3 ms·
What confidence do we have that we'd actually observe these probes? If one was orbiting, say, Saturn or Jupiter (or one of their moons) right now, would we def
by kelnos 3y ago
What confidence do we have that we'd actually observe these probes? If one was orbiting, say, Saturn or Jupiter (or one of their moons) right now, would we definitely have seen it? Or if it were something in a wide solar orbit?
And then there's the general time scale. I agree that half a million years (or even 10 million years) isn't much in the grand scheme of things. But it matters to us: what if this alien civilization sent them out 50 thousand years ago? They may not have gotten to us yet. Or what if they were sent out 100 million years ago? It's unclear if they'd still exist today, or if they would have broken down, their repair and replication systems failing after all those years; even if they are still around, maybe the civilization that sent them out doesn't exist anymore.
Also consider that building these probes is pretty much at or beyond the limit of our technological capabilities right now. We might be able to build enough of them as a seed fleet if we devoted tens of trillions of dollars to the project. And accelerating something to 0.1c is nothing to sneeze at either. Remember that they also have to decelerate from that speed in order to find targets for mining in order to fuel themselves and their replication systems, or even just to enter orbit around a planet or star. They'd require some pretty advanced software to run them, too.
I've seen quite a few articles and videos on Von Neumann probes, created by people I respect, but even many of them acknowledge that building these and sending these out would not be a small undertaking. A civilization that did so would have to be at a point where they've solved most of their problems at home (or be in dire need of finding a new home, but at the same time able to wait thousands or millions of years to find one) before they could justify taking this on.
(Remember, the person upthread isn't talking about the mere existence of aliens. They were talking about the improbability of us having some evidence or experience of their existence.)