7 ms·
including two of the executives behind “Lightyear”: director Angus MacLane and producer Galyn Susman. MacLane had been at Pixar for more than two decades, servi
by andsoitis 3y ago
including two of the executives behind “Lightyear”: director Angus MacLane and producer Galyn Susman. MacLane had been at Pixar for more than two decades, serving as an animator on classics like “Toy Story 2,” “The Incredibles” and “Finding Nemo.” He co-directed the 2016 sequel “Finding Dory” before his first solo directorial feature film “Lightyear.” The spinoff of the “Toy Story” franchise, which featured Chris Evans as the voice of Buzz Lightyear, was a commercial dud; Deadline estimated the film lost the studio more than $100 million.
Susman, likewise, was a longtime Pixar employee. She is also the hero of one of the company’s most legendary stories. During the making of “Toy Story 2,” a Pixar employee accidentally wiped the servers of nearly the whole movie. Thankfully for the animators, Susman was working from home while taking care of her newborn child — her backup copy saved the film.
Having done great work in the past is not enough to incentivize others to keep you around.
- oofta-boofta 3y agoThis is why I never go "above and beyond" anymore. Companies only care what you did for them yesterday and will drop you like a bad habit because it'll make their stock price go up by 0.000000001% Have a bad day? Fuck you, you're fired. Doesn't matter that you saved the company tens or hundreds or even millions of dollars last year. That was last year. What have you done for the bottom line today, peon?
- zinclozenge 3y agoAgreed, and I'll go one further. This is why you should work multiple jobs, aka overemployment.
- geodel 3y agoTrue. Other day I saw a provocative challenge on LinkedIn Whats stopping you from doing 336 hours worth of work in 168 hours of a week? To be honest I had no answer.
- zinclozenge 3y agoThe overemployment philosophy is to be so good at your job that you can do N (where N > 1) jobs in the usual 40 hours per week. So really, it's about finding those companies where you can meet those expectations.
- oofta-boofta 3y agoDid we just become best friends?
- DevKoala 3y agoSo you lose the company $100M and you shouldn't be accountable either? Also, think about this, these people were promoted multiple times for going "above & beyond". They just weren't an optimal fit for their last roles.
- BeFlatXIII 3y agoMore like: don't be a department head on an unlucky project.
- nehal3m 3y agoThey were laid off, not fired. Accountability was not necessarily a consideration here.
- mynameisvlad 3y agoOur industry is blameless for a reason, and this extends to this situation fully. Please explain to me exactly how it was that one director's fault that the movie lost $100M. Because in reality, it's going to be a lot more than one person's fault that a movie was a dud. Especially when there are so many moving pieces behind a piece of content's popularity.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoUsually, losses at that scale, started from the original pitch and greenlight. It was a bad idea from the start, and was never given a chance to correct. Steve McConnell was a big proponent of the worst bugs start in the Requirements Phase. Same goes for almost any project. The people that greenlight garbage are frequently fired, too, but that usually means they need to delay buying that second private island. People further down the food chain, might actually end up having to put their kids to work at McDonald's, instead of sending them to college.
- mynameisvlad 3y agoThat's not even remotely true. There are many reasons for a movie (or literally any other project) to not do well and many inflection points among the movie's development process which could have massively changed the impact. Politics in this case also played a big part around the movie's launch, for instance. It's impossible for you to say with certainty that a single decision caused the movie to flop and it's disingenuous to think so. Especially disingenuous to say it's one person's fault that an entire movie was pitched, greenlit, made, and then flopped. There are literally thousands of people who made decisions along the way, starting from the initial greenlight which would have been given by multiple people.
- rtkwe 3y agoHow long does that good will last for though? Toy Story 2 was released just shy of 24 years ago. It feels fair for that to have worn off by now and by all accounts she's done well at the company making plenty of money.
- hotpotamus 3y agoI wonder if it's still making money? I'm sure the copyright is still valid.
- rtkwe 3y agoCopyright is definitely still valid. Tracing where money is being made gets so much trickier with streaming platforms, especially when it's owned by the copyright owner instead of being licensed. Best you can really do is divvy up the monthly subscription each person pays by the time spent watching a particular show. I'm sure it's also still getting licensed for TV airings somewhere a few times a year along with a trickle of DVD/Blu-ray sales.
- dspillett 3y agoShe's been involved at high level of other projects since then. She has producer credit for Toy Story 4 for example, I seem to recall that did well enough and was only a couple of years before Lightyear. I think here she has fallen foul of the old “you are as good as your last result” during a costs downsizing period.
- atonse 3y agoI know that we tell ourselves this story about management just so we can justify doing the bare minimum as employees. But where does that leave us as a society? I just feel this cynical statement is as silly as a blanket statement as one that would say the opposite, something like "companies provide value and jobs and take care of employees" I would argue though, that the way you describe companies is definitely more true of larger companies because people just aren't invested/attached to each other and that enables that kind of thinking (employees just lines on a spreadsheet). Many small businesses (and small business owners like myself) do want to build a team and take care of the team and hope the team also invests back into the company. That doesn't mean they can't lay people off if they can't afford to keep them. But things are more likely to be human at a smaller size anyway.
