9 ms·
> This, or something like it, is the future: the computing device is portable, and adapts itself to the forms of input available Maybe it is, but it's not the
by bambax 15y ago
> This, or something like it, is the future: the computing device is portable, and adapts itself to the forms of input available
Maybe it is, but it's not the future I'd like best.
I would like to have a desktop in the cloud, and data in the cloud, and nothing in my pocket; nothing to lose or break or have to make sure it still has juice.
When I get somewhere to work (a client's, a café, a friend's, etc.), I log in to my cloud desktop using whatever dumb machine is available, and off I go. Everything I do is automatically saved, backed up, versioned, synchronized for me.
A portable computer is useful in the subway, but at the office? What benefits do we stand to gain from still having things run or be stored on a local machine?
- j05h 15y agoControl, security, trust. Even if I got rid of all other computers, I'd still have a phone. More and more I want to fully control my data on my terms. Maybe I'd be fine paying a service (linode?) to host my fully encrypted data in the cloud, but Google? Facebook? No thanks.
- epscylonb 15y agoIf consumer networks were as reliable as roads and the electricity grid, why would I bother giving my data to someone so they can put it in a datacenter?. The future I would like best is a device on the end of my home internet connection. I could authenticate myself to other online services against it. It could be a node in a social network (much like diaspora) where I can control all my own data. It could have access to a NAS at home, allowing me to stream my favourite music and movies to wherever I happen to be. In the future, with resilient enough networks, the datacenter will be distributed.
- phaer 15y agoYou described exactly what the people at http://www.freedomboxfoundation.org/ http://www.freedomboxfoundation.org/ are trying to do. It's still in an early state of development but you may join the mailinglist or read the wiki ( http://wiki.debian.org/FreedomBox http://wiki.debian.org/FreedomBox ) if you are interested in this topic.
- alexchamberlain 15y agoThis is a great hardware startup. Sell rack boxes that can be installed by an electrician next to the power in/telephone in and get rid of those under featured consumer routers. Hmmmmmm.... I'll sell you one for £500 a year, replaced regularly and managed?
- epscylonb 15y agoI was thinking more of a Raspberry Pi, though obviously combining this device with the router does make sense.
- alexchamberlain 15y agoSeriously? Why not combine into the NAS?
- epscylonb 15y agoI could see a NAS needing to be upgraded more often than this device. If the software and feature set were stable and mature enough then I can't see you needing to upgrade it very often.
- freehunter 15y agoWhy not carry the dumb terminal in your pocket and drop it into a monitor and charging station at a client's, a cafe, a friend's, etc? That way you have local access to things that should be local (I don't always have Internet access on my phone here in Michigan, but I still want to listen to music), but cloud access as well? Phones are pretty well tied to the Internet these days anyway. These two futures don't have to be mutually exclusive, and I'd argue we'll see them both on the same device at the same time.
- rickmb 15y agoIf you think your data "in the cloud" (which is just a way of saying "on other people's physical systems") is safe from theft, breakage or some foreign government agency pulling the plug, you haven't been paying much attention to reality lately. And by "lately" I mean the past decade. Don't get me wrong, I like the convenience of "the cloud". It's especially helpful in synchronizing all the data that I have on cheap and abundant storage on various devices. We can have both. Why advocate giving up the one option that makes you independent from third party interference (or simply a lack of connectivity)?
- Lewisham 15y agoBackup device manufaturers are really missing out on big bucks by not making a small NAS that downloads all you cloud data. Give it access to Google/Dropbox/Flickr etc an have it silently back everything up. I hope they've thought of this and I've just missed it. They won't be able to sell USB based backup drives for much longer.
- nodemaker 15y agoThe device 'Time Machine' by Apple does exactly that.
- Lewisham 15y agoNo it doesn't, it backsup your Macs over wifi, and that's all it does. It won't access web services, which is they key point I was trying to make. The Time Capsule, and all home backup devices I can name, make the soon-to-be-outdated assumption that your data exists on a hard drive you own.
- nodemaker 15y agoWell more elaborately your mac can access all web services and download all data which can then be wirelessly backed up by the time machine. For example my Dropbox folder is automatically synced on my mac which is then automatically backed up by the time machine.
- __alexs 15y ago> What benefits do we stand to gain from still having things run or be stored on a local machine? Security.
- rplnt 15y agoDo you store all your money at home or do you have some in bank? There's no reason why some big entity couldn't guarantee that the data you put in will get back to you whatever happens to company holding your data. If you mean security as in privacy, then there are cryptographically safe methods on preventing that.
- mikaelgramont 15y agoIf somebody steals your money from a bank, the bank can replace it. If somebody steals your data from the cloud, there's no way to make things ok.
- rplnt 15y agoIt doesn't matter that someone have a copy of your properly encrypted data.
- rosser 15y agoEven with strong crypto, if you're typing in your passphrase on a "dumb" machine that someone else owns and controls, you're risking the entirety of your security on how trustworthy (and security-competent) the owner of that machine is. No thanks.
- agrover 15y agotwo-factor auth helps?
- rplnt 15y agoYou could have a token that would work exactly as credit card. Only one token would be authorized. You cannot copy it so if you lose it, you know you lost it can be "disabled". You would then need a new one with the same key however. That key could be stored in real bank's deposit box. Hardware of the token would only allow to store the key and not read it. I mean, that's a possibility for the paranoid ones who are not happy with cell phone auth for example. I know there's no infrastructure in place (yet) but we're talking about some kind of future, not about today. It's certainly possible though. Even secured.
- javajosh 15y ago> I log in to my cloud desktop using whatever dumb machine is available, and off I go. Unfortunately there is no way to verify that that machine is actually "dumb". Fundamentally this is because modern computation and storage are microscopic phenomena. Even today we take it as an act of faith that our freshly produced electronics only do what the manufacturers say - and this is an ongoing problem for US defense contractors that outsource component manufacture to China. This problem is also experienced by travelers who expect a "dumb browser" at the internet cafe, when in fact they are being key logged. > What benefits do we stand to gain from still having things run or be stored on a local machine? There are a few, such as statefulness that is maintained even without network connectivity. But the big one is that, presumably, "your" device is more trustworthy than a dumb terminal because, at the very least, you haven't acted to subvert your own security (although even this is often not the case).
- verelo 15y agoWhats to say the data isnt in the cloud? I expect that the future of computing has a few layers. 1. Device (basically CPU) - this could be your phone or something similar 2. Storage local cache on your "Device" but sync'd with the cloud in case of it getting lost or damaged 3. Input. Lets face it, we all enjoy a good keyboard and mouse...if you're on the go touch screen does the job but I'll never write a document from one (unless I am super desperate)
- enormousfaggot 15y ago>I would like to have a desktop in the cloud, and data in the cloud You would sacrifice your freedom and privacy for a (dubious) convenience? >What benefits do we stand to gain from still having things run or be stored on a local machine? So that you won't be in paralysis when internet is unavailable?
- pfraze 15y agoI'm experimenting with that, actually: https://github.com/pfraze/link https://github.com/pfraze/link
- gbog 15y agoAlmost every answer emphasizes security, but what about convenience? Where is your dumb terminal when you climb in the Alps and wish too take a short at Mount Blank? In a taxi will you have to log in a machine before checking your friend'a address? Where is your dumb terminal in the washroom (probably the place where smartphones are most used)?
- bambax 15y agoIn those cases you don't have a big display or a dock either; you just use your phone and that's fine. What I'm questioning is the value of a dock+display to access your phone versus a "cloud" device that can be accessed from anywhere (including your phone).