7 ms·
Three companies agree to pay $1B to settle 'forever chemical' claims
- notRobot 3y ago$1B combined, not individually > The three companies said they have agreed to contribute a total of $1.185 billion to a settlement fund. Chemours will contribute 50 percent (about $592 million), and DuPont and Corteva will together contribute the remaining 50 percent, at about $400 million and $193 million, respectively.
- fuzzfactor 3y agoI would say the toxins will last a lot longer than the $1 Billion will.
- ProAm 3y agoThis is not enough of a penalty.
- Zetice 3y agoWhen a payout like this occurs, does it mean the problem is resolved? In other words, are these companies no longer putting out toxic chemicals, or are they buying the ability to continue to do that without fear of further lawsuits?
- pluc 3y ago> In a statement, Dupont said it “has never manufactured PFOA or PFOS.” CNN has reached out to the other companies for comment on the allegations, which they denied in a press release Friday. How can they stop something they never did
- laputan_machine 3y agoThen there would be no evidence, which would mean the court case would be thrown out / one-sided. Instead they settled for a large amount of money. Does that not make you raise your eyebrows?
- rebolek 3y agoyou forgot /s
- ceejayoz 3y agoI don't understand that statement. It seems to be an outright lie, or quoted out of context; not sure which, and both are plausible. https://www.dupont.com/position-statements/pfoa.html https://www.dupont.com/position-statements/pfoa.html says "While we no longer make PFOA..."
- paxys 3y agoThe settlement likely includes a provision for them not having to admit to any wrongdoing, so they can legally lie in their press release.
- HWR_14 3y agoThree possibilities (other than just inconsistent statements). The "we no longer" could be referring to "the US" as "we", since they talk about the FDA outlawing it. So DuPont never made PFOA. "Manufacture" might be used in the chemical industry only refer to creating products. And DuPont was earlier in the supply chain. Or, even more upstream, DuPont may have made precursor chemicals that other people mixed into the final PFOA.
- tedunangst 3y agoDuPont has a complicated corporate history. Chemours, one of the other companies in the settlement, is the division that made Teflon. Corteva was also part of DuPont (and Dow). It may be technically true that none of the business units currently in DuPont made anything bad.
- moi2388 3y agoDuPont is lying. They 100% did produce these materials. We have a factory on my place from which they dump this in the river.
- moneywoes 3y agoMaybi ask what type of factory, are there no regulations?
- EscapeFromNY 3y agoI can think of plenty of ways that sentence might be weaselly. Maybe they "synthesized" them, not "manufactured" Maybe they bought them from some other company (which they might happen to own) Maybe they manufactured PFAs in general, but not the specific chemicals PFOA or PFOS (it's an awfully specific statement, after all)
- horsawlarway 3y agoI think it will likely be this - I'm already seeing all sorts of companies pivot to marketing "PFOA" free teflon alternatives (Starflon was the one that popped up last). I suspect that just like the whole BPA in plastic thing - the "___ free" alternatives will not be any better. They will just be sidestepping the very precise legal definition of the chemical that got them in trouble.
- TylerE 3y agoEither that or it will be like gluten-free, and you'll start seeing it slathered all over stuff that never had it in the first place. Like, no duh non-flavored sparkling water is gluten free! (Actual example I saw in the grocery store today)
- lesuorac 3y agoWell something like Soy Sauce often has gluten in it and I'd say judging by the name it doesn't. So something that seems like it'd trivially not contain X may actually have X.
- ceejayoz 3y agoNot as silly as it sounds. If you've got celiac, you may want to avoid sparkling water made in a plant that also bottles wheat beers. Gluten free refers not only to the ingredients, but to the manufacturing facility. https://celiac.org/main/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Combined-Gluten-Free-Diet-and-Food-Label-Reading-Guide.pdf https://celiac.org/main/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/Combined-..., point #6. > "The gluten-free label represents that the procedures put in place to prevent cross-contact with gluten meet FDA standards."
- sebzim4500 3y agoI am aware that companies sometimes settle cases where they are in the right in order to avoid legal fees, but the idea that Dupont paid $400M in this settlement despite having not manufactured the chemicals in question is absurd. If they thought they weren't liable then they would have fought this in court.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rqtwteye 3y agoThe problem has been “resolved” in the sense that the companies and government don’t have to deal with it anymore. That’s the goal.
- agilob 3y agoI'll pay you $1B to shut up
- rad_gruchalski 3y agoI take it. Should I send you my bank details?
