3 ms·
> able to recover the clock of the source in order to know when to drop or duplicate video frames So this is why I can never watch a whole movie and not have
by londons_explore 3y ago
> able to recover the clock of the source in order to know when to drop or duplicate video frames
So this is why I can never watch a whole movie and not have a single dropped frame!
Back in the old TV days, the TV camera set the 60 fps frequency, and if it was slightly slow at just 59.9 fps, then your TV would also run slightly slow. The whole system was synced perfectly.
Whereas now every device seems to think it can set it's own version of "60 Hz". Your GPU's 60Hz is inevitably a bit different from your displays idea of "60Hz", which in turn is a bit different from your web browsers idea of "60Hz", which is again a bit different from the livestream you're watchings version of "60 Hz". At every stage, when one clock is slightly faster, frames are dropped, and at other stages duplicate frames are inserted. End result: You can't watch a film without random occasional jitters.
Please, everyone in the AV industry: Design your shit better. We should take away your quartz crystals and force you to have only inaccurate timing devices just so you are forced to properly sync everything!
- lxgr 3y agoWhat system(s) are you having these problems on? I haven't encountered that type of issue for years, neither on web video on my computer or smartphone, nor on streaming video (VOD and livestreams) on various smart and not-so-smart home devices. For VOD, your playback system's clock running slightly fast or slow should not be an issue, since all buffers are under its control (it can just send disk loads, HTTP requests etc. at the pace it needs them), and for livestreaming, the most common solutions (HLS and MPEG-DASH, ultimately using MPEG-TS or fragmented MPEG-4 container files) also explicitly specify clock synchronization. > We should take away your quartz crystals and force you to have only inaccurate timing devices just so you are forced to properly sync everything! For livestreams, that would ultimately require synchronizing your entire video pipeline to a remote source (i.e. running your video output slightly slow/fast as required) – I'm not sure if devices like set-top boxes or streaming receivers support that, but it seems entirely impossible for anything capable of displaying two video streams (synchronized to different source clocks) at once.
- hulitu 3y ago> So this is why I can never watch a whole movie and not have a single dropped frame! No, it is because bandwidth is expensive. That's why you get a 4k UHD HDR stream at 3MB/s. Your whole stream is calculated based on the few full frames that you receive. Notice how everybody says: HD up to ... Down to 0.
- lxgr 3y agoA low bit rate normally does not cause dropped frames (unless it's so low that not even the required amount of I-frames can be encoded, but that would be a pretty extreme mismatch of resolution and bitrate).