3 ms·
So you can get information from multiple well researched sources. This is one of them. Don't expect anyone to do all the work. "You're not publishing full inve
by viraptor 3y ago
So you can get information from multiple well researched sources. This is one of them. Don't expect anyone to do all the work.
"You're not publishing full investigative journalism articles on absolutely everything." is not a valid criticism of your article, or a reasonable criticism of the publisher.
- zmgsabst 3y ago[flagged]
- emodendroket 3y agoI mean that's just plain false. Think of how much time any one meaty investigative report takes; nobody has the time or resources to then turn around and carefully make sure they do some sort of counterbalancing expose that's somehow pro-industry (and what's the point of an expose? They employ many PR people for that purpose anyway).
- peter422 3y agoYou don't need to take their comment seriously... After all they didn't make the counterargument and therefore it's a overly biased point and thus not useful in any way.
- ImPostingOnHN 3y ago> You’re not engaged in journalism if you only investigate and present a narrative which aligns with your policy preferences. where did you hear this silly rule? It sounds like something a child would make up when they don't want to hear something >they don’t overtly lie or fabricate data to support their case... that’s true of many propaganda outfits. another thing which is true of "many" propaganda outlets is they don't literally give you cancer, and that is an observation exactly as discerning as yours, because they are both also true of "many" truthful media outlets if you have an issue with the specific article, or the facts alleged within, that's one thing, but the facts not reflecting well on your viewpoint and you being upset they aren't reporting other things which would make you feel better, is not a criticism of them
- rtpg 3y agoI mean in that case there is nobody engaged in journalism! You choose what you cover, and who you interview, and how much you spend hemming on a source's claims, etc etc etc. It's a lot easier to think about journalism as the result of human output that is indeed biased towards certain ideas, and to then read from various things, look into things yourself, or reading things from outlets that you believe have your interests at heart. Expecting one group to collect all the info and present a pro/con list is gonna be very hard, but if you just check out a handful of outfit's coverage on something you might get a good enough picture to apply some judgement.
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agothe actual secret is that this misguided line of reasoning is unfortunately abused by those who wish to suppress arbitrary journalism they dislike, or the concept of professional journalism in general, because as you say, such criticism would mean journalism doesn't actually exist
- haberman 3y agoThis is a motte and bailey argument. The motte: nobody is perfectly neutral, so no journalism can be perfectly objective. (true) The bailey: it is normal and reasonable for journalists to present a biased narrative without even attempting to find or mention relevant information that would contradict it. (false) Objectivity is an ideal that, while impossible to perfectly achieve, can certainly be done better or worse, and is important for journalists to think about if they want the trust of the public.
- emodendroket 3y agoI only really see this as a relevant objection if the "omitted" information is such that it distorts what is actually presented. Is that the accusation? Or are they "biased" because they didn't publish this next to a counterpoint about how wonderful internal combustion engines are?
- zmgsabst 3y ago
- jliptzin 3y agoThat's why as an individual you're supposed to get your news from multiple high quality sources, each with their own biases and slants, and then you make your own conclusion. I realize most people only want to read news that supports their already held beliefs though.
- civilized 3y agoYes, this type of criticism is baffling and, frankly, a bit morally outrageous. ProPublica can't be expected to do all the work of uncovering all sides of the truth. They already do the hardest work: uncovering what the powerful would rather that we not know. They do enough; what are the rest of us doing? I would agree that it's historically been uncommon for the media to give balanced perspective on civilizational progress, but some good sources for this have emerged in recent years. One of my favorites is Works in Progress magazine: https://worksinprogress.co/ https://worksinprogress.co/