4 ms·
> You can't decentralize the decision to (e.g.) increase or decrease criminal sentence length by ten per cent. Sure we could; different laws in different locat
by roenxi 3y ago
> You can't decentralize the decision to (e.g.) increase or decrease criminal sentence length by ten per cent.
Sure we could; different laws in different locations; let people see what works. That is how the world does things now - note that different countries have different legal codes and by experiment everyone comes to a sort-of consensus on what works, with lots of variance between jurisdictians when people don't agree.
That diversity of law can be re-done at any practical scale. I quite like the idea of different cities having different laws (oh, for the world to have a few more Hong Kongs in it! And note how well single-city legal entities usually do).
- pixl97 3y agoI mean, we already have that. For state crimes we have state sentencing, for federal crimes we have federal sentencing. >That diversity of law can be re-done at any practical scale. Eh..... Only at an extreme cost. I mean in a few minutes of actually thinking about the problem I hope you could see how this would totally fall apart. For example you live in BumFkt Nebraska and sell widget X. Totally legal in BumFkt. Your neighbors in Timbuktu Nebraska order X on your website and you ship to them. Oops, you've both committed felonies in Timbuktu, and now if you ever go there you'll be arrested on site and imprisoned. Typically every state constitution in the US holds itself as the highest authority in that state. Cities and make their own regulations, but the state is the final arbiter in setting the limits to their power to keep petty squabbling shit from damaging the citizens of said state. After that the federal government can step in, and quite often has as some particular states love to violate human rights dependant on the minority group you're in.