3 ms·
Posts on Hacker News related to LiquidPiston go back 11(!) years. The most comments are on this post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25450477 https://news
by xnx 3y ago
Posts on Hacker News related to LiquidPiston go back 11(!) years. The most comments are on this post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25450477 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25450477
If this was going to revolutionize anything, it would've happened by now.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoI think any engine design that was popularized was backed by a car company, even the Wankel engine. If they want to make this design popular, they need to design products around it so their claims are proven. I mean I still don't believe Tesla's primary business model is cars; the competition is outselling them left right and center. Theirs is batteries and charging infrastructure. That's a huge market that can fuel the company for a century if they play their cards right.
- 7jjjjjjj 3y agoTesla doesn't make their batteries, they buy them from Panasonic.
- dreamcompiler 3y agoIf you have evidence that Tesla doesn't make batteries, perhaps you should alert their shareholders that the company is lying on this page: https://www.tesla.com/giga-nevada https://www.tesla.com/giga-nevada
- ngvrnd 3y agocells are not the same thing as batteries; it's possible tesla is making batteries with cells from Panasonic or whatever.
- taylodl 3y agoYou're both right. Tesla doesn't make battery cells, they make battery packs. A battery pack is comprised of several battery cells, for example the Model Y has over 4,000 cells in its battery pack.
- dreamcompiler 3y agoThey certainly appear to be making cells now too. https://cleantechnica.com/2020/09/22/everything-you-need-to-know-about-teslas-new-4680-battery-cell/ https://cleantechnica.com/2020/09/22/everything-you-need-to-... https://electrek.co/2023/04/21/tesla-update-4680-battery-cell/ https://electrek.co/2023/04/21/tesla-update-4680-battery-cel...
- taylodl 3y agoWow! That's huge! They're doing a good job of positioning themselves as being the world's best source of batteries. Honestly, Tesla Energy is looking to eclipse Tesla as the main source of recurring revenue.
- kamranjon 3y agoIs Tesla really doing that bad at sales? The Model Y just became the worlds best selling car.
- ngvrnd 3y agoI have this feeling that all of Musk's comnpanies are technology development ventures intended to support his primary goal of getting humans to live off-earth. Note: I am not defending his goal, or idolizing him. But consider: boring company: finance learning about tunnel construction; tunnels needed on moon or mars for habitation; solar cells: very useful on moon or mars; hyperloop: finance learning about vacuum seals and related technology. My explanation makes much more sense for each of these than the ostensible goal of the company. which brings me to the point in Cthulhu's post: tesla is selling cars to understand the techne of energy storage for use in space habs.
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agothere isn't a single product elmu could produce for which a tenuous connection couldn't be imagined apples? well he's just learning about agriculture, which we will need on Mars toilets? well, people poop on Mars, too overpriced AV cables? well, obviously Mars will need high end cables for stuff
- basch 3y agoYou would need a lot of the same tech to terraform Earth, or make Earth habitable, if it became unso.
- bogwog 3y agoThe overproduced site/video gives off strong crypto scam energy. There’s a big INVEST NOW button with a very low dollar amount, and I like how they even threw in the line about being an immigrant from Ukraine as if to capitalize on current events. I’m sure they’re not a “scam” though, just a poor investment.
- toss1 3y agoYup Seven-ish years ago while working on a hybrid-powered UAV I was checking out high power/weight engine platforms. I found a significant variety of regular Wankel engines that had MUCH better power/weight ratios and were available for purchase (not "real soon now"). Since power/weight is Liquid Piston's main claim to fame, this is rather important. Today, a quick DDG search similarly returns many Wankel-based engines that definitely have better powr-weight ratios than Liquid Piston. The primary markets seem to be lightweight aircraft and some motorbikes. The first one is AIE 80S [0]. It puts out 15BHP/11.2kW at 5kg/11 Lbs. AIE's 225CS puts out 40BHP/30kW at 10kg [1]. In contrast, Liquid Piston's XS-210 weighs 21kg/46.7 Lbs to produce 19kW/26HP (third page of PDF spec sheet in button on [2]). The net power/weight for these Wankels is 2.24kW/kg and 3.0 kW/kg. Compare this to the Liquid Piston XS210 0.9kW/kg. Liquid Pistoin's main advertised performance is between 1/2 and 1/3 of an already available Wankel. And there are many more Wankel options. Plus, despite power/weight being Liquid Piston's main claim to fame, I have to wade through multiple pages, multiple "Invest Now!" popups, to finally dig down to their PDF spec sheet to even find an actual weight figure. In contrast, whereas the Wankel's pages post it right up front. It is quite obvious that the Liquid Piston people know that they are not even close on their main claim to fame, yet are willing to just act as if they are the best available and count on people not actually doing their due diligence. They literally look like they are in the same position as 7-8 years ago, "ohh we have this great lightweight new technology, shipping real soon now -- get in on the ground floor!!" I used to look at it as "maybe they'll get better". But at this point, it is pretty clear that they know they have nothing groundbreaking and are just trying to ride it as long as possible. TBF, they MAY have a possible market using JP-8 fuel which is widely used and available in military contexts. But Wankels have been adapted to many different fuels and it would only be a temporary advantage if someone wants to get into this market. Don't be parted from your money here.... [0] https://www.aieuk.com/80s-15bhp-wankel-rotary-engine/ https://www.aieuk.com/80s-15bhp-wankel-rotary-engine/ [1] https://www.aieuk.com/225cs-40bhp-wankel-rotary-engine/ https://www.aieuk.com/225cs-40bhp-wankel-rotary-engine/ [2] https://www.liquidpiston.com/xts-210-engine https://www.liquidpiston.com/xts-210-engine
- aredox 3y agoThe main selling point of LP would be in durability - I'm sure once liquidPiston patents are expired, better engineering firms will produce better Wankel engines with their design. LP doesn't seem to execute well.