4 ms·
This is a bad example though, because everyone knows who Apple are. There's no point inventing anything as a new company if an existing one can just copy it and
by robertlagrant 3y ago
This is a bad example though, because everyone knows who Apple are. There's no point inventing anything as a new company if an existing one can just copy it and outspend your marketing.
- strbean 3y agoPatent law doesn't provide you much protection unless you can outspend infringers in court.
- lazide 3y agoAnd the infringers can be reached/influenced by the court. Random resellers on China have no reason to care about US patents.
- Taywee 3y agoAnd there's no point inventing anything as an established company if you can just aggressively buy IP and leverage existing property. There's a balance to how much IP protection actually encourages innovation, and we're far on one side of it.
- TimPC 3y agoIf companies choose not to innovate and purchase their innovation instead that still creates a market for innovation and a source of funds for doing so. I'm far from convinced this is the case as most big tech companies have entire research divisions regularly producing papers and patents and we've seen some big AI products recently launch out of internal big tech initiatives.
- lend000 3y agoYou need to have enforceable NDA's, keep things as trade secrets, and have a well built organization that simply continuously out-innovates AND out-executes the competition. I think patents are okay, but the maximum duration should be 5 years and there needs to be some proof of utilization of the patent to sue for damages. 20 year patents are ridiculous, and it seems like even in the 1800's that should have been considered a bit extreme.
- thfuran 3y agoThe term (in the US) wasn't originally that long. It was decided individually but not to exceed 14 years. That's long, but much more reasonable in a time when it could take months for just some basic roundtrip long-distance correspondence.
- TylerE 3y agoI don't think you can just state that in good faith while ignoring how much harder/more expensive R&D is these days.
- CogitoCogito 3y agoHow much harder/more expensive is R&D these days?
- thfuran 3y agoIs it harder by an amount that exceeds the amount by which the readily addressable market has expanded for most things?
- rudyfink 3y agoI wouldn't be surprised if it takes 5 years (or more) to both get a patent and litigate it though any appeal. FWIW, in the current U.S. system, my understanding is the time it takes to get the patent comes out of the 20 years, though I think you can get some time back if it takes a very long time.
- AlbertCory 3y agoCorrect. There IS a "patent term adjustment" if the PTO takes longer than it should. The term you want is "prosecute" not "litigate."
- wongarsu 3y agoIt should probably depend on the product type. I get 20 year parents for medicine where research is expressive and time-to-market is long. But for most fields 5-10 years is plenty to make back your R&D investment and make a profit. And after your patent expires you still have the first-mover advantage