4 ms·
Why shouldn’t mods be able to run their communities the way they want? It’s not like you can’t open a competing /r/newsButNotModeratedVeryMuch.
by ceejayoz 3y ago
Why shouldn’t mods be able to run their communities the way they want? It’s not like you can’t open a competing /r/newsButNotModeratedVeryMuch.
- tayo42 3y agoThe same reason every make your Twitter fails, the people are already there.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- krono 3y agoThey are servants of those communities, not their owners. Or at least that's how things used to be.
- ink_13 3y agoThis is a romantic view but completely false. Reddit admins over the years have always completely backed the view that subs belong to their moderators.
- Mindwipe 3y agoBecause /r/news has a massive, massive advantage over /r/newsButNotModeratedVeryMuch. If there were multiple /r/news pages and none were a default that might work, but that has always been Reddit's big structural weakness.
- pphysch 3y ago/r/newsButNotModeratedVeryMuch might as well be a different website. The thing about Reddit is that it's "the front page of the internet", and the "front page" has been captured by special interests in collaboration with Reddit, Inc.
- olalonde 3y agoOne problem is subreddit names. People who want to discuss bitcoin will head to /r/bitcoin, world news to /r/worldnews, etc.
- chx 3y agoThat happens occasionally but it's rarely successful. /r/onguardforthee/ has ~270K users, /r/Canada has 1.76M. That counts as a success. Most similar replacements never got off the ground.
- _Algernon_ 3y agoNetwork effects exist and constitute a massive moat for new entrants, both within platforms and between platforms.
- gettodachoppa 3y agoOften things go like this: 1. Niche refreshing or funny subreddit becomes popular. Power mods request to join the mod team, are rejected by the mods of the sub, who are just normal people like you and me. 2. It hits 100k users, becoming subject to more stringent rules from the admins 3. Incestuous relationship between powermods/astroturfers/reddit admins is used to get the original mod banned (at least accused of "allowing hateful content" or some other false flag) 4. Powermods take over the sub, keep some old mods, but ban anyone speaking up 5. The subreddit is now under the full control of powermods, and becomes an astroturfed echo chamber like the rest of the reddit front page. Sub's front page becomes a mix between the original content and the marketing page for ShareBlue-like organizations.