3 ms·
> For example, if you want to cultivate a more positive attitude about big changes in your company, lunch more often with those who are leading the charge and l
by neilv 3y ago
> For example, if you want to cultivate a more positive attitude about big changes in your company, lunch more often with those who are leading the charge and less often with those who are forming the opposition.
Sounds like very familiar best-practices advice for the stereotypical corporate boot-licking yes-person.
Speaking of framing, as the article does, the writer seems to be implicitly framing failures to being the best manipulative, sharp-elbowed status climber you can be... as "bad habits".
- agumonkey 3y agoReminds me of books about knowing how to have power over people. Inversion of values to me to think that manipulating people is grand.
- helmholtz 3y agoThat book is life changing, if it's 'How To Win Friends'. Maybe for an older person, this stuff is trivial, but for a younger me, it taught me just how much we as a species think only of ourselves, how you can never win an argument, how you cannot browbeat someone into submission. You can at best hope to make the other person want to do something. Look at things from their perspective. Stephen Covey seemed to hate Carnegie's book too, as if the book was written by a moustache-twirling supervillain. It's not. It's just a very lovely look into human psyche, beautifully illustrated by tonnes of examples (rather than the platitude-filled bullshit that is inside modern books by Ryan Holiday and company).
- agumonkey 3y agoMaybe I was too biased when I skimmed through it. I understand that people all have complex psychologies and being aware of the recurrent traits is useful. But to me it lacks real warmth.. I'll try reading it again.
- NikolaNovak 3y agoMy initial attitude toward that section was similar. But in the spirit of doing a charitable interpretation - in every company there are those who want to do good and make a change. And there are those who just want to say No to everything. Just everything. Just no. There are always ten million reasons to not do anything new and just keep being the same. And the article is suggesting that if you spend more time with those who want to change things you will adopt their attitude by osmosis. Doesn't say anything whether any given change is a good one. If you are an alcoholic, being around people who drink a lot is not helping you. I choose to interpret that paragraph to mean you shoild be around people with attitude you want to adopt. More broadly I see articles main point to be adopting a systemic approach. Don't think hope or try to magically make yourself "a better person who doesn't do bad things ". Rather come up with systems and methods to enforce behaviour you want in yourself.
- neilv 3y agoIMHO, charitable interpretation is for HN comments. With HBR, it might be better to see what they're pushing today, and guessing how that affects people who read it seriously. (Though it's often just filler or brand-promotion content that's innocuous, AFAICT.) If you can also salvage good ideas by considering the content at face value, that's a bonus, but don't let that compromise your critical thinking.
- karmakaze 3y agoThat's a great way to read it to get the most useful value. I find using ChatGPT to be similar in that if you add/fix the bits it's missing or gets wrong it can be a good time-saver and useful.
- gtirloni 3y agoIf I'm a lowly IC leading a project to improve code reviews, are those interested in my work "bootlickers"? Notice the article didn't say managers, you're assuming it.
- neilv 3y agoI think that's not what this is talking about, or not the message that I expect the writer's target audience to take home. Is there actually a faction opposed to improving code reviews? Or are you on your way up, and savvy operators should get with your program, and hitch their wagon to you, including at lunchtime?
- gtirloni 3y agoYes, that's what you think but I don't see words in the article saying that.
- larperdoodle 3y agoNo faction opposing the goal, but certainly factions who disagree on whether any particular proposed change is actually an improvement
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]