3 ms·
It's like few that commented here about the "purr" (people commenting how cats meow and don't purr, how the purr is not like a chainsaw, and so on) bothered to
by coldtea 3y ago
It's like few that commented here about the "purr" (people commenting how cats meow and don't purr, how the purr is not like a chainsaw, and so on) bothered to read (as opposed to skim) the article or deploy some basic reading comprehension.
The article begins with saying cats meow to ask for things. It EXPICITLY says that "Anyone who has lived with a cat has experienced their household companion meowing to them, clearly trying to communicate something or other (perhaps “dinner time” or “Help, I’m locked in the closet”)".
When the article talks about the purr, is in addition to that. It even literally starts that section saying "And it’s not just the meow.".
As for the purr, they don;t refer to the "satisfaction purr" cats do when you pet then (or sometimes the agitated purr they have when they're stressed), that you knee-jerk assumed it does. The article links to the relevant research where they describe those "solicitation purrs" and the audio analysis they did on them:
"Here we report how domestic cats make subtle use of one of their most characteristic vocalisations — purring — to solicit food from their human hosts, apparently exploiting sensory biases that humans have for providing care. When humans were played purrs recorded while cats were actively seeking food at equal amplitude to purrs recorded in non-solicitation contexts, even individuals with no experience of owning cats judged the ‘solicitation’ purrs to be more urgent and less pleasant. Embedded within the naturally low-pitched purr, we found a high frequency voiced component, reminiscent of a cry or meow, that was crucial in determining urgency and pleasantness ratings. Moreover, when we re-synthesised solicitation purrs to remove only the voiced component, paired presentations revealed that these purrs were perceived as being significantly less urgent."
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0960982209011683 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S096098220...
- yellowapple 3y ago> As for the purr, they don;t refer to the "satisfaction purr" cats do when you pet then Before today, the only sort of "purr" I'd ever heard anyone refer to is a "satisfaction purr". What your quotation describes as a "solicitation purr" is what I reckon most people would call a "meow" or maybe a "yell". One of those cases where colloquial v. scientific uses of a word diverge rather severely, I guess.
- coldtea 3y ago>is what I reckon most people would call a "meow" or maybe a "yell" Again, no. They refer to a different kind of purr that cats do when asking for something, distinct from a meow. A purr that most people might not even have noticed as it occurs next to (and between) meows. And this special purr also has an embedded higher frequency component similar to a meow, as they explain, that they had to amplify and do some signal processing to hear properly. It's funny how people are not willing to read the study (or read carefully), but would rather assume that scientists (and even worse: scientists studying cats) don't know what a meow and a purr is, and just use the terms incorrectly!