6 ms·
I will never understand how Reddit bungled this so badly. I'm no Harvard MBA, but here's an easier way out – instead of asking small-time app developers to pay
by paxys 3y ago
I will never understand how Reddit bungled this so badly. I'm no Harvard MBA, but here's an easier way out – instead of asking small-time app developers to pay millions, put API access contingent on the account subscribing to Reddit Premium. That way users get to keep the experience they enjoy, independent developers can keep doing their thing, Reddit gets to make up for the lost ad revenue in the form of subscriptions, and if people complain about it they are the ones being cheap.
- jacooper 3y agoIts not about the revenue, its about forcing everyone to get ads, with endless tracking.
- paxys 3y agoSays who? They are only pushing the "official experience" to make up for lost ad revenue. If I pay Reddit $50/yr why would they care what app I use? YouTube does the same thing with Premium, and it is working out great.
- kitsunesoba 3y agoIt's about ads and tracking sure, but they're also trying to build a TikTok-style algorithm-powered black hole that keeps you sucked in by way of constantly shoving more things in front of you, including posts from subreddits you're not subscribed to. They also want to be able to force whatever new half-baked features they add to work with prominent positioning in their apps.
- Spivak 3y agoBut to what end? You have a bunch of users who you know are willing to pay real dollars for a different experience. You couldn't ask for better segmentation getting people with wildly different desires and expectations to both be hooked on your platform.
- kitsunesoba 3y agoI think it's probably because users paying to be able to use third party clients can't be sold as growth potential — it's a relatively static number, and they're paying for an entirely static experience. They don't want whatever gimmick Reddit is pushing at the moment (like NFT avatars), they want their simple chronological feed and that's it. The limit of worth for those users is the subscription they're paying, whereas if they're using the official app they're theoretically monetizable in N different ways.
- yunohn 3y agoWhich 3rd party YouTube app are you using?
- Semaphor 3y ago> If I pay Reddit $50/yr why would they care what app I use? Then why is that not an option? The narrative that they want more tracking and control makes sense with the facts we have.
- paxys 3y agoThat is an option, considering Reddit is charging third party developers the equivalent of ~$2.5/mo per user for API access, so the tracking argument already goes out of the window. They are already giving up control, for a very low price too, but just implementing it in the most brain dead way possible.
- Semaphor 3y agoThat is what the 3rd party dev has to implement, Reddit already has a premium feature, but there is no api-unlock, there is just dev payments. That’s a big part of the issue. If people paying Reddit would unlock api access, most issues would disappear.
- Eisenstein 3y agoEvery reddit account gets API access with OAth. No payment needed.
- Semaphor 3y agoUh, no, that’s the upcoming change.
- Eisenstein 3y agoSorry friend, you are incorrect. * https://www.reddit.com/r/modnews/comments/13wshdp/api_update_continued_access_to_our_api_for/ https://www.reddit.com/r/modnews/comments/13wshdp/api_update... "If you are using OAuth for authentication: 100 queries per minute per OAuth client id If you are not using OAuth for authentication: 10 queries per minute"
- valine 3y agoThat’s a monumentally stupid reason to alienate your most dedicated users.
- jacooper 3y agoThey don't care. It's all about the money and tracking the user.
- last_responder 3y agoDo you think this desire is out of the goodness of their hearts and they genuinely think that it is the best? I cannot believe anyone would think that.
- tgv 3y agoPossibly (but it's just a guess) it's about ads and/or data harvesting. If you access it via another app, they cannot get everything they're getting now. Plus: a subscription would drive many users away.
- jacooper 3y agoI never said that, its obviously to track everyone and to force users into that endless algorithm.
- beezlewax 3y agoWhat for profit company is doing anything and not thinking about revenue? Why would they force users to do something they're not too pleased about if it wasn't entirely for generating revenue of some description?
- George83728 3y agoThe same official experience? So they're going to take away user choice in which subreddits to read too? Probably not. It's about money, not enforcing a uniform experience.
