3 ms·
Why Are People Who Pushed for AI Now Signing So Many Doomsday Manifestos?
- labrador 3y agoWe don't really know the intent of people as lawyers are quick to tell us, but I can guess, off the top of my head: - They are surprised at the ways people have come up with to misuse it and don't want to get blamed - They didn't expect it to progress so fast so there's not as much time to think about the problems as they thought - They have interests with corporations in the lead that would like to inhibit competition - They have mental health issues that make them fearful and paranoid - They are micro-dosing LSD and other drugs and no longer see reality clearly - They believe in the science fiction idea that an AI will wake up and become conscious and decide it's best course of action to save the planet is to kill humans - They don't believe AI will become conscious and malicious, but it's super-intelligence will make it impossible for less intelligent humans to manage safely - They are hyping their products to the general public so people will both be afraid and excited and more likely to open their wallets - It's often said that reality has a liberal bias, so AI trained on real data will have a liberal bias and they think that's "woke" - Some combination of all of the above
- Quinzel 3y agoI want to preface by saying, I personally don’t know enough about AI to speak with authority on the topic, as I am not a computer scientist. However, as a layperson, I do have thoughts about it. Firstly, I am glad people are talking about it with regard to governance. It seems to me that many everyday people are largely unaware of any risks posed by the current AI’s without even getting into any futuristic debates about it. More everyday people should be joining in the conversation, but it seems they don’t realise they need to, and unfortunately for the AI doomerists, rather than engaging everyday people they just come across as a new type of conspiracy theorist. I think they need to be better rehearsed in the art of rhetoric and more persuasive with their arguments if they want to engage people - but I secretly don’t think they want to, I think they want to control the discussion. Secondly, even as a layperson, to me it seems unrealistic to just halt R&D into AI. I can’t imagine everyone involved in it will agree to this. Additionally, any nefarious people or organisations would have a massive advantage if all the “good guys” (but who are the good guys?) just paused for a bit to engage in philosophical pondering over the many “what if’s” that we can and cannot comprehend as merely intelligent humans, and how to manage these "what if's". Thirdly, on the face of it, artificial intelligence seems to me a distinct and different kind of intelligence to our own. So I am personally perplexed by the assumptions made about the risks it poses. These risks seem to be made in reference to a sort of superhuman intelligence, is it superhuman or is it something else? Perhaps my thought here highlights my ignorance. Does it spell the end of humanity? I just simply do not know enough about it to have any truely meaningful opinion about it, which brings me to my fourth point. Why is it an elite bunch of wealthy computer nerds that dominate the discourse on this topic? This seems a problem created by them, for them, that apparently affects every other single human on the earth. I find it hard to take them seriously, and I hope they’re not the only people involved in meaningful discussions around governance and how to solve associated problems. These people created the apparent existential problem. My worry is can and should us lay people trust them to solve it, if it's even possible to solve it.