- wiz21c 3y agoFor that price I can even clean the dishes if you will, say, for a year or two.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CommanderData 3y agoPocket change. This is not accountability for infecting the worlds population with these nasty chemicals.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoPFAS technology was top secret WW2 research output. Then the military discovered that they had amazing properties to fight extremely dangerous fires in missile warehouses and were eventually required to use them to maximize safety decades ago. Prozac, Lipitor, Flonase and about 30% of upcoming new pharmaceutical drugs are PFAS, so they aren't going away completely, because society has determined that they are valuable even if they can reach toxic levels if not disposed of properly (every chemical is toxic after a certain human concentration, including water). Companies wouldn't be able to manufacture semiconductors without PFAS as well, or high temperature components for warfare. Now that we are smarter, we know how to mitigate risk and reduce concentrating materials to keep below relevant ppb thresholds. If America isn't educationally sophisticated enough to handle this manufacturing and risk, it will just be done in zero regulation geographies like China and the world will be worse off.
- bluedays 3y agoPFAS is not used in pharmaceutical drugs.
- ok_computer 3y agoThey listed prozac that is fluorinated https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluoxetine https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluoxetine But I’m unsure the line where perfluoralkylated is reached. I’d think if the compound had alkylated chains instead of a fluorine-linked head group.
- nate_meurer 3y agoThey absolutely are. My favorite antidepressant fluoxetine (Prozac) is unambiguously a PFAS.
- 3y ago
- EscapeFromNY 3y agohttps://www.dupont.com/news/dupont-reports-fourth-quarter-and-full-year-2022-results.html https://www.dupont.com/news/dupont-reports-fourth-quarter-an... Look at these numbers, extrapolate them to the decades they've been in business, and then compare them to DuPont's payment here of $400 million. The numbers aren't even close.
- PaulKeeble 3y agoThe cost for anything like this should always be the cost of cleaning up the entire mess it created and compensating the humans harmed by it and covering their lifetime medical bills. $1billion sounds a tad low for doing any of that given the world wide impact. Its a bad deal.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rqtwteye 3y agoAgreed. Most of the money probably doesn’t even go to the people who got damaged.
- BizarroLand 3y agoYeah, it's a "make the victims feel like they got some justice" money but not anywhere near enough to actually solve the problem or to repay the damages. They're basically getting off scott free, and they made tens of billions of dollars in profit for only having to pay 1 billion in damages.
- wmeredith 3y agoJustice served would be jail time for execs or a corporate death penalty. Levying a fine means it's just a cost of doing business. And a billion dollars sounds like a lot, but it's a drop in the bucket for these massive multinational corporations that have been in business for decades.
- politician 3y ago> a corporate death penalty So, no more Kevlar for police protection? The problem with the idea of a corporate death penalty is that it would shutter the corporation, shock the supply chain for critical materials, terminate the employment of thousands of people, and devastate their communities (e.g. because employees have families and those families consume food and stuff from the local economy which, in turn, supports other families). It's obvious why we haven't adopted it as a viable punishment.
- rieg3c 3y agoi'm reading these are used everywhere, pretty much like plastics :( i really think this problem is out of our hands, i wonder how much time we have until the food and water has so much plastic and forever chemicals that it isn't safe to eat anymore
- Invictus0 3y agoJust the cost of doing business. They paid pennies on the dollar for the damage they inflicted and they will do it again next time it suits them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- stodor89 3y agoAnother day, another slap on the wrist.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoIsn't $1B a trivial amount for environmental damage?
- HWR_14 3y agoThis is only to cover damage to the drinking water (and excludes any drinking water supplied by state or federal governments). More lawsuits or settlements can concern themselves with damage to the environment. As for if that is a trivial amount for what they are paying for, I don't know.
- Sunspark 3y agoYes. It's an absolute steal of a price to pay for something that persists in the environment. It seems like a big number to people who live off a paycheck but if you compare it to a project like a section of highway construction or an airport or whatever you quickly see that this is no penalty. Put another way, an NBA basketball franchise is worth 2.86 billion on average. The penalty is basically 1/3rd of a pro level basketball franchise.
- JohnFen 3y agoYes, it's meaningless. Once again, these huge corporations are destroying the world for profit and getting away with it.
- 29athrowaway 3y agoThey made more than $1B and caused more than $1B in damages. This is a slap on the wrist.
- cgb223 3y agoI mean it’s great they’re paying a fine, but are they going to you know, develop anything that will pull these forever chemicals out of the water?
- intelVISA 3y agoDon't be silly, have you even thought of the stakeholders?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sledgehammers 3y agoThe leadership should go to jail. The fine should be 100x.
- Agingcoder 3y agoIf they agree then it’s not expensive enough.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y agoSeems kinda low given the scope and bets that amount a) gets substantially reduced later on and b) will be claimed as business expense so will have a even lesser net effect. Its just minor inconvenience for them.
- MrYellowP 3y agoThis is a fucking joke and nobody can do anything about it.