4 ms·
Ask HN: What are some popular books affected by replication crisis?
I was planning on reading "Thinking: Fast and Slow" after seeing it recommended here. I soon saw that some of the studies the book relies upon might be flawed. This made me wonder, what are some other popular titles that at least need a disclaimer?
- outdig 3y agowait, which study is flawed?
- jakabia 3y agoI'm also interested, I bought it too but haven't started to read it, I'd like to know those claimed flaws before diving into it.
- shubhamjain 3y agoOne of a the famous study quoted in the book is how hungry judges (working before the lunch) delivery harsher sentences. The study failed to account for vastly more plausible explanations like scheduling of cases [1]. [1]: https://inews.co.uk/news/do-judges-give-out-tougher-sentences-when-hungry-the-story-behind-a-study-too-good-to-be-true-2238347 https://inews.co.uk/news/do-judges-give-out-tougher-sentence...
- version_five 3y agoAll of those pop self help books need to be taken with a grain of salt and not assumed to add up. Every diet books falls in that category, books like that "wheat belly", Aitkens, whatever, it's all the same idea of cherry picking stuff to support a thesis. Born to run about barefoot running and the tara-humara Indians... Studies in context as a practitioner in the field may mean something, in a self help book and the like, they just are there to lend some legitimacy. Belive it or not, Michael Crichton's very well referenced "State of Fear" has even been called into question.
- bjourne 3y agoFreakonomics