3 ms·
A good overview but a bit short on details. Some crucial things that got omitted (and are generally valid across Central Europe - no idea about the US, India an
by mschuster91 3y ago
A good overview but a bit short on details. Some crucial things that got omitted (and are generally valid across Central Europe - no idea about the US, India and other places notorious for railway accidents):
- signals, both "old" mechanical and modern filament/LED light based, are continuously monitored for their status. If a wire breaks (for mechanical signals) or the current is abnormal, a fault is detected by the interlock control and there are rigid procedures on how to operate safely under such conditions.
- Signals have some sort of direct connection to a railside element communicating the status of the signal (go/slow/stop) to the locomotive. In the case of the most common used system PZB [1], it's a box containing a tuned inductor circuit, with the resonance frequency changing according to the status of the signal by connecting or disconnecting a capacitor (which can also be done by a mechanical signal). The train drives over these boxes and the locomotive's antenna detects driving over a tuned or mistuned box. The French use a system applying a low voltage to a third, short center rail that gets picked up by a brush [2] or, for high-speed rails, a low-frequency FM carrier signal transmitted over the rails [3].
- railway sections are sub-divided into "blocks", spaced at least a full brake distance from full speed apart. Signals signal to conductors what to do, and axle counters or DC monitors verify a block of rail is free of trains. The purpose of all that effort is to make sure that a) even in the worst case of a conductor missing a red light at full speed, the safety system has enough time to stop the train before it crashes into the train ahead and b) should a train separate and someone made an error in linking the central brake pipe (leading to the front part not braking automatically), the axle counter will detect that less axles came out of the block than came into it. It has the obvious disadvantage that a lot of capacity is wasted by the requirement to have one entirely empty block between trains; as a consequence systems like ETCS or LZB got developed that monitor position, speed and condition of trains and provide a virtual "moving block" leading to better utilization. In the long term, ETCS will lead to a complete elimination of track-side signals and eventually pave the way towards fully automated driving - but that's many decades away.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punktf%C3%B6rmige_Zugbeeinflussung https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Punktf%C3%B6rmige_Zugbeeinflus...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crocodile_(train_protection_system) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crocodile_(train_protection_sy...
[3] https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transmission_Voie-Machine https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transmission_Voie-Machine
- iggldiggl 3y ago> even in the worst case of a conductor missing a red light at full speed, the safety system has enough time to stop the train before it crashes into the train ahead For legacy systems that's not generally true, especially outside of rapid transit applications. This is because most legacy train protection systems can only intervene (if at all – some systems like the British AWS only require the driver to acknowledge a warning and don't actually stop the train even if it passes a signal at danger) when the train actually passes the signal, and at that point it's already too late and a mainline train at full speed will still require several hundred metres or even up into the kilometre range to come to a stop. Spacing signals that far apart is impractical (it's not just about the signal-to-signal spacing on the plain line, but also how close to a junction signals can be placed and things like that), so most mainline railways didn't bother and only provide a limited "overlap" that gives some margin for mis-judged braking and similar incidents, but doesn't cater for a full-speed signal overrun. (And some countries like e.g. the Netherlands don't really do overlaps at all.) Reliably stopping trains within such a limited (not full braking distance) length overlap requires a train protection system which can react not just when the train actually passes the signal, but also if it approaches the signal too fast to stop in time, and only a limited number of legacy train protection systems possess that capability (and even then maybe only in a partial fashion). Things are somewhat different on rapid transit-style railways, where lower speeds mean that a full-length overlap (to go hand-in-hand with a simple trainstop-style train protection system of the day) isn't quite as ridiculously long and more practical to implement, and the combination of frequent trains with high passenger loadings in constrained surrounding (and therefore bigger risks in the case of accidents) also provided a higher impetus for improved safety measures than on mainline railways even one hundred years ago. > It has the obvious disadvantage that a lot of capacity is wasted by the requirement to have one entirely empty block between trains Even with modern cab signalling trains are usually spaced apart based on absolute braking distance (i.e. even if the train ahead came to a sudden, instantaneous stop, the following train could still safely stop. Even if you wanted to be more adventurous and allow spacing based on relative braking distance, a set of points/turnout that requires changing between successive trains effectively acts as a stationary obstacle, effectively returning you back to absolute braking distance.) The capacity loss with conventional signalling happens because the actual spacing then needs to be quantised and rounded up based on the actual signal spacing. > spaced at least a full brake distance from full speed apart. Sub-braking distance block lengths aren't anything too unusual, though with conventional signalling there's usually a limit to how fine you can sub-divide your regular braking distance. With more modern systems on the other hand, simulating "moving" block by just providing a large number of very short fixed blocks has been done and is entirely practicable. The motivation for true moving block is hoping to save on the installation costs for axle counters and suchlike.