3 ms·
You are familiar with terminus post quem? Genomic evidence and things like tree-ring dates often provide "no later than" evidence and so your observations to "b
by ggm 3y ago
You are familiar with terminus post quem? Genomic evidence and things like tree-ring dates often provide "no later than" evidence and so your observations to "but 80 years" are true, and reasonable, but also conjectural: find a document, get an artefact, or.. it's terminus post quem. (I'm sure you know this)
Within a few moments of being shown steel artefacts, islanders depending on stone age tools sought to obtain them, no matter how small, from sailors. It wouldn't surprise me if the first artefacts consciously designed to be sold to islander indigenous peoples has a 10-20 year lag, for whaling ships to realise it was better to source cheap knives to sell, than sell their own goods. Whaling ships stayed at sea for 2 or more seasons so it's easy to get to 5, 10 years purely on the mechanistic dynamics.
What percentage of written evidence to islander trade remains esablishes in like sense terminus post quem. If only one diary in a hundred survives, what chance it's the first one in time?
Patrick O'Brien writes of a reader complaining that his use of eau de cologne in georgean naval fiction is anachronistic. He responds in print that whilst written evidence of eau de cologne may lag his fictions time by 20 years he has little doubt people were using it, before they wrote about it. Analogous I feel.