3 ms·
> Musicians don't make money from streaming or CDs The main reason that's the case is due to record labels forcing musicians into bad deals, because they are o
by kelnos 3y ago
> Musicians don't make money from streaming or CDs
The main reason that's the case is due to record labels forcing musicians into bad deals, because they are often the gatekeepers to popularity. Some of the streaming platforms are better about this now, but the economics of streaming have been set by the record labels and the streaming companies, so even if it's a bad deal, independent artists just have to deal with it. This doesn't have to be the case, it's just where we've unfortunately ended up.
> they make it from live performances, performing at private events, endorsements, etc.
Sometimes musicians write songs that they don't perform themselves. They license the performance rights to others. Copyright enables that.
These things are aided by copyright, though, even if the songwriter and performer is the same person. If a musician writes a song, and doesn't have copyright to protect it, other musicians could perform it as well. Maybe people start liking another performer's rendition more, and the original songwriter doesn't get to make money at live performances anymore, and gets no royalties from other performances. You could argue that's just tough luck, I suppose, but I don't think that's particularly fair.
> My dad slaved away for years writing his books. He knew they'd never make money, he did it for the academic reputation.
That's just a reflection of the idea that the value in a copyrighted work isn't necessarily monetary. Presumably your dad used the reputation he gained from writing those books for some purpose that was valuable to him. Without copyright, someone could have taken his work and used it for their own gains. After a while, the original provenance of his work may have gotten muddied enough that he couldn't use that work to enhance his own reputation anymore.
> we give away all our work for free under the most permissible license we could find - the Boost license.
That's great, but not everyone wants to do that. Who are you to say that no one should be able to retain GPL-like control over their software if they want? Who are you to say that someone shouldn't be allowed to release something while prohibiting commercial use?
And hell, the Boost license is certainly not even the most permissible license available: it still requires that the copyright/license notice be included with any distributions or derived work. Copyright enables you to make that requirement. If you didn't want that requirement, then you could have released into the public domain (or licensed similarly to public domain, for jurisdictions that don't have that concept). You didn't do that, and your license relies on copyright in order to function.
I will be the first person to agree that we need heavy copyright reform. DMCA should be gutted if not completely repealed. Copyright term should be reduced (the only thing from TFA I agree with) to something on the order of 20 years, or perhaps something where you have a shorter term with the option to renew for another short term if the work ends up being important to you. There should be no criminal penalties for copyright infringement; all of it should be dealt with in civil court, and monetary penalties should be based on what the infringer gained, not some made-up number that the rightsholder "lost". Unfortunately these reforms are unlikely.
- WalterBright 3y agoMy original plan was to release it as Public Domain. I was informed, however, that there were legal problems with that, as some countries don't recognize Public Domain. It needed a copyright, and the license saying the copyright notice stays in it is part of it being copyrighted. > Who are you to say ... I made my career creating intellectual property. I'd say that entitles me to have an opinion on it as much as anyone. As to the songwriter who cannot perform, if I was a band that couldn't write hit songs, I'd pay him to write a hit song for me. As for other musicians playing the songs, I have a friend who is a major Beatles fan. I said once that I liked some of the covers of Beatles songs better than the Beatles version, and he about had apoplexy. People are always gonna wanna pay big bux to watch the Beatles perform their songs, just like if a painting's provenance proves it's a Rembrandt, an otherwise unremarkable painting would become worth $$$$millions$$$$. > the original provenance of his work may have gotten muddied enough that he couldn't use that work to enhance his own reputation anymore I'm not buying that. I've had people take my game Empire and claim they developed it more than once. I've been able to prove provenance each time. These days its pretty easy to prove with a github repository, which is a big reason why I'm a big github fan. Yes, other people have also claimed they developed my compilers.
- xigoi 3y ago> Who are you to say that no one should be able to retain GPL-like control over their software if they want? GPL exists to avoid free software being used to create proprietary software. If proprietary software didn't exist, what would be the point of GPL?