5 ms·
I wonder if the test was "crafted" to carefully avoid classing some species as sentient. For example, what if chickens suddenly went off the food market? (man
by m463 3y ago
I wonder if the test was "crafted" to carefully avoid classing some species as sentient.
For example, what if chickens suddenly went off the food market?
(many bird species exhibit really intelligent behavior - would they fit the bill?)
- viraptor 3y agoChickens (and many other animals) are already classified as sentient. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/may/12/animals-to-be-formally-recognised-as-sentient-beings-in-uk-law https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/may/12/animals-to-be-... It doesn't stop us eating them. Just tries to stop being pointlessly cruel while they're alive.
- psychphysic 3y agoI've never really understood the significance. Cows are sentient, does that mean the guy who artificially inseminates them is raping them?
- baliex 3y agoNot an expert but, yes. The purpose of introducing this kind of law is to continue to expand the legal recognition of what we now consider to be ethical, based on our continually expanding understanding of the world. The cows aren’t in a position to protest in some animal rights movement, so some interested (and compassionate) humans are working on their behalf.
- afiori 3y agoIt is legal to toss a rock, a small bush, a mosquito, or a earthworm into a fire in most places. In those same places it is likely illegal to toss a live cat into a fire. In this context sentience is about "should I care about how this clump of atom _feels_" and/or "it is possible to be unduly cruel to this clump of atoms". In farming it mostly means that you cannot cause unnecessary suffering too much outside of the Overton window; not about recognizing bodily autonomy to cattle.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- shafyy 3y ago> Cows are sentient, does that mean the guy who artificially inseminates them is raping them? Yes
- whamlastxmas 3y agoIn the commonly accepted and emotionally charged connotation of rape, no. Inseminating a cow is likely no different to the cow than an antibiotic shot.
- LinXitoW 3y agoIn that very definition, it is rape. Look at any thread on any social media platform featuring bestiality, esp. regarding dogs or cats. The vast majority of people will explicitly use the word rape, and also call for all kinds of horrible punishments for the perpetrator. I can think of no sensible, morally relevant difference between these instances and what happens to female animals through artificial insemination. "It doesnt hurt" isn't an excuse, because you can certainly think of bestiality that doesn't hurt the animal (or features physical pain to the same degree as artificial insemination).
- whamlastxmas 3y agoIf I squirt medicine from the vet into my cat's mouth, am I raping my cat?
- dmbche 3y agoCan you identify differences between insemination and squirting medecine in your cats mouth?
- hgsgm 3y ago> many bird species exhibit really intelligent behavior - would they fit the bill?) Duck, yes. Chicken, no.
- dieselgate 3y agoYou have beak evidence to assert that claim
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pjaoko 3y agoGoat, yes. Sheep, no.
- whamlastxmas 3y agoAre humans with an IQ of 60 subhuman?
- lost_tourist 3y agoNope it was crafted that the above critters should be killed quickly and humanely and say not boiled alive or chopped in little pieces and eaten raw by humans while still alive. Chickens and other birds definitely fall under their sentient species law.