- esotericimpl 3y agoEmployee owned businesses combined with strong labor unions.
- itake 3y agoWhy are there so few successful employee owned businesses?
- truckerbill 3y agoBecause they naturally don't want to rely on exploitation to the same degree. That's not a problem of the concept but the context.
- flangola7 3y agoBecause the system dis-incentives it. It's hard to compete when your opponent is willing to play dirty and the referee doesn't care to stop it.
- trey-jones 3y agoAs a 10 year veteran of a small (less than 20 employees) software company, I can confirm they do exist. Many a screw-up has been overlooked, and I do feel that my overall contribution to the company is valued. We are all friends here. It's not perfect, but I don't envy participants in the corporate rat race.
- xyzelement 3y agoI am not sure that strategy optimizes for your outcomes however. Think about probabilities. Does doing good and relevant work increase your chances of promotion and better pay? Yes. Does it decrease your chances of being laid off? Yes. So it seems like doing good work is your best chance at doing well, although nothing is guaranteed. Now obviously if you're doing the minimum at work because you're growing your own business - that could be the superior strategy. But if you're doing the minimum so you can just waste time doing nothing - seems worse.
- peruvian 3y ago> Does it decrease your chances of being laid off? Yes. This is so hilariously false.
- xyzelement 3y agoNot sure where you've worked but in my experience based on established finance firms, a scale-up and FAANGs, layoff-rounds - especially early ones - have a high mix of low and borderline performers. Being in that cohort obviously hurts you - though obviously nothing is guaranteed.
- alangibson 3y agoWhat industry are you in, and how long have you been at it? I tend to think the parent post is objectively correct after 25 years of doing everything computer related.
- nehal3m 3y agoThere's a flip side you're skipping over. Going above and beyond has an opportunity cost, you are spending time and effort on a chance of improving your employment situation at the cost of spending that time and energy elsewhere, places where it _could_ be a guarantee at a better life. For example, spending time doing things you love, or spending time just being around the people that you love. In my opinion the optimised outcome is a good life, not good employment.
- maerF0x0 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- caturopath 3y ago> Companies only care what you did for them yesterday Yeah, they should employ you forever if you, out of luck, not work, had some hard drives at home in 1998.
- savanaly 3y agoThey didn't lay her off the next day or even the next year or even next decade. How long does a heroic act entitle you to a job at a company for?
- Retric 3y agoIt’s not like she did nothing over the last 24 years. But, assuming they save a company orders of magnitude more than their entire salary for the rest of your career, it’s probably worth it to keep such people around indefinitely assuming they continue to actually work. If for no other reason but to incentivize other people to go above and beyond. I’ve seen the other side of this where employees decided not to save the company 10’s of millions because it would be a hassle and they wouldn’t be rewarded for it. Nobody wins when you fail to reward people.
- inconceivable 3y agosmall or tiny companies don't adhere to these dynamics (mainly because it's impossible to over-hire in the first place), but of course generally nobody "established" wants to work for a no-name company if it isn't some well funded startup. they're happy to interview and get an offer and use it as leverage against a bigger company, though. you also hear this from customers, but of course generally nobody wants to be a customer of a smaller unknown company either. same thing - they're happy to get a quote and use it as leverage against a big competitor. as long as you want that upside of security or a big paycheck or prestige or "never got fired for choosing" or whatever imaginary thing you've convinced yourself of, you're also going to get a corresponding downside when the going gets tough. live by the sword, die by the sword. if you're unhappy about the dynamics of big companies, maybe consider a change.
- 0xB31B1B 3y agoIt’s a job, not a pension. The goodwill lasts a quarter, not 20 years.
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoJust change your last name to Kennedy and you can keep failing up at Disney.
- samtho 3y agoThis is one of the reasons why I’ve become disillusioned from working for 99% of companies out there. I don’t expect a great deal of loyalty from a company but I expect not to axed for dumb reasons that usually have little to do with me. Running a company out of fear is how you get a highly neurotic, blame-deflecting, egotistical, competition-over-collaboration workplace. In practice, these are the smells I look for, but sadly, it’s not always visible in the interview process: * Each of the organizations of the business produce more evidence of their worth than actual value they bring * Blame is deflected causing everyone from C-level to individual contributors speaking with the passive voice within internal communication * Yes-men/women bubble up to the top and those who pose contrary opinions are not welcome Unfortunately, most companies have some degree of these, but there are some that are worse than others. I’ve just found that starting my own thing is going to be better long term for my mental health even if it puts me in a more precarious financial situation.
- newsclues 3y agoIt's a breakdown of the incentive structure that has been so successful.