- roncesvalles 3y agoAt least on Android, the official app is terrible. Scrolling is very janky and feels unnatural, and the design is cluttered and soulless. Just need to look at Reddit is Fun to see how good it could be. They say a product reflects the organization that produced it, and it's clear from the app that this is a company with unchecked Promo-Driven-Development and Resume-Driven-Development. There is no impressive metric that measures app jankiness or design clarity in isolation, and the effort to fix it is disproportionately larger than the line that it adds to your resume or promo package. So even though it's glaringly obvious that the app is broken within 3 seconds of opening it, not a single person anywhere in the org is incentivized to fix it.
- phailhaus 3y agoYeah OpenAI just demonstrated how effective this is.
- Spivak 3y agoSpotify demonstrates it too because you need premium to use things like mopidy.
- snide 3y agoYes! Speaking as a heavy Reddit, but non-sub user, this is exactly what would have gotten me to pay them $50 a year. Not NFTs, stickers and avatars. I think the problem is that the API concerns are more around LLMs having easy access points to their data than anything else. Still, this could have been avoided by providing free-use keys to trusted developers. It's not like there are that many of them. Just seems odd how dark they've been towards this user class. It's very similar to the Twitter changes. The nuke approach they've done will send so many of their important, core users off the site.
- judge2020 3y ago> Still, this could have been avoided by providing free-use keys to trusted developers. This approach mostly doesn't work because, for third-party client apps that don't go through the developer's own server, scrapers could snag those keys from the client. Scraping has always been a thing and I don't see a foolproof solution that allows good actors to use the product without bad actors getting to scrape content (not that scrapers won't settle for html scraping).
- moneywoes 3y agoHow would those api keys be exposed if it’s an app?
- anaganisk 3y agoWouldn't you leave the API key, in the server and proxy thru? That's what I was taught to do, and you give your own tokens to clients to track which client is making that request and block that client if needed. It seems very dangerous to pass on the reddit API key to the client.
- shmatt 3y agoThat small time developer who discussed paying millions also said it came out to $2.5/month on average[1]. Which actually isn't that bad for the service Reddit is providing One of the problems mentioned in the many Reddit threads discussing the issue about Apollo, is that its creator was selling ULTRA LIFETIME MEMBERSHIPS[2]. Yes, they were charging people money, taking it, then using a free API to deliver paying members their value. The developer now feels he cannot charge lifetime members an extra $2.5/month because he promised them he wouldn't Beyond the discussion of is Reddit about to die or not, selling LIFETIME access to someone elses free API is a dumb move, which will always end badly I think Reddit charging $2.5/month for API access is more than fair [1] https://www.theverge.com/2023/5/31/23743993/reddit-apollo-client-api-cost https://www.theverge.com/2023/5/31/23743993/reddit-apollo-cl... [2] https://www.reddit.com/r/apolloapp/comments/r3npbm/last_call_to_pick_up_apollo_ultra_lifetime_unlock/ https://www.reddit.com/r/apolloapp/comments/r3npbm/last_call...
- paxys 3y ago> I think Reddit charging $2.5/month for API access is more than fair That's my point though. Reddit is NOT charging $2.5/mo for API access. It is charging a set amount per app (based on overall usage), and the developer has to now be in the business of creating and charging for a whole new subscription themselves to make up for what they have to pay Reddit.
- anonred 3y agoWith the cost per request model, third party apps have more autonomy to dictate how much users pay per month.
- paxys 3y agoMajor third party developers are all unanimous in saying that they do not want this autonomy. This puts too much of a burden on them, and they have virtually zero time to make broad changes to their apps before getting hit with huge bills.
- jackson1442 3y ago
- chillbill 3y agoThe aim is not _just_ to make money, but to force users to use their crappy app so they can track users better. Sort of like what Twitter did. It’s also why they had like one dude working on their mobile website one hour a month for the last few years.
- wmurmann 3y agoWhat’s so crappy about it? I’ve seen some bad apps and it’s definitely not that bad. Can you elaborate?
