3 ms·
That people have been wrong before for other products in no way comments on or invalidates what they're saying now about this one. All it says is predicting th
by JohnFen 3y ago
That people have been wrong before for other products in no way comments on or invalidates what they're saying now about this one.
All it says is predicting the future is incredibly hard and all predictions (the ones predicting success as well as failure) are without much weight.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- thomk 3y agoI don't think Apple predicts the future as much as it drives the future. Just my opinion.
- JohnFen 3y agoEvery product a company makes is a prediction that the product will succeed (if they didn't think it would succeed, they wouldn't make it). This applies to Apple just as to every other company. It's not like Apple hasn't had product failures, after all.
- npunt 3y agotbh the real question is not the output (whether this succeeds or fails), it's whether Apple followed the same inputs that made prior products category-defining like Apple II, Mac, iPod, iPhone, iPad, Watch, and Airpods. All of those took niche computing ideas and made them mainstream, creating a new market and new way of life, and did so by following a playbook of timing the tech right, scoping narrowly, and understanding which use cases were worth targeting. I wrote about some of these input factors in my post on category defining products a few years back: https://nickpunt.com/blog/category-defining-products/ https://nickpunt.com/blog/category-defining-products/ Personally, I feel Vision is a bit too broadly scoped for a v1. 3d photos really didn't need to be in there. The consumer use cases that Apple loves really aren't where Vision is providing next level value add, whereas the remote workplace ones are. But I understand those alone are not enough to drive adoption so I can see why they wanted to make it more consumer oriented. My hunch is they pivot slightly toward workplace in subsequent versions, much like they did with Apple Watch pivoting toward health and away from luxury.