3 ms·
I like this guys content generally, but it's worth noting in this instance he's unknowingly echo-ing free-market libertarian dogma. > You might hear comments f
by ZeroGravitas 3y ago
I like this guys content generally, but it's worth noting in this instance he's unknowingly echo-ing free-market libertarian dogma.
> You might hear comments from time to time about studies showing Dvorak is "no better than QWERTY," or words to that effect. All such comments that I've heard seem to echo an article, "The Fable of the Keys," by S. J. Liebowitz and Stephen E. Margolis, published in the Journal of Law & Economics, vol. XXXIII (April 1990).
> Note the word "economics." Liebowitz and Margolis are economists opposed to an "excessive inertia" theory, for which QWERTY is often cited as an example. Rather than try to prove their point with a generally valid argument, they simply attack Dvorak as a dubious replacement for QWERTY. As the article's last footnote explains, there are a number of other possible reasons for Dvorak's failure to replace QWERTY, besides a perceived lack of value. The article ignores those reasons, however, and perpetrates that false perception in a nicely self-fulfilling way.
https://web.archive.org/web/20050204023432/http://www.mwbrooks.com/dvorak/dissent.html https://web.archive.org/web/20050204023432/http://www.mwbroo...
- bediger4000 3y agoI haven't looked in a few years, but "The Fable of the Keys" was not available on the web. I had to slip into CU's library to find it on microfiche. Unimpressive paper, no original research, just pot shots at old Navy and Dvorak experiments. Economists call "excessive inertia" "path dependence".
- causi 3y agoWhat makes that libertarian dogma?
- lern_too_spel 3y agoPath dependence is a kind of market failure. Libertarians like to pretend that market failure does not exist in free markets because market failure implies market intervention. The authors of "The Fable of the Keys" have frequently argued against the existence of path dependence. https://eh.net/encyclopedia/path-dependence/ https://eh.net/encyclopedia/path-dependence/