8 ms·
Atomic Wallet exploited, users report loss of entire portfolios
- paulpauper 3y agoYet again, we see that just because you can be your bank , doesn't mean you should. These 'safe', ' audited' programs, protocols, wallets keep failing. The introduction of irrevocable bounties creates a huge incentive to find bugs. The so-called self-funded bug bounty. Never trust a 3rd party to do your crypto.
- chrsig 3y ago> Never trust a 3rd party to do your crypto. This strikes me as funny because software engineers are regularly told not to roll their own crypto.
- wolongong942 3y agoThe CEO is a huge scammer and at least one audit said atomic wallet was very insecure.
- rkagerer 3y agoNot doubting you but could we get sources for that? (Genuinely interested in some of the key highlights from that audit)
- not_your_vase 3y agoWell, being audited means only that it is audited. Nobody forces the company/developers to act upon the findings of the audit... but still, technically it is true that they were audited even if the outcome of the audit was "haha, I wouldn't trust my used hanky on this"
- gregjor 3y agoSlot machine gives house the edge, users report loss of entire portfolios.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gigatexal 3y agoAhh the schadenfruede is strong for me with this one. Silly cryptocurrency fans. When will they learn?
- lyu07282 3y agoPerhaps now the only people left are scammers, scamming each other in an infinite loop.
- qingcharles 3y agoIt's scammers all the way down!
- throwing_away 3y agoThese are the stories of people learning.
- fron 3y agoHow many times does this have to happen before people learn that cryptocurrency is not a good place to park money?
- paulpauper 3y agothe level of technical savvy to store crypto safely makes it impractical for the general population
- HlessClaudesman 3y agoAKA:too many crocodiles at the watering hole.
- spaceman_2020 3y agoAnd god forbid if you accidentally transfer your crypto from one incomprehensible address to another.
- lfkdev 3y ago? It is literally uncountable how many times the big banks stole money from regular people. Crypto indeed is a good place to store money.
- j16sdiz 3y agoWhen this happens with big bank, you could try going to the court. When this happens to crypto, you got nobody to blame but yourself.
- scotty79 3y ago> When this happens with big bank, you could try going to the court. Great. So not only I lost my money but now I'm getting an assignment as well. Which will last many years and at best will result in recovering a fraction of what I lost and the most likely outcome us not getting anything back and possibly paying more.
- 3y ago
- TimJRobinson 3y ago[flagged]
- thorncorona 3y ago> Is there anything intellectually interesting about this article? Just seems to be posted for anti crypto folks to feel better about themselves? Perhaps that it’s news? “Atomic Wallet has been apparently exploited, with users on Twitter reporting complete losses of their crypto portfolios.”
- oxygen_crisis 3y ago> Perhaps that it’s news? Is it? This looks like rumor-mongering based on a couple tweets. "Several users on Twitter" "A number of users have commented on the post reporting losses" There is one firsthand tweet from someone saying he lost funds this week, one from someone who says he lost funds six months ago, and one from the wallet developer saying "We have received reports of wallets being compromised". Are we talking a hundred, or are we talking five? As far as the sources go, we have two in six months. How, exactly, do they come up with an adjective like "several" for this? I'm as anti-cryptobro as the next guy, but let's put on our critical thinking caps for a minute. Where's the indication that something newsworthy happened here?
- TimJRobinson 3y agoIf I posted an article about some people got rich off crypto is that also worthwhile because it's "news"? No, if there's no intellectual discussion and it's just cheap 10 second takes then it's not suited for HN. From the guidelines: > On-Topic: Anything that good hackers would find interesting. That includes more than hacking and startups. If you had to reduce it to a sentence, the answer might be: anything that gratifies one's intellectual curiosity. > Off-Topic: If they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic. This is a very shallow news story that gives no information on the technical nature of the hack or anything intellectual in the slightest. As can be seen by the comments on this thread almost everything is low-brow commentary similar to what you'd see on a Facebook news story. If people want to discuss crypto security and the merits of different approaches that would be an awesome discussion to have. Unfortunately it can't happen here any more because the only crypto related things that get upvoted are news stories about bad things happening and the more that happens the more intellectually curious people are driven away.
- 29athrowaway 3y agoRepeat with me: Not your keys, not your coins.
- buildbuildbuild 3y agoThis is a self-custodied light wallet, keys were on user devices. It could have been a weak RNG or due to client side malware, it’s too early to tell.
- friend_and_foe 3y agoI'm curious about what happened too. Non custodial? Then how? Was the application FOSS? If not, I'd guess they were collecting some kind of data they shouldn't have been.
- scotty79 3y agoIt's an app on a phone. It's only as self custodied as your front porch is. With entirety of the internet as your neighborhood.
- lxgr 3y agoAre you implying that the compromise happened due to an OS or app store level exploit/vulnerability? If not, I don’t see how an app on a phone is worse than on a desktop.
- paulpauper 3y agostill no update about how it was done surely they would have some idea
- tiku 3y agoThere should be a trail. If the funds are just gone it could be a glitch in Atomic.
- anonzzzies 3y agoIt seems, but I might be wrong (others suggested it though) that you need the app to be compromised to do this. A server hack wouldn’t work because you still need your key/seed phrase. The app, with a hack, of course can, next to unlocking your wallets locally, send it to a server (which should never happen) and then the owner of that server can take the funds. To me this seems the most obvious. Use open source wallets, reproducible builds, hashes and, of course, cold wallets. Also, divide; don’t put your money in one place; I would say that goes for banks too.
- spaceman_2020 3y agoThe general rule of the thumb in crypto is that everything will get exploited. Its a matter of “when”, not “if”. I wouldn’t even trust Metamask in the long run. If the wallet doesn’t get exploited, something that interacts with the wallet will. If crypto ever becomes a bigger market, you’ll eventually have state actors trying to exploit protocols and wallets, and they’ll be more sophisticated than the North Korean hackers.
- ETH_start 3y agoCrypto is just totally ruthless with software exploits. Any software exploit leads to millions of dollars worth of assets being stolen, by whoever found the exploit.
- scotty79 3y agoThat's the cost of having something actually valuable on you actual device.
- tourmalinetaco 3y agoExactly. If a million people have $5 on their device, and it gets exploited, that’s up to $5 million in payout.
- yashg 3y agoJust another day in the cryptoverse. Charlatans duping poor suckers by selling libertarian dreams.