3 ms·
It also has a legal obligation to the US government and the US courts, a government I have no right to elect and a legal system I cannot afford. Generally, if
by tomkarlo 15y ago
It also has a legal obligation to the US government and the US courts, a government I have no right to elect and a legal system I cannot afford.
Generally, if you're not in the US (and I'm assuming that's what you mean, not that you're disenfranchised but live in the US), then Google and other US companies have an obligation to comply with the laws of your country, assuming their terms of service allow use in your nation.
Ultimately, you have a choice to use or not use a service. The Company offering it has an obligation to disclose what information is collected and how it's used, and you also have to make an assessment of their ability to protect that data from misuse either internally or by external parties. We make these decisions all the time both online and offline.
I think it's fine for folks to opt out of using a service like Google if they no longer agree with the privacy policy. I don't think it's appropriate to villanize any company for good-faith efforts to update their privacy disclosure over time as long as you can opt out of those changes and erase your data. And I think we have to be realistic and expect that for 95% of users, they're not going to opt out.
- fauigerzigerk 15y agoI simply explained what my concerns are and why I'm opting out. I think that is a perfectly appropriate thing to do and has nothing to do with villainizing anyone. I also think that it would be appropriate for you to disclose that you work for Google if you contribute to a discussion like this one taking the side of your employer.
- tomkarlo 15y agoI appreciate your view on that, but I'm expressly not posting on behalf of Google or in my role as a Google employee. I don't think it would make sense to clutter the HN threads with disclaimers considering that just about every topic here that involves a tech company will have folks from that company posting, or who have investments in those companies. It's not as if I keep it secret who I work for.