5 ms·
Really? Why? What makes driving a stranger around in your car so much more dangerous than driving your wife and kids around? It's absolutely crazy. The bus com
by mseebach 18y ago
Really? Why? What makes driving a stranger around in your car so much more dangerous than driving your wife and kids around?
It's absolutely crazy. The bus company asking the government to protect it from delivering the service that their customers want and need.
- tptacek 18y agoHmmm. Start here: the "threat" is that people will set up businesses offering rides to people full-time. Those people are, in fact, nothing less than unlicensed cab companies. Now, let's go with: * There's an official definition for what a "fare" is, and cab drivers can't change it in the middle of a trip. * Cab drivers lose their medallions if they drive people around in circles to rack up fares. * Cab drivers lose their medallions if they randomly drop people off halfway to their destination. * The insurance requirements for cab drivers are much more strict than for noncommercial drivers. * Cab drivers are more stringently licensed than normal drivers; in fact, with "P2P car service", there's no incentive to be licensed at all. Reckless driving is a huge problem with urban cab drivers. * Taxis themselves are inspected for safety, and cab companies risk their licensing by fielding cabs with bald tires and fucked up brakes. There are two obvious reasons why you'd want to be careful about using the Internet to route around taxi regulation: * There is no incentive whatsoever for "P2P car services" to follow safety, insurance, and fair business practice rules, because a bad actor can simply re-register their car with a new account. * The P2P system cannibalizes the regulated taxi system, which offer far more consumer protections. That's a start. I don't think it's crazy at all --- though again, I'm not arguing that this Internet service should be outlawed.
- Prrometheus 18y agoThe most important aspect of the regulated taxi market to the status quo is that all the fares are set the same, preventing competition on price/quality. Also, medallions are rationed, ensuring that the supply of cabs is always heavily utilized. The demand always outstrips supply on weekend nights and rainy days, but the market cannot adjust to meet it. You could make an argument for the licensing of any profession. In practice, most markets get by with some basic safety regulations and reputation incentives. The licensing only serves to stifle competition and innovation.
- tptacek 18y agoMost rational people probably agree that the medallion caps should be lifted; they were a deliberate attempt to stifle competition during the Depression. So, fix that problem. It's not a strong argument for deregulating taxi service. The regulated taxi service has huge problems as-is without making rules impossible to enforce: * Taxi drivers tend to be unsafe drivers * Taxi drivers tend to rip off their customers * Taxi drivers tend to drive unsafe vehicles There are so many cabs on the road, it's infeasible to address this problem car by car. One thing the medallion system does is to try to inject some accountability into the market, so that there's more to lose for being a scofflaw than just one car. Note also that there's apparently a trend towards leasing medallions on a per-shift basis instead of in long-term leases, and that trend --- which is a step towards deregulation --- correlates with a decline of compliance and and increase in service complaints. Whether or not I believe we should outlaw shadow cab dispatcher services, I think it's easy to make the argument that there's a real risk that they will hurt cab service for most people in the long run. But I mean, as long as they keep them out of New York, Chicago, and San Francisco, I don't really care.
- mseebach 18y ago> * Taxi drivers tend to be unsafe drivers > * Taxi drivers tend to drive unsafe vehicles That's for the insurance companies to settle. It's easy to imagine that "regular" liability insurance policies will prohibit commercial transportation of humans in the vehicle. > * Taxi drivers tend to rip off their customers Your "P2P Car Service" rating will plummet if you rip off your customers. By the same measure, eBay and Craigslist should be blatant failures.
- tptacek 18y agoThat's obviously true, but I think you might be missing my points. Right now, they are: (1) If you lose your million dollar medallion, you are out a million dollars (and likely the ability to ever get a medallion again). If you lose your P2P car service rating, you do what every scammer on every online market has done since 1995: you fake up a new one and game it with BS reviews. (2) Many of the most severe costs of running a bad car service are externalities. I haven't had a valid drivers license in (checking...) THREE YEARS, and I drive every single day. I drive in a car with invalid plates. I get pulled over (checking...) NEVER. Take me, but make me a foreigner with no knowledge of the rules of the road, no knowledge of the city I drive in, and a record of hit and run accidents. I would do just fine in a P2P cab market. Any system that would have me as a cab driver is one we should be skeptical of.
- tdavis 18y agoIf people setup businesses offering rides full-time and those businesses perform better than cab companies or buses, who cares? If the business is full of drivers (or just a driver) who doesn't follow fair business practices it's not going to be successful. Sure, they may trick a couple people, but it won't take long for them to be shunned. If such a company existed that could get me from A to B at half the cost of a regular cab and they had a decent reputation, I'd use 'em. Hell, I wouldn't even care if the vehicles had been inspected recently; I can wear a seat belt. Who knows if it would even be a viable business; maybe none of the companies would do a good enough job vetting drivers or provide enough protection to get enough business, but the market should be allowed to decide that, not a bus company. If "Bob's Taxi" existed, I wouldn't care, so long as they weren't outright lying. If they said, "Hey, we don't have as many consumer protections or regulation as regular cabs but we're cheaper." I would have no problem with that at all.
