarian in the last ten years.
- roenxi 3y agoThat was also part of an iconic period that marked the lull between 2 of the bloodiest wars in human history and the partial collapse of civilisation in Europe, if not for the benevolence of the US in helping it to repair. Presaged one of the worst periods of economic collapse too. If authoritarianism is on par with the 1920s we are in very bad shape. That was part of the incubation period for the people who ended up shovelling Jews into ovens.
- n4r9 3y agoYou have a very odd way of framing historical events. The US govt's own website contradicts the claim that assistance with rebuilding Europe was out of "benevolence": > The necessities of commercial growth dictated continued government support for overseas private investment. That, in turn, drove the United States to further engage with both with Latin America and the rebuilding of Europe in the 1920s. https://history.state.gov/milestones/1921-1936/foreword https://history.state.gov/milestones/1921-1936/foreword Regardless, all of the policies I mentioned happened in the US, which was nowhere near as affected by the war (albeit disillusioned with it).
- roenxi 3y agoI'm just saying; we both seem to be pointing out that current policies look a lot like the sort of thing that might have been found in the 1920s. The 1920s turned out to be setting up the 1930s, where people thought it couldn't get worse. Then the 1940s where they were proven wrong. I don't know why you expect me to relax when you compare the situation to 1918. 1918 was when the seeds were being planted for one of the greatest episodes of suffering that the world has seen to date. The policies set in motion around then and the philosophies in vogue around then were indefensible disasters. The upside of the 1950s->2020s was that people were so shaken by the failures of 1910->1950 that they changed tack. The ones that didn't, in China and the USSR, who doubled down on authoritarianism then turned into their own disasters but at least they focused inwards. The US can consider itself lucky that it only had to deal with the great depression and an acceptable rate of needless war casualties. > You have a very odd way of framing historical events. The US govt's own website contradicts the claim that assistance with rebuilding Europe was out of "benevolence": That is nitpicking. Investing huge amounts of money to rebuild a shattered continent is benevolent no matter what the motivations of the US government's website happens to say. People do things for reasons. Sometimes they do things that are benevolent because it benefits them.
- peppermint_gum 3y ago>The odds of a global nuclear conflict are hopefully not in the double digit percentages, but I can't see why they aren't at a historic high in history. It's not even close. There are many precedents for nuclear powers fighting each other directly without triggering a nuclear war. For instance: - The Korean War. It wasn't a proxy war, Western troops were directly fighting Chinese soldiers and the Soviet air force. - The Sino-Soviet border conflict in 1969. Two nuclear powers fighting each other directly on their own soil. - Indo-Pakistani conflicts. Both have nuclear weapons and they fight each other on their own soil. - Indo-Chinese conflicts. I'm not advocating for it, but I'm fairly certain that even a direct NATO intervention in Ukraine wouldn't lead to a nuclear war. Hell, Putin might even welcome it, it would give him a good excuse for the poor performance of his troops.
- pixl97 3y ago>I want people to stop this hyper-collective power accumulation that is doing a remarkable amount of damage. So why don't you get a bunch of people together with like minds that believe in the same thing to form a voting/power block of your representative views... Oh, oops. I'm having an extremely hard time not being snarky to the complete unawareness you have in this post. It really represents the peak ability of libertarians to ride the coattails of an already established power system while being blissfully incognizant of it.
- brookst 3y agoI won't repeat what others have said. I'll just encourage you to question your own beliefs just a little bit. Setting aside hot button topics, currency cannot be perfectly neutral. It is either inflationary or deflationary. Inflation is much much much much much preferable to deflation. These are big topics. You're taking a very reductive, binary approach, and it's hard to even engage with.