- ap99 3y agoThis is a grim way to live. Yes, there are companies that are extreme in their mercurial attitudes towards employees. But so are there people like that. Do you similarly say, I don't do anything above and beyond for other people because that one time some boy/girl/friend left me because I had a bad day? No, you find the people who value you. And because there needs to be balance, you show that you value them by sometimes going above and beyond. And besides that, you should be tying everything you do for a company to some self-oriented goal. Like these folks laid off from Pixar, do you think they are now at a net negative in life for having been laid off? Their lives have been enriched through skills, relationships, income, savings, experiences, etc. Does it suck to be laid off? Definitely. But if you come away from a 20 year career at a company feeling empty and used then I'd say that's more on you than on the employer. If you think to yourself, "I could have given so much more time to my family but the company forced me to work." No, you did that to yourself. You work for an abusive employer? Plan your escape.
- tomrod 3y agoThe notion of employee tenure isn't absolutely crazy, and if exists should be hard to achieve. But for someone who literally saved the company, I'd expect the person to be treated a bit better?
- caturopath 3y agoShe happened to be lucky 25 years ago. I am not sure that suitable 'good treatment' means employing her forever.
- tomrod 3y agoPerhaps the event is not sufficient for 25 years in a binary classification of "unfireable/unlayoffable". Can we at least agree that maybe 10 years is reasonable, with a follow-on review?
- caturopath 3y agoNot especially, it would really depend on what's up at the company and the nature of the layoffs. Hopefully she got a bonus at the time. As fortunate as it is that she had these copies of the data, it's not like she helped them by being really, really good at her job, she helped them from the coincidence of working from home for a while.
- thefounder 3y agoLightyear was so bad at so many levels. I think it's expected for you to step down after such a flop. I'm pretty sure she fought for a lot of Lightyear stuff to be included in the final release. The risk didn't pay off...such is life!
- jakelazaroff 3y agoWhy are you sure of that? What makes you so confident that she bears responsibility for the movie being a flop?
- Gualdrapo 3y agoFor what it's worth, I've already seen several posts on Facebook where people are claiming they were sacked because they made that movie "woke"
- jakelazaroff 3y agoOf course, but those takes are untethered from reality. We saw the counterfactual play out with The Super Mario Bros. Movie: first it was "woke" and "feminist" because Peach was a "girlboss" rather than a damsel in distress, and then when the movie made a ton of money the same people said it was actually "anti-woke" because they didn't race swap Mario and Luigi. I guarantee that if Lightyear had done well, they'd be talking about how these layoffs happened because Disney is a "woke corporation" that hates white male leads or some other reactionary conservative culture war mad-lib bullshit.
- thefounder 3y agoThe director and the producer have a big say on the movie. You can't blame the distribution(disney) or the public. So who else is to blame if not at least the director and the producer?
- jakelazaroff 3y agoI'm specifically asking about this claim: > I'm pretty sure she fought for a lot of Lightyear stuff to be included in the final release.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> Having done great work in the past is not enough to incentivize others to keep you around. Happening to have a backup copy in your house 25 years ago doesn't justify your current role of being good at losing the company millions of dollars. Disney and Pixar have had a series of movies that in the main have had bad production and writing decisions attached to them, so even though the technical delivery (e.g. animation; music) and performances are generally very good, they are just boring. A lot of the spark seems to have gone. If you watch the latest Disney or Pixar movies and compare it with something like the Arcane TV series, which is unbelievably beautifully animated and extremely well written, it's night and day. The talent that led Pixar has fizzled or been replaced over the years, and they can't pay people a fortune to lose them money forever.
- jakelazaroff 3y agoI'm not convinced you're putting the blame in the right place. Looking at the last decade or so, most of the original films — Inside Out, Coco, Luca, Turning Red, etc — have ranged from "great" to "incredible". It's the sequels and spinoffs like Cars 3, Toy Story 4 and Lightyear that have fallen flat. I don't know where in the Disney org chart people start worrying about revenue, but from where I sit Pixar still has plenty of spark.
- robertlagrant 3y agoEr - I'm not sure about that. Toy Story 4 took in over a billion[0] worldwide. Coco and Inside Out did around $800m[1] each, but Luca did very poorly, taking under $50m.[2]. Turning Red appears to be the worst, on a $250m budget (and probably similar for marketing, it took $20m[3]. [0] https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt1979376 https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt1979376 [1] https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt2380307 https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt2380307 [2] https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt12801262 https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt12801262 [3] https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt8097030 https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt8097030
- jakelazaroff 3y ago
- agloe_dreams 3y agoI would love to know how Steve reacted to hearing that they deleted the film. that must have been Thermonuclear.
- paddw 3y agoThese people are executives, not regular employees. The headline about laying off "animators" in this case is misleading. They were animators. Now they are executives who likely had large pay packages.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoYes this totally changes the dynamic, it's pretty normal for executives associated with big flops to get sacked.
- oneTbrain23 3y agoAlways do quiet quiting and IP theft. Use the spare times in company to siphon all important info. It will be very useful to competitors in years later.