- chillbill 3y agoEverything, similar to how crappy the new (now old) god awful and broken design. It’s not meant for users, but for advertisers. From abominable amount of tracking, to recommended community posts, to unnecessary avatars, to taking multiple clicks to view something, and on and on and on…
- 888666 3y agoThe reason why I dislike it is that, compared to 3rd party apps, it's slow and the design is overly busy. I prefer a more minimalistic design. The excessive tracking doesn't help.
- KptMarchewa 3y agoDoes it look remotely like this site? No? Then that's not the reddit experience I want.
- cragfar 3y agoThe app on iOS isn't too bad. It used to just light your data on fire though when reddit was trying to do streaming.
- Gareth321 3y agoThe design language follows all modern social media apps: engagement. Think TikTok. This means auto-playing videos, large elements instead of small elements (low information density) designed to draw attention, prioritising popular and contentious items in the feed instead of relevant items for the user, etc. This language is user-hostile. It uses psychological techniques to keep users on the platform for longer instead of presenting the information which they actually want. There are technical issues too. Many users report issues playing videos and gifs. Finally, the Reddit app serves ads.
- justapassenger 3y agoSource for people being happy to pay $50 per year? I’m not saying that Reddit handled it well. Buy your option doesn’t seem to be any better.
- anonred 3y agoReddit Premium costs more per month ($7) than the expected cost per user for the API ($2). If third party apps can’t make it work with the request-based pricing model, limiting access to just premium users isn’t going to work any better.
- wayne 3y agoFacebook's North America revenue is around $50 a quarter per user ("ARPU"), which is ~$15/month. You'd have to charge quite a bit to clear that, given most users won't pay. (Plus 30% to pay for App Store fees.) Reddit probably did the math and figured the churn was worth it to get everyone seeing ads. Facebook is much more optimized for ads, but optimizing Reddit's ads is probably easier than getting more people to pay. The latter would probably require paywalling more which is just as icky.
- paxys 3y agoThey are planning to charge third party apps ~$2.5/mo per user (aggregate amount based on average usage), so that is already quite a bit less.
- rtkwe 3y agoThat would still get a lot of backlash as a lot of users just aren't going to be willing to pay just to use a different app. Turning this around isn't so easy as you make it appear too it's still reddit effectively shutting out 3rd party apps.
- lcfcjs 3y ago[dead]
- graypegg 3y agoI mean, I think even still charging (a reasonable amount) for the public API, and in return bringing it up to near the standards of the Reddit-built app’s private API, and possibly allowing some ad revenue split with the large apps where by showing Reddit ads (currently impossible with the current API!) is compensated with some minute fraction off the API bill/paid to dev if no outstanding balance. Reddit won because it was the Digg-alternative, they’ve always been on shaky ground if people just start posting less. What ever per-impression value they get now on their own apps/website will plummet if people just start using it less, regardless if they’re making ad revenue off every user or only some users. Plus, yeah it’s an awesome LLM training resource. Make it cheap, why not? Your competitors are expensive, and your data is well indexed by topic and conversational in tone.
- exac 3y agoIt may be the case that they have foreseen the backlash, and they plan to publicly compromise with this as a solution.
- sleight42 3y agoAs an until-recently premium Redditor, exactly this. I voluntarily subscribed. I didn't derive value from subscribing. I just didn't want to be a freeloader since I enjoy the site so much. Because of Reddit's current practices, I've cancelled my premium membership. I'll likely move on from Reddit unless they chart a path where I and others can continue to use our third party clients happily.
- BeetleB 3y ago> I will never understand how Reddit bungled this so badly. Are we living in different universes? Less than 1% of Reddit users will be impacted by these changes. If all the people who are upset at this leave, it will have almost no impact to Reddit. A few niche subreddits may die, but that's it.
- lost_tourist 3y agoAs per the usual they should have chosen the middle way and forced reasonable charges for subscriptions for those people who want to use 3rd party aps $3-5 a month. Instead they now have a rebellion, that might turn into a movement to ditch reddit like people ditched digg. I'm not sure where they'd go though, I don't know of any platform out there that is similar to reddit that could handle a large influx.