5 ms·
That’s not how technology works. Only minor changes in CPUs are done without supporting motherboard changes. Are you also going to tell CPU manufacturers that
by scarface_74 3y ago
That’s not how technology works. Only minor changes in CPUs are done without supporting motherboard changes. Are you also going to tell CPU manufacturers that they can’t put memory and the CPU on the same die?
Are you going to tell every computer manufacturer they have to use the same motherboard across all of their computers.
- avmich 3y ago> Are you going to tell every computer manufacturer they have to use the same motherboard across all of their computers. Roughly, yes. There are communication and energy standards, which are used by external devices, the CPUs should have embedded or externalized adapters to these standards. Motherboard is the place to assemble these standard-compliant devices together.
- scarface_74 3y agoAnd are those standards going to work across all of the different form factors that Apple has for instance? Are they going to work across CPU architectures?
- jchw 3y agoWell on one hand, pretty much yeah. Not literally of course, that would be absurd. However, there should absolutely be strong incentives for manufacturers of computer hardware to focus on hardware that is built to last: chipsets designed with future development in mind, unsoldered external RAM, etc. Incentivizing this is good because it prevents the situation where a vendor gets punished for "doing the right thing" and making hardware that doesn't need to be replaced as frequently. But is that "right to repair"? Mostly no. I would place it more in the broader category of measures against ewaste.
- scarface_74 3y agoAnd it will also result in worse computers that are necessarily slower and larger? Should Apple be forced to use standardized boards that are meant for x86 chips? Should they be forced to try to use the same board for the Mac Mini, the iMac, and the Mac Studio?
- jchw 3y agoIn my opinion, forcing everyone to standardize on Intel architecture chips is bad for an entirely different reason. However, since the industry is already broadly standardized on DDR RAM, I think we're not losing anything by pushing for "standard" RAM interfaces, even if it's just "some kind of standard socket for current JEDEC spec". It's sort of in a similar vein to the EU pushing for USB-C standardization on phones. For motherboards, it ought to just be more future-proofed. Exactly how to incentivize that is not trivial, definitely not going to be figured out in a Hacker News comments section. > And it will also result in worse computers that are necessarily slower and larger? Slightly, which is exactly why it's never going to just magically happen on its own even if it would literally be better for everyone overall. But I don't really buy the idea that Apple can't make a competitive motherboard or computer if they're forced to support modular system RAM. And personally, I'm not in favor of outlawing soldered RAM or embedded RAM or what have you, I'm in favor of disincentivizing not supporting expandable RAM on desktop and laptop computers. It doesn't have to be illegal, but it absolutely should be discouraged. I am not, on the whole, more concerned about Apple's bottom line over concerns like ewaste and consumer rights. I have a sneaking suspicion they will do just fine, somehow.
- scarface_74 3y agoUnless you found another way to increase the speed that electrons move, the best way to have better speeds from RAM to the CPU is by integrating them on the same die. The slow, overheating, short battery life Intel world may have standardized on DDR RAM. But I’ll take my fast, quiet, cool, 14 hour battery life MacBook Pro 16 inch any day. It’s not about Apple’s bottom line. It’s about making a better computer. You’re taking away my right as a consumer to have a better computer.
- circuit10 3y agoRight to repair isn’t about standardising parts though, it’s about preventing things that purposefully prevent repair with no other good reason. For example, in recent Macbooks the lid closed sensor is paired to the device so if you replace it yourself it will stop working. Only Apple has the tool needed to pair it to the device and make it work again. There’s no good reason to do that apart from preventing repair