3 ms·
Many Watts means some combination of Amps and Volts - power is Amps times Volts. The main risks from each are different though. Simplified explanation for th
by londons_explore 3y ago
Many Watts means some combination of Amps and Volts - power is Amps times Volts.
The main risks from each are different though. Simplified explanation for the non-physicist:
Lots of Amps make wires get hot, make connections melt, etc. In general, thin wires (eg headphone wires) are good for 1 or 2 amps safely, and chunky wires (eg. AC cords) are good for 10 or 20 amps safely. The exact amount depends on how much cooling they get - which is why you should never put blankets over power cords. If you screw this up, the outcome is probably a fire, which maybe kills you.
Lots of volts causes electrocution. Thats because your skin is pretty decent at blocking electricity, but when you have enough volts, some can sneak through your skin, freezing up your muscles, stopping your heart which probably kills you.
So - amps and volts have totally different mechanisms of death. USB-C @ 100W is 20 volts at 4.5 amps. The voltage is well below dangerous levels, and the current is pretty safe in the cables specced, but I can totally imagine a few fires.
It's worth noting that about 10x as many people die from amps (electrical fires) than volts (direct electrocution).
- londons_explore 3y agoBy the way... The USB-C standard goes up to 240 Watts. Thats 48 volts (fairly safe IMO) at 5 amps (only marginally safe IMO, on that connector design). There are laws in many countries capping voltages, but not on currents - which is why the standard is pushing the safety envelope there! The standard has no way to detect damaged cables (ie. baby chewing through the cable), nor connections getting hot (ie. an old dirty connection heating up and catching fire). But I suspect a future revision will allow both more volts and more amps, and will add those safety features - I'm hoping on the next version being 500 volts and 8 amps, allowing it to replace all household outlets.
- cduzz 3y agoHopefully they come with auto-update firmware where if I plug a gen 15 cable into a gen 14 device and a gen 12 local power delivery unit the cpu in the cable will update the key in the PDU and get key material from the device to ensure that everyone's up-to-date on their licenses.
- endgame 3y agoThat would enable a new generation of USB worms.
- cduzz 3y ago"It would unleash an entire new generation of recurring revenue generation opportunities as innovators could develop exciting new technologies and industry leadership while protecting intellectual property rights holders" "blah blah blah worm security blah blah" -- same sentence different language. (and -- I'm entirely trying to be tongue-in-cheek -- the notion of little dynamically updated microcontrollers everywhere in my house, getting bricked or asking me for a micropayment to turn a light on is a pkd story come to life)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoEloquent that, thanks.
- ilyt 3y ago> The standard has no way to detect damaged cables Of course it does. All it needs is to ask the other device what voltage is on the other side, calculate resistance off it and trip or drop to lower power mode if it deems that there is too much power lost in the cable. Still not perfectly safe as say 3W lost over whole cable is far less dangerous than this 3W loss focused solely on dodgy connection but still.
- Kirby64 3y agoWhat part of the standard mandates, or even optionally supports that? Standard USB-PD only requires that you negotiate a voltage and current suitable for both sides (among a preset list). It essentially goes open loop after that; you can't exceed the current limit set, but beyond potentially tripping the PD controller (on the sink side) if the voltage drops too low, there's not really any protection here. It's fully on the PD sink to implement (or, not implement) any sort of protections like that.
- Eisenstein 3y agoI think the parent was saying that it could be done, not that it is being done.
- ilyt 3y ago> What part of the standard mandates, or even optionally supports that? None, which is the fucking problem. Cheap cable can just lie about it's current capacity.
- redox99 3y ago> USB-C @ 100W is 20 volts at 4.5 amps Clearly one of those numbers is wrong
- Eisenstein 3y agoIt is 5A. * https://imgur.com/a/mjF0coQ https://imgur.com/a/mjF0coQ
- themerone 3y agoI got a pinprick sized 3rd degree burn from the end of a micro usb charging cable. It was more startling than dangerous, but I now have a little more respect for low powered devices, especially when plugged into mains.