4 ms·
Give development a few years and it'll be faster than a human.
by mschuster91 3y ago
Give development a few years and it'll be faster than a human.
- jacquesm 3y agoDepending on the task it may well already be faster than a human at equivalent performance.
- MrBuddyCasino 3y agoNeurons are very complex and not just on/off switches. We can't even fully simulate the ~300 neurons of c. elegans, not even close.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoA lot of that complexity comes from them being living cells, optimized for and functioning in a different environment than our silicon-based machines. We don't need to model it all. (Though we do need to pay attention to evolution cheating by overfitting relative to what we'd consider a clean design. Some of the complexity may be doing double duty.)
- MrBuddyCasino 3y ago> Some of the complexity may be doing double duty. Since we have not succeeded in imitating even the most primitive brains, even though computationally we should have enough juice by now, it would seem that complexity can't be discarded at all, no?
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> Since we have not succeeded in imitating even the most primitive brains, even though computationally we should have enough juice by now looks at the browser tab with GPT-4 in it looks back again here ... we didn't?
- AstralStorm 3y agoWe didn't. Try to get ChatGPT through a maze a C. Elegans can solve in minutes. (That slow mostly because pond scum moves slowly.) Seriously, get it to successfully play through a text adventure maze game.
- mschuster91 3y agoThe problem with ChatGPT is it lacks the context depth for more complex tasks - but that is a computation resource limit, not a technical one.
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> Seriously, get it to successfully play through a text adventure maze game. I did exactly that the other day in response to a different objection on a HN thread. Or at least similar enough. https://cloud.typingmind.com/share/c0a68cb2-5f59-4e83-b383-bcd7aad497f2 https://cloud.typingmind.com/share/c0a68cb2-5f59-4e83-b383-b... Now, the goal there wasn't to get it to solve a maze, but rather to see how it can come up with a plan of action and adjust it on the fly. But I see no reason a variant of that wouldn't work with a traditional maze game - provided you remember this is a stateless model without volatile memory, so it needs to be fed its memory with every request.
- MrBuddyCasino 3y agoNo we haven't. ChatGPT is basically a sophisticated Markov chain. It is very good at pattern matching, but it has no understanding of anything, or its own will. People who think is even close to AGI are deluded, fooled by an elaborate Mechanical Turk. This is also the reason why its output sounds convincing, but is very often factually wrong.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoI disagree, but that's beside the point here. You yourself narrowed the scope to: "imitating even the most primitive brains, even though computationally we should have enough juice by now" Which is kind of weird to claim today. GPT-4 may be the strongest counterexample to date, but it's far from the only one. Of course, you need to remember not to confuse the brain with attached peripherals. Just because we can't replicate a perfect worm or fly body, complete with bioelectrical and biomechanical components, doesn't mean we can't do better than their brains in silico.
- mrguyorama 3y agoSlime molds and single celled creatures can learn things despite having ZERO neurons. Neurons are built on top of an already incredibly complex machine evaluating hundreds of thousands of chemical and physical interactions per second that ALL effect how the cell works. We aren't likely ever going to reduce that to a model as simple as the one used in machine learning, because it probably isn't that simple period. Neurons are not "just" electrical signalling devices. They are complicated processors and systems in their own right.