3 ms·
> This feels very hand wavy, to me. This is how the system works. "Code is law" does not apply to actual law; it's a long history of interpretation, wiggle roo
by ceejayoz 3y ago
> This feels very hand wavy, to me.
This is how the system works. "Code is law" does not apply to actual law; it's a long history of interpretation, wiggle room, precedent, legislative intent, and common sense being applied in various amounts. It works pretty well, all things considered; far more than trying to explicitly write down every little edge case.
- taeric 3y agoAh, completely agreed. But we can't lean on "it is easy, the Howey test explains all" without a huge caveat. I will note that this particular path is treading on the "lets write down every edge case." As such, it would be better to have a slightly stronger guideline than that. Specifically, when the law is "this test, except for specific carve outs that all fail the test", that is a pretty bad law. Unless there is some unification of the carve outs other than "we decided these don't apply."