- tptacek 18y agoEasy: because many of the problems the bad businesses will cause are externalities. Your argument as stated is, "we should eliminate all taxicab and car service regulation". I assume you want to refine it a bit more. At the very least, if that's your stance, you can no longer argue that it is crazy for the state to shut down services like this: first, pass the law that deregulates cabs, then start the shadow taxi dispatch service.
- tdavis 18y agoNo, I kinda like it the way it is actually. Look, I think cab regulation is a good thing; let it be regulated. Despite the inherent inefficiencies and abuse that comes with any sort of regulation, I'm sure it helps consumers by providing strict rules for cabbies and cab companies. Except, we're not talking about a Cab company because it's not licensed as one. If I want to drive people around in my car all day for a fee and I put an ad in the newspaper that says "Tom's Kinda Cab Company; I Drive You Places" why should that be illegal? If someone asks "Is this a regulated cab service" I say "No, but it's half the price!" Either they use my service or they don't. If I get turned down by so many people that it's not viable employment, I guess it's time to look elsewhere. And, perhaps I'm being naive here, but I have no reason to believe that if I were to provide a horrible service that it would somehow affect the bottom line of Yellow Cab. I'm all about giving people choices and letting the market decide. If you decide to order a cab from some deregulated company you've never heard of and you get kidnapped and tortured instead of driven to the bar, well, that's your own fault. It's certainly not "all the cab companies'" fault. And that cab company probably won't be around long.
- unalone 18y agoBut if they're going for regulation, they're going about it entirely backwards. You don't start with a regulated service and deny others entry. You begin with an open market, allowing sites like these, and then other people create a niche business of offering reliability through the same venues. Right? What am I missing?
- tptacek 18y agoThat the phenomenon you're talking about happened like 70 years ago.
- unalone 18y agoAha! Color me ignorant, then, that makes sense.
- tptacek 18y ago:)
- mseebach 18y agoWhat? There was a thriving free market and suddenly the public taxi-regulation-and-rationing scheme out-competed everyone else?
- tptacek 18y agoNo, there was a thriving free market and the public taxi regulation scheme shifted the negative externalities that it was empirically observed to generate back onto the cab companies. Regulated businesses don't "outcompete" unregulated businesses. That's why they're called "regulations" and not "features". You can argue that regulation is stupid, but: * We won't settle the argument, because every point you make about competition I'll respond to with a negative externality, like, "anonymous unmarked drivers killing people by running red lights". * You won't be refuting my original argument, which is that states are not crazy for getting upset by PickupPal.
- corentin 18y agoThere's at least one reason why it shouldn't be outlawed (well, apart from mundane things like justice, freedom and this kind of crap which is not very relevant anymore): if it's outlawed, we will never know if the model they offer is indeed better or not than the current one. If the taxi drivers believe what they say (more safety, etc.) they don't need to ban their competitors because truth will eventually emerge.
- cabalamat 18y agoTaxi regulations generally involve limiting the number of taxis. This has two effects (1) they are more expensive than what a market price would be, and (2) you can't always get a taxi when you want one. So taxi regulation definitely cause drawbacks to customers. Do these drawbacks outweigh the advantages that you enumerate? This could be determined experimentally, by allowing unregulated taxis to offer their services in the market alongside regulated taxis. Unregulated taxis would be obliged to clearly state that they were unregulated, and customers would be able to choose between the two. If proponents of taxi regulations are right, customers will choose the regulated taxis over the unregulated ones.
- tptacek 18y agoThat is a gross oversimplification of taxi regulation. You're just fixating on the one regulation that we all agree is ill-considered.
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- cabalamat 18y agoSurely my argument is more general than that? I.e. it applies to more things than just limiting the number of taxis. A regulated taxi system will differ in some ways from an unregulated system. (If it doesn't then the regulation is so light-touch as to be virtually non-existant.) For example the regulated taxis might have safer drivers, or be less likely to rip off customers, etc. Because regualted and unregulated are different, people will have preferences one way or the other. If an unregulated system is allowed to operate side by side with a regulated system, then each customer will be able to choose which one they buy from, like choosing which supermarket they shop at. (Obviously for this to work it must be easy to tell which is regulated and which unregulated). So if people prefer a regulated service to an unregulated one, they'll continue to choose the regulated one even when there's a choice, won't they? Perhaps you'd like to elaborate on why you think I'm making a gross oversimplification, because I think my argument applies to any differences between regulated and unregulated taxis.
- mleonhard 18y agoWe need to inject competition back into public transportation, but keep some of the regulation. I think that share-taxis are an important piece of the public transportation system that is missing in the USA and Canada: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Share_taxi http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Share_taxi